1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

Failing the test

March 6, 2011

The head of leading economic Ifo think-tank says the EU's new banking stress tests are too lax. He argued the new tests are no better than last year's widely criticized ones.

City of Frankfurt with umbrella protecting it
Stress tests in 2010 simply covered-up weaknesses, critics sayImage: picture alliance/dpa

The European Union's new stress tests for banks are too lax, according to the head of a leading German economic think-tank.

Hans-Werner Sinn of Munich's Ifo Institute said in an interview in Sunday's edition of the Frankfurter Allgemeine newspaper that the tests will fail to expose all loans at risk of default.

"Accurate stress tests would reveal that many banks are still carrying enormous non-performing burdens," Sinn said.

He argued that EU rules still allow banks to declare many securities at their nominal value, not their lower market value. This included Greek government bonds which currently trade at less than 70 percent of their nominal value.

Hans-Werner Sinn is the head of Munich's Ifo InstituteImage: DW-TV

"The new stress tests will be just as bad at uncovering these non-performing assets at the old ones were," he warned.

Weathering a potential storm

Stress tests are designed to expose whether each EU bank can remain viable if the market experiences a downturn or a new recession develops.

Tests carried out on 91 EU banks in 2010 were criticized for being too weak, which is a primary factor behind the new round of tests prepared by the European Banking Authority (EBA).

Only seven banks failed the last slate of tests. In fact, all of Ireland's banks passed just months before that country's banking crisis forced Dublin to appeal for an international bailout.

Author: Catherine Bolsover (dpa/Reuters)
Editor: Kyle James

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Skip next section More stories from DW