Foreign journalists reporting on the flood disaster in China have been hindered in their work by normal citizens who feel the reporters are presenting a distorted picture of the country.
Mathias Bölinger in BeijingImage: DW
Advertisement
"Are you that BBC guy?" a passerby asked Mathias Bölinger, a German journalist who has been reporting for DW and other broadcasters from the flooded regions in China.
Ever since the BBC aired an investigative TV report on the origins of the coronavirus pandemic — a report Beijing considers "fictitious" — the British broadcaster has had a credibility problem in China. There, the BBC has become synonymous with "anti-China untrustworthy foreign media." The official take is that their reporters spread nothing but "lies about China."
At least 63 people died in the flooding in Henan ProvinceImage: Stringer/HPIC/dpa/picture alliance
Bölinger, who is accredited by the Chinese Foreign Ministry for journalistic activities in China, does not work for the BBC — but has involuntarily become the focus of a bizarre debate on Chinese social media.
Angry crowd
During a live English-language interview with DW on July 24 in Zhengzhou, the capital of Henan province, passersby filmed him with their mobile phones, said Bölinger, who speaks fluent Chinese. Later, he said, a few people approached him and told him he was not allowed to film at all. Soon, a crowd had gathered. "Someone held up a photo and asked me, 'Is that you?"' The photo showed BBC correspondent Robin Brant.
He was asked why reporters slander everything in China, and why they spread lies. A video posted on China's Weibo microblogging service and that was later also posted by Bölinger on Twitter shows an agitated crowd, and how someone tried to grab Bölinger's mobile.
China flood death toll rises
01:32
This browser does not support the video element.
Confused with BBC reporter
It turned out people had mistaken the German for a BBC reporter who was also working in the city and who the Chinese locals felt reported "falsehoods" and manipulated the statements of Chinese interviewees. His photo was posted online by the Chinese Communist Party's youth organization along with a warning to watch out and not get involved in a "supposed interview."
"Whoever discovers him, please publish the location," the warning said.
Foreign journalists are often harassed in China, like this camera crew at the Huanan Seafood Market in Hubei province in January 2021Image: Thomas Peter/REUTERS
Once the misunderstanding was cleared up, Bölinger said the situation relaxed. The crowd backed off, and in the end, the journalist recalled, "even applauded me, and one man said 'sorry.'"
'Evil media' of the West
Various videos about this particular situation spread rapidly on the internet. Many users left disappointed comments, writing that "there's no point in hoping that the Western media will report objectively and in a balanced way about China." One user, however, wrote: "China lacks media like this that investigate social problems and question their own government."
It is completely justified to be "upset about the reporting of Western media," the Beijing daily Global Times wrote in an opinion piece, saying that it contributed to the creation of a distorted image of China in the West. But the commentator advised against "besieging foreign reporters and harassing them at work" — that would after all give the Western media even more ammunition to criticize China.
Mathias Bölinger reports for DW from ChinaImage: DW
Mathias Bölinger said he did not expect the incident would make such waves. As a foreign correspondent in China, he said, he is used to being constantly observed, harassed and confronted. This time, however, he conceded it was different. He received a lot of hate messages on Twitter, to which he did not respond. He said he does not accept criticism of his supposedly one-sided China-critical reporting.
"I haven't claimed anything in the reports that doesn't correspond to the truth," Bölinger said.
In pictures: Deadly extreme weather shocks the world
From the Mediterranean to Germany to California and beyond, dramatic pictures of the severe impacts of extreme weather have been dominating the news this summer. Is the climate crisis to blame?
Image: Jon Nazca/REUTERS
Rainfall best ally for Spanish firefighters
A wildfire that burned through at least 7,780 hectares (30 square miles) in about a week and devastated forests in southern Spain was brought under control thanks to steady rains. The downpour helped the firefighters, who were backed by some 50 aircrafts. The blaze was one of the most difficult to combat in recent times in Spain. Some 2,600 people were forced to flee their homes.
Image: Jon Nazca/REUTERS
Fierce flash floods in Europe
Unprecedented flooding — caused by two months' worth of rainfall in two days — has resulted in devastating damage in central Europe, leaving at least 226 people dead in Germany and Belgium. Narrow valley streams swelled into raging floods in the space of hours, wiping out centuries-old communities. Rebuilding the ruined homes, businesses and infrastructure is expected to cost billions of euros.
Image: Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images
Europe on fire
While half of Europe is drowning, elsewhere areas are going up in flames: Large fires raged, particularly in Greece, Italy and Turkey. They have caused unforeseeable monetary damage, while thousands of people in Europe have lost their homes and their belongings.
Image: ANGELOS TZORTZINIS/AFP
Record heat in Italy
In addition to deadly wildfires, Italy also battled record heat temperatures, with the Italian Health Ministry issuing the maximum possible heat warning level for many cities. On the island of Sicily, 48.8 degrees Celsius (almost 120 degrees Fahrenheit) was measured on August 11 — a new European heat record. The heat could make existing fires worse, or lead to new ones.
Image: Andrew Medichini/AP/picture alliance
Still out of control
Meanwhile, the Dixie Fire continues smoldering in California. It's California's largest fire on record, and among the most destructive in the state's history — it wiped the town of Greenville off the map. Although it's about 60% contained, the fire continues to burn two months in. Meanwhile, hot and dry conditions continue in the region, spreading fears of more fire.
Image: DAVID SWANSON/REUTERS
Extreme rainy seasons
Earlier this summer, record floods also hit parts of India and central China, overwhelming dams and drains and flooding streets. The downpours have been particularly heavy, even for the rainy season. Scientists have predicted that climate change will lead to more frequent and intense rainfall — warmer air holds more water, creating more rain.
Image: AFP/Getty Images
Greece melts down amid heat waves
As nations flood in northern Europe, Mediterranean countries like Greece were in the grip of several heat waves. In the first week of July, temperatures soared to 43 degrees Celsius (109 Fahrenheit). Tourism hot spots like the Acropolis were forced to shut during the day, while the extreme heat also sparked forest fires outside Thessaloniki, which helicopters tried to douse.
Image: Sakis Mitrolidis/AFP/Getty Images
Sardinia scorched by 'unprecedented' wildfires
"It is an unprecedented reality in Sardinia’s history," said Sardinia's Governor Christian Salinas of the ongoing wildfires that have scorched the historic central western area of Montiferru. "So far, 20,000 hectares of forest that represent centuries of environmental history of our island have gone up in ashes." Around 1,500 people were evacuated from the island by the end of July.
Image: Vigili del Fuoco/REUTERS
Heat records in the US, Canada
Intense heat is becoming more common, as seen in late June in the US states of Washington and Oregon and the Canadian province of British Columbia. Scorching temperatures under a "heat dome," hot air trapped for days by high pressure fronts, caused hundreds of heat-related deaths. The village of Lytton recorded a high of 49.6 Celsius (121 Fahrenheit) — and burned to the ground the next day.
Image: Ted S. Warren/AP/picture alliance
Wildfires sparking thunderstorms
Heat and drought are fueling one of the most intense wildfire seasons in the West Coast and Pacific Northwest regions. Oregon's Bootleg Fire, which burned an area the size of Los Angeles in just two weeks, was so big it created its own weather and sent smoke all the way to New York City. A recent study said the weather conditions would have been "virtually impossible" without climate change.
Image: National Wildfire Coordinating Group/Inciweb/ZUMA Wire/picture alliance
Amazon nearing a 'tipping point'?
To the south, central Brazil is suffering its worst drought 100 years, increasing the risk of fires and further deforestation in the Amazon rainforest. Researchers recently reported that a large swath of the southeastern Amazon has flipped from absorbing to emitting planet-warming CO2 emissions, pushing the rainforest closer to a "tipping point."
Image: Andre Penner/AP Photo/picture alliance
'On the verge of starvation'
After years of unrelenting drought, more than 1.14 million people in Madagascar are food-insecure, with some now forced to eat raw cactus, wild leaves and roots, and locusts in famine-like conditions. With the absence of natural disaster, crop failure or political conflict, the dire situation in the African nation is said to be first famine in modern history caused solely by climate change.
Image: Laetitia Bezain/AP photo/picture alliance
More people fleeing natural disasters
The number of people fleeing conflict and natural disasters hit a 10-year high in 2020, with a record 55 million people relocating within their own country. That's in addition to some 26 million people who fled across borders. A joint report released by refugee monitors in May found that three-quarters of the internally displaced were victims of extreme weather — and that number is likely to grow.