A German court has ruled "admissible" a Peruvian farmer's claims that energy giant RWE's contributions to climate change threaten his Andean home. Environmentalists have praised the court for writing "legal history."
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/G. Kirchner
Advertisement
Climate change activists on Monday hailed a German court's decision to proceed with a Peruvian farmer's case against German energy company RWE.
After hearing arguments from both sides, the court in the German town of Hamm found that Saul Luciano Lliuya's allegations that RWE's contributions to global warming were threatening his hometown of Huaraz had merit.
Luciano argues that RWE must share in the cost of protecting his Andean town from a swollen ice glacier that risks overflowing from melting snow and ice. The farmer is asking for just €17,000 ($20,000) from RWE, which would go towards funding flood defenses he plans to install for his community, as well as a further 6,384 euros in reimbursement for money he already spent out of his own pocket on protective measures.
Klaus Milke, chairman of the environmental pressure group Germanwatch, which is advising Luciano's claim, praised the court in Hamm for writing "legal history."
Why has Luciano singled out Germany's RWE in his claim?
Peruvian farmer Saul Luciano Lliuya said he based his claim on a 2013 climate study that found RWE, Germany's second largest electricity producer, responsible for 0.5 percent of all global emission "since the beginning of industrialization."
This, he argues, makes the German energy giant, at least - in part - responsible for the plight facing his hometown of Huaraz and must therefore share in the cost of protecting it.
RWE is one of the world's top emitters of carbon dioxide, although it claims to have invested billions into modernizing its coal-fired plants and into moving towards renewable energy.
Representatives for the energy giant maintain that, under German civil law, RWE alone cannot alone be held responsible for a global phenomenon, such as global warming.
Why is the case important?
The German court's decision to allow Luciano's case to enter its second stage could set precedent for future so-called "climate justice" cases.
Not only does Monday's decision mark the first time a German court has directly linked the emission of carbon dioxide to global warming; it also marks the first time ever that a court has acknowledged emitters may have to contribute towards protecting those vulnerable from climate change.
If successful, Luciano's claim could open the door for further cases seeking funding from energy companies to help protect those vulnerable from effects of climate change, particularly within developing countries.
Court expected to hear evidence
The court in Hamm has given both sides until November 30 to provide further arguments before deciding how to proceed. However, it added that the claim was "likely to proceed" to hearing evidence.
"It's good news for the many potential plaintiffs worldwide who will be emboldened to take action themselves," Klaus said.
The case coincides with COP23 climate change conference taking place in Bonn, just a two-hour drive away from Hamm. Delegates at the Bonn conference have gathered to negotiate the rulebook for the 2015 Paris climate pact, which calls for temperatures to be capped at "well below" two degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels.
COP23: Art against climate change
At the UN climate summit in Bonn, negotiators are discussing goals, funding and measures to slow global warming. But it's not all talk — artists and activists have channeled their creativity into the call for action.
Image: DW/P. Große
All in this together
Frank Bainimarama, prime minister of COP23 host country Fiji, appealed to delegates from 196 countries in the summit's opening ceremony: "We have to sail together, with one collective will, to reach our goals." Summit participants are reminded of the sentiment whenever they pass by this original Fijian canoe.
Image: DW/H. Kaschel
Talanoa - a respectful exchange of ideas
At COP23, Fiji is encouraging everyone to remain open-minded. "We want to lead talks with our Talanoa spirit of understanding and respect," Bainimarama said. His country's pavilion is decked out with traditional furniture and plants, encouraging visitors to stay a while and get into the Talanoa mindset — a Pacific island tradition of open communication.
Image: DW/P. Große
Global crochet
Developing countries are hit hardest by climate change — particularly their indigenous peoples. At COP23, delegates from across the world hope to establish rules to protect them from devastating consequences of global warming. This tipi in the Rheinaue, the park in Bonn where COP23 takes place, is also a global effort. It's made up of hundreds of squares crocheted by people from around the world.
Image: DW/P. Große
The polar bears' sad fate
Animals suffer from climate change too. Drought, floods and storms destroy their natural habitats. The most emblematic example is the sad fate of polar bears. Due to global warming, the ice is melting from beneath their paws, as highlighted by this statue of an impaled polar bear at COP23.
Image: DW/P. Große
Our friends, the trees
Forests are crucial to the climate. Each year, they absorb millions of tons of CO2 from the atmosphere. Activists from the German Forests Association who want the woods better protected have brought this art project to Bonn. Over the course of the summit, it will grow into an 8-meter tree with a globe on top.
Image: DW/P. Große
The world in peril
The goal of the Paris Climate Agreement is to keep global warming to under 2 degrees Celsius. Today, people are already suffering the consequences of climate change, like droughts and extreme weather events. At the "Climate Planet" in Bonn, visitors can learn about climate change and how it affects them. The 20-meter-tall globe was thought up by Germany's Development Ministry.
Image: DW/P. Große
China and India catching up
In the long run, renewable energy is supposed to replace fossil fuels. Each country is setting its own rules for when this has to happen. After China and the US, India is the third-largest emitter of greenhouse gases. While the US wants to pull out of the climate agreement, China and India are doubling down on climate action. India is showing off its ambition in its country pavilion.
Image: DW/P. Große
Taking climate action to the streets
Climate activists are calling for urgent divestment from coal. Before and during COP23, many of them have been protesting for a rapid end of our fossil fuel dependency. Thousands of people have already taken to the streets in Bonn and the Bonn Theater is showcasing protestors' anger and demands in an exhibition of protest posters.
Image: DW/P. Große
Costumes for climate
At one rally in the run-up to COP23, protestors wore costumes and masks. One of their biggest targets was US President Donald Trump. The US is the only country in the world to want out of the Paris Agreement. That's a decision that's likely to hurt polar bears — the real ones, not these costumed fellows.
