Austria debates bike trailers after two children die
Rebecca Staudenmaier
August 7, 2019
The debate on traffic safety broke out after two children died when a car hit the bike trailer they were riding in. The far-right is mulling a ban, while others say more limits are needed for cars — not for bicycles.
Advertisement
Following the tragic deaths of two young children in a traffic accident, Austrian politicians are locked in a debate with bicycle advocates over safety measures for children on bikes.
A 1-year-old and a 4-year-old died on Monday in a town outside of Vienna after a car hit the bike trailer that they were traveling in. The 39-year-old mother who was pulling the children behind her electric bike was also injured.
Police said that the trailer was sent flying 15 meters (49 feet) into a nearby field and that the cause of the accident was still unclear.
Both the mother and the 60-year-old driver of the car are being investigated on suspicion of involuntary manslaughter, reported Austrian newspaper Der Standard.
Austrian authorities said they are still working to determine whether the trailer was properly lit and that neither child was wearing a helmet.
E-Bikes and co: How eco-friendly is electromobility?
E-scooters, hoverboards or e-bikes — if you want to enjoy the outdoors without having to work too hard, there are plenty of options. But are electric modes of transportation good for us and the environment?
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Old-school biking
Until recently, the classic old bicycle would have been an obvious option for anyone wanting to get active outdoors. These days, however, there are a number of electric alternatives that require slightly less exertion. But e-bikes and e-scooters aren't always as eco-friendly as you might think, and can cause other problems too.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/S. Kahnert
The electro-classic
The e-bike, an enhanced bicycle if you will, is probably the best-known electric alternative to regular bikes. The battery motor makes it move faster and is especially helpful on inclines. One problem: Because it makes biking less exhausting, more seniors who would normally not head out into the traffic anymore, ride e-bikes. That has lead to an increase in accidents.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/T. Hase
The battery problem
Another issue with e-bikes is the battery, the production of which requires a lot of natural resources. E-bikes run on rechargeable lithium batteries. Digging this metal out of the earth is no easy feat and requires large lithium mines. It's also a finite resource. In 2018, the world's remaining lithium reserves were estimated at 53.8 million tons.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Growing energy demand
Electric modes of transportation don't emit CO2, but e-bike batteries have to be charged regularly. The same is true, of course, for batteries of e-scooters, e-skateboards monowheels, hoverboards, … See a trend there? The demand for electricity is growing and not all of it is met with energy from renewable sources.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/I. Wagner
Many new ideas — and many more batteries
As companies keep coming up with cool new e-gadgets for us to buy, the number of batteries that need to be charged is likely to keep rising. In addition to regular e-bikes, there are even e-unicycles. Not into peddling? Then how about a hoverboard, inspired by cult classic "Back to the Future II"?
Image: Getty Images/S. Gallup
Last mile scooters
E-scooters are similar to the scooters you might remember from your childhood. These new ones, however, don't rely exclusively on our feet to propel them forward, but on battery power. That makes them more eco-friendly than vehicles with a combustion engine, but many people only use them to travel the "last mile" from a bus stop or car park to wherever they're going.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/H. Neubauer
Illegal fun
Up until now, zipping along the streets on an e-scooter was illegal in Germany. Because of their little "engine," you'd need certain permits for e-scooters (like a license for a car), but those weren't available. Starting in the summer of 2019, Germans will be allowed to drive e-scooters with a maximum speed of up to 20 kph (12 mph) on bike paths. In the US, that's been legal for a while.
"Bike trailers for children have no business on the streets," FPÖ politician Karl Baron said in a statement.
"The FPÖ has been warning for years about the insufficient safety of bike trailers or cargo bikes to transport children on the road," added Baron, who is the party spokesperson for Vienna's transportation committee.
Transportation Minister Andreas Reichhardt, also a member of the FPÖ, announced on Tuesday that the government is investigating data on child transport on bikes.
The Austrian government wants to "look closely" at accident figures and safety regulations, a ministry spokeswoman told Der Standard.
Cities where cycling is a joy
This year's Tour de France kicks off in Copenhagen on July 1st. The Danish capital is famous for its fantastic cycling infrastructure. Here are a few more bike-friendly cities in Europe.
Image: CC/Negu
Copenhagen
Denmark's capital boasts a 350-kilometer (217-mile) cycle path network, traffic lights that prioritize cyclists, and footrests on the roadside when you have to wait for a green light. No wonder, then, that 63 percent of the population cycle to work. The word "copenhagenize" has already become established in English to describe making cities more bicycle-friendly.
Amsterdam in the Netherlands is one of the most bicycle-friendly cities in Europe. Cyclists in Amsterdam cover some 2 million kilometers (approx. 1.24 million miles) a day. The country is popular with cyclists because it's very flat. Utrecht, for example, is home to the largest bicycle parking garage with 33,000 parking spaces.
Image: picture-alliance/NurPhoto/N. Economou
Paris
In Paris, the city authorities have been systematically expanding the cycle network for years. On Sundays, entire streets are even closed to traffic. As a tourist, one can also easily mingle with the cyclists, as there are bicycle rental stations everywhere. This is also the case in Strasbourg. The two cities count as the most bicycle-friendly in France.
Image: picture-alliance/robertharding/S. Dee
Malmo
Malmo in Sweden has invested a lot of money in improving its bicycle infrastructure. There are almost 500 kilometers (311 miles) of cycle paths with (tire) pumping stations and right-of-way systems. Probably the most creative idea is a bicycle hotel with its own workshop, rental bikes — and bike parking directly in front of the rooms.
Image: Ohboy
Trondheim
Trondheim in Norway is a hilly city. The "Trampe", the world's first bicycle lift, provides a solution. The 130-meter-long (426 ft) lift takes up to 300 cyclists per hour up the mountain to the Kristiansten Fortress. A plate, on which you can stand with your right foot, is pulled along a rail. This plate then pushes the cyclist together with the bike up the hill.
Image: public domain
Münster
In Münster in Westphalia, there are more bicycles than residents. It is therefore not surprising that Münster is the city, after Leipzig, with the highest bicycle theft rate in Germany. But that doesn't stop people from riding their bikes — after all, Münster offers wide cycle paths, plenty of parking spaces and no hills.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/B. Thissen
Barcelona
As early as 2002 you could ride a rental bike through Barcelona. 250 kilometers (98 miles) of cycle paths connect destinations in the Catalan capital. Zones limiting speeds to 30 kmph ensure more safety in city traffic. For tourists, the city offers various themed cycle paths through the city, to the beach or to the sights of architect Antoni Gaudi.
Image: picture-alliance/imageBROKER/G. Guarino
Basel
In Basel the land is flat and the distances short. The streets are particularly crowded during the slowUp. During this event, which takes place in summer in different cities in Switzerland, the organizers block off around 30 kilometers (18.6 miles) in beautiful surroundings for cyclists and provide them with a wide range of activities along the route. What could be more fun?
Image: picture-alliance/imageBROKER/M. Dr. Schulte-Kellinghaus
8 images1 | 8
Activists urge more protections for bikes
The FPÖ's proposals and articles criticizing the safety of bike trailers received pushback from safety experts and others on social media who urged expanded protections for bicyclists.
"The fact is that the danger stems from those 1.5-ton vehicles traveling at 100 kph (62 mph) and not from child trailers," wrote Ulrich Leth, a transportation expert at the Technical University of Vienna, on Twitter.
"The discussion must then revolve around minimizing the risk from cars," he added, suggesting speed limits as a possible solution.
Ines Ingerle, a communications official with Austria's bicycle lobby, also took issue with the criticism leveled at electric bikes due to the accident.
"Whenever a car driver is unsafe and hits a bike trailer, it doesn't matter whether it was being pulled along by an electric bike or one powered purely with muscle power," Ingerle told Der Standard.
She urged for more security measures for bikes to move around safely, such as installing more bicycle lanes.
Unlike in Germany, children under the age of 12 in Austria are required to wear helmets including while riding in a bike trailer.
The trailers are also required to have sufficient lighting on the backs and sides that is separate from the bike, as well as seat belts and brakes.