LGBTQ in Africa: Stigma, attacks and criminal charges
Martina Schwikowski
June 3, 2022
In Africa, same-sex partnerships are only legal in about half of the continent's 54 states. Many countries outlaw homosexuality and LGBTQ people still live in fear of attacks, imprisonment and even the death penalty.
Advertisement
The persecution of LGBTQ people by the state is brutal in Africa. In some countries, sexual minorities fear for their lives due to the threat of the death penalty or lengthy prison sentences.
There are also drastic restrictions on LGBTQ freedom of expression, as well as discrimination.
That was evident on a football field in France recently.
In mid-May, Senegalese international and Paris Saint-Germain soccer club player Idrissa Gana Gueye refused to wear a rainbow jersey as a symbol of greater tolerance and support for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer or questioning, also known as LGBTQ, and people with other sexual minorities.
Top 10 most queer-friendly travel destinations
To mark German Diversity Day, we've looked at travel destinations around the world that rank as very friendly to the LGBTQ community. Our selection is based on the 2021 Spartacus Gay Travel Index.
Image: Christoph Hardt/Geisler-Fotopres/picture alliance
Canada
Canada is considered the most queer-friendly travel destination in the world. It legalized same-sex marriage in 2005, making it one of the earliest countries to do so. Canada is also well-known for staging numerous LGBTQ events, such as Toronto Pride in June (pictured), and Fierte Montreal Pride Festival in August of each year.
Image: Nathan Denette/empics/picture alliance
Malta
This small island nation in the Mediterranean Sea is Europe's most progressive country in terms of protecting the LGBTQ community. It banned discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity in 2004. Malta was the first European state to outlaw so-called gay conversion therapy in 2016.
Image: Mark Zammit Cordina/Photohot/picture alliance
Portugal
Lisbon and Porto (pictured) are among the most diverse and open-minded cities in Portugal. Same-sex marriage has been legal in the country since 2010. A few years later, same-sex couples were also granted full adoption rights. However, the country still has some way to go when it comes to protecting the transgender community and outlawing conversion therapy.
Image: Diogo Baptista/ZUMAPRESS/picture alliance
Sweden
Known as one of the most progressive countries in the world, Sweden has passed many laws strengthening its LGBTQ community. Indeed, the Scandinavian nation decriminalized sexual relationships between consenting adults of the same sex over 75 years ago! Today, use of the inclusive, gender neutral pronoun "hen" as an alternative to the gender-specific hon ("she") and han ("he") is widespread.
Image: Iulianna Est/Zoonar/picture alliance
Uruguay
As one of the most tolerant countries in Latin America, Uruguay was among the first to legalize same-sex marriage. The small nation decriminalized consensual sex between same-sex couples as early as 1934, and in 2004 passed anti-discrimination legislation to further protect the LGBTQ community.
Image: Daniel Ferreira-Leites Ciccarino/Zoonar/picture alliance
Australia
Most travelers tend to associate Australia with glorious beaches and multicultural cities. But many might not be aware that added to this, Australia is also very tolerant. It passed far-reaching anti-discrimination legislation in 1984, aiming to protect people from mistreatment based on their sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or intersex status. Same-sex marriages were made legal in 2017.
Image: Subel Bhandari/dpa/picture alliance
Germany
While Germany is making progress in bolstering intersex rights, it still has some way to go in terms of creating a truly queer-friendly society. Cologne (pictured) and the capital Berlin, however, are known as particularly open-minded and diverse cities. Germany legalized same-sex marriages in 2017, and intersex people can now legally identify themselves as such.
Image: Christoph Hardt/Geisler-Fotopress/picture alliance
Iceland
This sparely populated nation near the Arctic Circle is famed not only for rugged landscapes and hot springs but also for being incredibly friendly to the LGBTQ community. It is, after all, one of the safest and most liberal holiday destinations you could pick. The capital Reykjavik (pictured) has been hosting an annual Pride Festival since 1999, and same-sex marriages were legalized in 2010.
Image: IBL Schweden/picture alliance
Taiwan
Taiwan is touted as Asia's most progressive country when it comes to LGBTQ rights. The island state has adopted staunch anti-discrimination legislation, entrenched transgender rights and was the first Asian state to legalize same-sex marriage in 2019.
Image: Ceng Shou Yi/NurPhoto/picture alliance
Colombia
Although the Catholic faith and macho attitudes remain deeply ingrained in Colombian culture, it is regarded as one of Latin America's most progressive countries, after Uruguay, in terms of LGBTQ rights. Its top court ruled same-sex marriage legal in 2016. In 2020, Colombia was voted South America's leading LGBTQ destination at the annual World Travel Awards.
Image: Sofia Toscano/colprensa/dpa/picture alliance
10 images1 | 10
The rhetoric against LGBTQ people has increased among Senegalese social media users since the incident at a league match in France.
In France, Gueye was criticized but in Senegal the player has received much support for his behavior, even at the highest level.
" I support Idrissa Gueye," Senegal's President Macky Sall tweeted. "His religious beliefs must be respected."
Around 95% of Senegal's population is Muslim and so-called "unnatural acts" with a person of the same sex are punishable by law with prison terms of one to five years.
Increase in attacks
Members of the LGBTQ community report that attacks and homophobic incidents in the West African country have increased in recent years.
Meanwhile, violence against LGBTQ people in Cameroon is also on the rise, according Human Rights Watch.
The country still criminalizes same-sex relationships, according to Lewis Mudge, the organization's director for Central Africa.
"This law creates this atmosphere in which LGBTQ people are targets," Mudge told DW.
"Homosexuality, same-sex conduct, is difficult for some people in Cameroon to accept, as it is in other African countries," he said.
The police are also not on their side, he added.
Advertisement
Where in Africa do LGBTQ people have rights?
In the past decade, five African countries have legalized homosexuality. Angola now allows same-sex relationships after passing a new law that came into force in February 2021.
The new law overturned legislation that dated back to 1965, when the country was still under British rule.
In 2015, Mozambique removed a colonial era clause from its penal code that banned same-sex relationships. It had designated them a "vice against nature."
Lesotho and Seychelles are also among the frontrunners in terms of acceptance, according to a 2020 global overview by the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association.
Same-sex partnerships are only legal in 22 of Africa's 54 countries, according to the overview.
In some countries, they are punished with imprisonment, in others even with death — that includes Mauritania, a dozen states in Nigeria and Somalia where Sharia law applies.
The maximum sentence is life imprisonment in Tanzania, Uganda and Zambia, while in Gambia, Kenya and Malawi, prison sentences of up to 14 years are possible, according to the overview.
In Zambia, President Hakainde Hichilema has just reaffirmed at a church service that his government would not stand up for the rights of homosexuals in the country.
While same-sex relationships are not criminalized in Rwanda, members of the LGBTQ community criticize the government for not protecting them enough from stigma and violence by security agencies.
This is confirmed by the Kigali-based Health Development Initiative.
Fighting discrimination and stigmatization
The initiative's director, Aflodis Kagaba, commissioned a study on the challenges facing the LGBTQ community in Rwanda.
"Leaving no one behind means addressing stigma and discrimination," Kagaba told DW.
"We must ensure that all those inequities that make some of us feel unwelcome or condemned in our society are eliminated."
Institutions that support women should also consider LBGTQ people, one Rwandan activist told DW.
"We want to see ways they can improve their social or economic status, in the private or public sphere, without paying attention to gender identity or sexual orientation because we are more than that."
Prejudices are also evident in schools, workplaces or in the health care system, according to Jean Claude Cedric, an LBGTQ activist from Rwanda.
"The employees in health centers openly refuse to treat us. This forces many people in our community to stop visiting these facilities. Our government must enact laws that improve our lives and fight those in the community who harass us," Cedric told DW.
Queer life in South Africa: Zanele Muholi's photography
A new exhibition in Berlin showcases the world-renowned work of Zanele Muholi, who aims to lend a voice to Africa's LGBTQ community through photography.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi and Stevenson, Kapstadt/Johannesburg and Yancey Richardson, New York
Black is beautiful
Zanele Muholi, shown here in a self-portrait, celebrates the lives of the LGBTQ communities of South Africa through photography and other kinds of visual art. The language of Muholi's depictions of queer African identities builds on visual contrast, and also focuses on the explicit portrayal of acts of introspection.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi and Stevenson, Kapstadt/Johannesburg and Yancey Richardson, New York
A scarred society
Muholi's work is more than mere photography. It is an act of activism itself. Through art, Muholi highlights issues affecting the LGBTQ community in their country, where issues like so-called "corrective rape" and HIV/AIDS continue to affect the lives of thousands of South Africans. At the same time, Muholi's focus on beauty provides a contrast that could be interpreted as a sense of hope.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi and Stevenson, Kapstadt/Johannesburg and Yancey Richardson, New York
Reflections on identity
Identifying as non-binary, Muholi (who uses the pronouns they/them) regards the subjects depicted in their works simply "as a human being." Their exploration of the human condition often hints at the harsh realities of life in South Africa as a queer minority — such as suffering hate crimes. This is a deliberate juxtaposition to the aesthetic standards they also seek to present in their work.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi, acquired by using funds of the African Acquisitions Committee 2017
Blurred lines
Having grown up under apartheid during their youth, Muholi's deliberate blurring of social identities can be seen both as representative and contradictory of the "Rainbow Nation" concept that South Africa hopes to project. Race continues to be a major issue in their country, as the white minority still rules over the economy. Muholi's response is to simply mix things — and identities — up.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi and Stevenson, Kapstadt/Johannesburg and Yancey Richardson, New York
Smoke and mirrors
Muholi's portraiture of South African members of the LGBTQ community often conceals the subject's (biological) gender identity. This way, audiences can deliberate how they automatically react to an image — and what that might say about them. It also protects the identity of the queer subjects shown in their photographs, who despite legal protections on paper often have to live in hiding.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi and Stevenson, Kapstadt/Johannesburg and Yancey Richardson, New York
Forbidden kisses
The depiction of lesbian couples in particular is often regarded as controversial in South Africa's black communities. Many people believe that women who love women can be "cured," while homosexual men are often rejected as lost causes. Muholi's efforts to share images of tenderness, care and love among women hits a sore nerve in South Africa.
Image: Courtesy of Zanele Muholi and Stevenson, Kapstadt/Johannesburg and Yancey Richardson, New York
Global success
Muholi's works have traveled around the globe, with exhibitions introducing them to audiences beyond Africa. Shows in London, Paris, Amsterdam, New York, Boston, Houston, and now Berlin have not only furthered their career as a visual artist but have also increased the reach of the message Muholi wants to share. In South Africa, Muholi is a permanent fixture at the Zeitz MOCAA museum in Cape Town.
Image: AFP/GettyImages
Ongoing struggles
Zanele Muholi continues to document the struggles of queer identities in South Africa. But in the meantime, they also succeed in injecting their subjects with universally understood aesthetics. This way, their art becomes accessible to a wide audience both at home and abroad. Muholi's photography can currently be seen at the Gropius Bau Museum in Berlin until March 13, 2022.
Image: DW/U.Sommer
8 images1 | 8
South Africa as a role model
Many persecuted people seek refuge outside their home country, especially in comparatively more liberal South Africa.
Although violence and social discrimination against LGBTQ people is still widespread there, the rights of sexual minorities are enshrined in the country's Constitution.
In this respect, South Africa is a role model in Africa.
Other countries are also seeing some progress.
The small kingdom of Eswatini, which neighbors South Africa, held its first gay pride parade in 2018 — an event that has been on the public calendar in South Africa for years.
In 2006, South Africa became the first country in Africa — and one of just a few nations worldwide at the time — to legalize same-sex marriage.
South Africa: An LGBT beacon?
02:15
Nasra Bishumba contributed to this article. It was originally written in German and has been adapted by Benita van Eyssen.