Students vs. teachers
June 23, 2009
The plaintiff, irked by a low ranking, regarded the site as a breach of her personal rights. The teacher had demanded that her details, including her name, school and the classes she teaches, be removed from www.spickmich.de.
Germany's highest civil court, based in Karlsruhe, on Tuesday ruled however that students have the right to grade their teachers on the website. Two years ago, a state superior court in Cologne ruled that the website was protected by constitutional freedom of expression.
Many teachers oppose spickmich.de, saying no teacher should be graded without consent. Data protection specialists also argue that the teachers' personal rights should come before the freedom of expression in this case.
Spickmich.de was founded by three students in 2007. Last year, the founders announced the site had more than a million users, making it one of the largest of its kind for German-language speakers. The website allows secondary pupils all over Germany to vote online on the qualities of their teacher, grading them in categories like "competent," "well prepared" and "cool or funny."
Student rankings are anonymous
Tino Keller, one of the original founders and head of spickmich.de, said the site created a channel of communication and made teacher assessments more transparent. In an online interview with Die Zeit last week, Keller said he was confident the court would rule in spickmich.de's favour.
"We have won on all levels of jurisdiction so far. The judges made it clear that school is not the teachers' private affair; teachers must allow for a certain amount of criticism from their students," Keller said.
After all, Keller added, freedom of opinion applies to the internet, too.
He pointed out that certain rules apply in order to be able to access spickmich.de to check out teachers' ratings.
"You have to have a legitimate interest and be enrolled at the school in question in order to receive information."
In general, the website shows that German students are quite satisfied with their teachers – as everywhere, some are excellent, some are bad, with a large group of standard teachers in between.
wl/dpa/AP
Editor: Trinity Hartmann