Are conspiracy theories 'explanations' for real problems?
Torsten Landsberg db
June 21, 2019
How do conspiracy theories take hold, and why are these "alternative facts" so hard to counter? American cultural historian Michael Butter explains that conspiracies also reflect deeper societal insecurities.
Advertisement
Conspiracy theories and their origins: From the Freemasons to the Twin Towers
Are plane 'chemtrails' poisoning us all; and who was really behind 9/11? An exhibition titled 'Conspiracy theories — then and now' at the Dalheim Monastery shows how such beliefs emerge and are maintained.
Image: LWL/www.hoffmannfoto.de
9/11: Inside job?
Who was really behind the 9/11 terrorist attacks on New York? Was it the US government, meaning the Twin Towers were subject to a controlled explosion? Was it a Jewish conspiracy, with some claiming that Jews did not go to work in the World Trade Center that day? An exhibition titled "Conspiracy theories — then and now" at the Dalheim Monastery shows how such beliefs emerge and are maintained.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Anti-Semitic propaganda
In the so-called "Protocols of the Elders of Zion," 12 Jewish leaders allegedly layed out their plans to conquer the world in writing. In reality, the 1903 document (pictured here in the exhibition at the Dalheim Monastery) is a work of fiction by Sergej Nilus, an anti-Semitic Russian writer and publisher. The protocols are a central part of modern day anti-Semitic conspiracy theories.
Image: LWL/www.hoffmannfoto.de
Nazi conspiracy-fueled ideology
The idea of a Jewish conspiracy was also a central part of Nazi ideology. The Nazis spread alleged revelations gleaned from the fake Protocols of the Elders of Zion for their own purposes, reprinting them in their weekly "Der Stürmer" (The Attacker) propaganda newspaper.
Image: Deutsches Historisches Museum/S.Ahlers
Fear of negative energy
People who believe in the barcode conspiracy probably have a special pen in their pockets when they approach a checkout counter to neutralize what they believe is negative energy radiating from the barcode. The barcode information supposedly aims to reduce the world population. Some companies even go so far as to print a line through the barcode to keep their customers happy.
Image: LWL/www.hoffmannfoto.de
Secret societies
Those seeking to explain major political events and revolutions have often invoked grand conspiracies. In the wake of the 1789 French Revolution, secret societies such as the Freemasons and Illuminati were seen as the all-powerful rabble-rousers. Pictured is an Illuminati Minerval class medal currently on show at the "Conspiracy Theory - Past and Present" exhibit that runs through March 22, 2030.
Image: LWL/www.hoffmannfoto.de
5 images1 | 5
German Chancellor Angela Merkel is Adolf Hitler's daughter; airplane vapor trails in the sky contain chemical substances designed to sedate people and control their minds; and the CIA is behind the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the US. These are among some well-worn conspiracy theories that many throughout the world take as gospel. Michael Butter, who teaches American literary and cultural history at Tübingen University, told DW why such theories are so popular; and why it's so difficult to debunk them.
DW: Conspiracy theories can be amusing — Elvis is alive and well on some out-of-the-way island; or ridiculous, like saying Angela Merkel is an alien. When are they concerning?
Michael Butter: Even a conspiracy theory that seems harmless at first sight can be problematic — for instance, if someone believes that Angela Merkel is an alien and thinks they must do something about it. In general, they are not harmless when they are target minorities like refugees, or historically, Jews. Conspiracy theories can endanger our democratic coexistence.
Is that because people increasingly mistrust politicians?
If people assume our politicians are all in cahoots and that it makes no difference whatsoever who they vote for because politicians are all puppets of a conspiracy anyway, they will either turn their backs on politics and refuse to participate at all — or they will vote for parties that present themselves as alternatives to the established parties. In recent years, in the West and beyond, that would have been for the most part right-wing populist parties. In the end, they don't really contribute to solving the problems, either.
If you look at the growing gap between poor and rich, you could get the impression that something is wrong with our political system. Does that boost conspiracy theories?
Most certainly. Conspiracy theories are not only the domain of paranoid nutcases. Many rational people believe in conspiracy theories because they seek explanations for real problems. In the vast majority of cases, they have to be taken seriously because they are a symptom and point out issues people are concerned about.
While conspiracy theories are often discredited today, they were once mainstream, especially during the age of the Enlightenment?
During that era in particular, people sought out non-religious patterns to explain the world. The logic of the Enlightenment says that cause and effect must be clear. The outcome is a worldview that supports the belief in conspiracy theories, even among the educated people of that era.
Why are conspiracy theorists so resistant to facts?
US studies show that convinced conspiracy theorists believe even more strongly in their conspiracy theories after they are confronted with conclusive counterevidence. Conspiracy theories are extremely important for the identity of people who believe in them — everything follows hand in hand, there's no coincidence. Belief in and spreading conspiracy theories makes people feel they stand out from the crowd.
Even developments most people would rate as self-evident, like gender equality, are an issue for conspiracy theorists. Is reality too liberal for these people?
Conspiracy theories often have a strong conservative impetus in the sense that they are should preserve a threatened order or return an order abolished by the alleged conspirators. Populism along the lines of "Make America Great Again" is similar. Conspiracy theorists as well as populists are driven by a nostalgia for the past.
Are conspiracies ultimately a function of ambiguity and political complexity?
For some people, it is easier to accept that the bad guys pull the strings in the background than to accept that there is no one pulling the strings in the background. Conspiracy theories often simplify by reducing the political field to the conspirators and the others.
Michael Butter is Professor of American Literature and Cultural History at the University of Tübingen. He researches conspiracy theories, leads an EU research project on their analysis and is the author of the book "Nothing Is As It Seems: About Conspiracy Theories."
Hollywood's political conspiracies
Conspiracies about US politics abound - especially when it comes to Russia, the FBI and the president. While there's no shortage of Hollywood films on the matter, here are some of the most memorable.
Image: Imago/United Archives
JFK (1991)
The assassination of US President John F. Kennedy has been the subject of conspiracy theories since the moment it took place on November 22, 1963, at the height of the Cold War. While many movies have tackled those theories, this one by Oliver Stone, which considers an alternative conclusion to the FBI's official story of a lone assassination, drew in more than $40 million in box office receipts.
Image: Imago/United Archives
Nixon (1995)
Perhaps the largest scandal in US history, the Watergate affair that took down President Richard Nixon is captured in Oliver Stone's biographical picture, "Nixon." How could a break-in at an office building in 1972 lead to the US President's impeachment? Through the FBI's investigation, the president's role in the burglary and a tape-recording system in his offices was uncovered.
Image: Imago
All the President's Men (1976)
This political thriller is based on the book written by the two "Washington Post" reporters, Bob Woodward (Robert Redford, right) and Carl Bernstein (Dustin Hoffman (left), who uncovered President Nixon's role in the Watergate scandal. Their reporting, based on information from an FBI informant they referred to as Deep Throat, led to Nixon's resignation in 1974.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Thunderheart (1992)
Based on the true story of a 1975 shootout that killed a tribal council member on South Dakota's Pine Ridge Reservation, "Thunderheart" dramatizes the story of a man with Sioux Indian roots, Ray Levoi (Val Kilmer), who moves to the reservation to investigate. Over the course of the investigation, the agent begins to reject the tactics of his fellow FBI agents.
Image: Imago/Entertainment Pictures
The Manchurian Candidate (2004)
Frank Sinatra stars in the 1962 original, "The Manchurian Candidate," in which a former POW is brainwashed into becoming an international assassin. The 2004 remake, featuring Denzel Washington, put a contemporary twist on the plot by setting the film during the Gulf War. The thriller takes on a major political tone as it questions the role of fictional corporations in US politics.
Image: Imago/Entertainment Pictures
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (2011)
The Cold War has long proved a fertile backdrop for Hollywood. Based on a John le Carré novel, the 2011 thriller is set in London in the early 1970s and follows a retired spy in his search to uncover a Soviet agent who has infiltrated the British spy services, MI6. The espionage film stars Gary Oldman (left) and John Hurt (right).
Image: picture-alliance/Zumapress/face to face
Wag the Dog (1997)
Taking a more humorous approach to scandalous politics is "Wag the Dog," with Dustin Hoffman (l.) as a spin doctor who concocts a war with Albania in order to save the fictional US President, Robert De Niro (r.), from a sex scandal. The ploy is uncovered by William H. Macy, a suspicious FBI agent. Released in 1997, the film was seen as a tragic commentary on the role the media plays in politics.
Image: Imago/United Archives
Canadian Bacon (1995)
Director Michael Moore is known for his outspoken politics. In the 1995 comedy, "Canadian Bacon," he imagines what would happen if the US invaded Canada. The biting message has that the US President has done so to boost the economy and his own approval rating. It was the last movie released with John Candy (right) in a starring role.