Despite evacuation orders, some people choose to stay and defend their home during extreme weather events. Why do they do it?
Advertisement
In December 2019, Jack Egan watched his home in the Australian beachside settlement of Rosedale go up in flames.
Despite orders from authorities to evacuate, he and his partner, Cath, decided to stay and defend their home from the fires. Egan had some experience with wildfires and thought the property was savable.
"It's definitely at your own risk if you stay — and do not expect anybody to come and help you," Egan told DW.
The decision to stay and defend the home using a firefighting pump and hose was part of Egan's fire plan. But when his house was caught in the blaze and the heat became too much, he was forced to stop defending his home and shelter in his neighbour's more fireproof house.
"I don't really like the term firefighting because it's as though you can fight it," says Egan. "You can't really, you can only manage your survival and maybe direct the path of the fire if you've got bulldozers."
In extreme weather events such as floods, hurricanes, and wildfires, some people will stay to defend their homes despite evacuation warnings. It is a choice more and more people will be forced to make as the planet heats up.
"Home is really almost indistinguishable from who we are," says Frank McAndrew, a social psychologist and professor of psychology at Knox College in the US. "It is the one place in the world that we supposedly have control over. No one else can even come in there without our permission."
For many people home is more than a shelter. It's their safe space, a place they have made their own, filled with items that connect them to their past, and where memories were made.
"It's the repository of all of the things that make you who you are," McAndrew says.
Why people stay
There are many reasons why someone might not evacuate despite serious risk to their life. Depending on the type of hazard, the advice might even be to stay inside the home.
Advertisement
Some people's entire livelihoods are tied up in their homes. Insurance for damage caused by extreme weather events may be too costly for some, while others who live in risk areas can find it difficult, and sometimes even impossible, to find a company that will insure their property.
One of the lessons learned from Hurricane Katrina — a category 5 hurricane that hit the US in 2005 and killed more than 1,800 people — was that some people were not willing to leave their pets behind. This has led to the creation of evacuation areas specifically for animals.
In some cases, such as with the July floods in northern Europe, warnings that come too late or not at all take the decision out of people's hands. In these situations, it might even be safer for people to stay in their home, said Sarah McCaffrey, a social scientist for the Rocky Mountain Research Station at the US Department of Agriculture's Forest Service.
Some people stay because they have a business they want to save, or they believe they can protect their home.
Similar concerns were seen in research that looked at people living in three cyclone-prone coastal sites in Bangladesh.
When cyclones hit the island of Mazer Char, as Cyclone Sidr did in 2007, some people could afford to leave their house and belongings behind because the cyclone didn't impact their food security, said Sonja Ayeb-Karlsson, a senior researcher in (im)mobility, climate change and well-being at the United Nations University Institute for Environment and Human security. But others felt that this loss of assets would put their survival at risk because they wouldn't be able to provide food for their families.
"A fisherman who had put his life savings into his fishing nets or boat may not feel that he is able to leave these behind," Ayeb-Karlsson told DW.
Mass destruction as floods sweep across western Germany
Intense flooding caused about 200 casualties and extensive destruction throughout Western Germany
Image: Christoph Reichwein/TNN/dpa/picture alliance
Houses collapsed, people trapped on roofs
Heavy rainfalls and storms pounded Germany’s western states and caused rivers to burst their banks, inundating towns and villages. Torrential overflow swept away vehicles, destroyed roads and bridges and reduced some houses to rubble.
Some survivors were trapped on their rooftops for hours before they were airlifted by helicopters.
Image: Christoph Reichwein/TNN/dpa/picture alliance
once-in-a-century floods
The flood's damage and death toll—about 200 dead—made it one of the deadliest disasters to hit the country in more than half a century.
During the height of the flooding, some 1,300 people were reported missing in just one German district, Ahrweiler.
Image: Sascha Schuermann/Getty Images
Shuttered roads
Phone and power lines are still down in some areas, at least two highway roads need fundamental repair.
The damage to infrastructure hampered immediate rescue efforts and threatened to leave the affected regions facing a long and difficult road to recovery.
Image: Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images
Rescue workers face danger
At least four firefighters in the German state of North Rhine-Westphalia lost their lives during rescue operations since flooding began Wednesday, according to Bernd Schneider, chairman of the NRW Firefighters Association.
Image: Harald Tittel/dpa/picture alliance
Dams threaten to burst
Dams across the region reached their capacities and threaten to overflow amid the massive rainfall. The flood, damaged water facilities and created a water shortage in some regions.
Image: Sebastien Bozon/Getty Images/AFP
A terrifying situation
Chancellor Angela Merkel visited the badly-hit town of Schuld, personally surveying the damage and speaking to residents and emergency workers.
She described the situation as "terrifying" and called for more to be done to tackle climate change in the wake of the floods.
Image: Wolfgang Rattay/AFP/Getty Images
Army deployed to help out
Over a thousand soldiers and more than 200 military vehicles have been deployed in western Germany over the last few days, as volunteers line up to help flood victims. As the water begins to recede, questions are emerging over whether residents received timely warnings before the floods. Critics say that if the country was adequately prepared for disaster, the loss would have been much less.
Image: Abdulhamid Hosbas/AA/picture alliance
7 images1 | 7
Facing uncertainty
In the year and a half since the pandemic began, many people will have faced some kind of uncertainty: the risk of catching COVID, standing by as loved ones battled illness in hospital or wondering when you'll be allowed to return to your home country.
The first thing everybody does to try to deal with uncertainty is reduce that uncertainty by seeking more information, said social scientist McCaffrey
While it might seem like people don't listen to authorities' warnings, McCaffrey said people do pay attention to official cues. It's just that some people will also use their own judgement.
People's decisions in extreme weather events are driven by their risk perception: the subjective judgment they make about how likely it is to happen and how bad it will be.
McCaffrey is the lead author of a 2017 study published in the journal Risk Analysis that looked at what influences a person's decision to respond to officials' evacuation orders for wildfires.
The study found that while most people relied on official cues like evacuation orders to take action, a large number of people relied on a combination of official and physical cues, like seeing wildfire flames, before making a decision.
"They're sort of doing that tradeoff between the cost of evacuating versus the cost of staying," McCaffrey says.
Black Saturday
The 2009 Victorian bushfires were the deadliest in Australia's history. Such blazes have been a fact of life on the extremely dry continent since time eternal. But climate change is believed to be worsening them.
Image: Getty Images
Record temperatures, record fires
The Black Saturday bushfires in Victoria were the deadliest in Australia's history. They came on the heels of a record heat wave — with scorching temperatures reaching the mid-40s Celsius (around 113 degrees Fahrenheit) for several days before the blazes started. In the dry heat, all it took was a spark to ignite an apocalyptic firestorm.
Image: Getty Images
Many fires to fight
As many as 400 individual fires broke out on February 7, 2009. When it was all over, they had killed 173 people and razed 2,133 homes in addition to hundreds of other buildings. Whole towns had been annihilated. In many cases, people who had lost everything did not return to rebuild.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/W. West
Post-traumatic stress
David Barton's home in Marysville, Victoria, burned down during the Black Saturday bushfires. He and his then-wife survived but the traumatic experience still haunts him and contributed to the eventual failure of his marriage. He wasn't alone. Many other couples who lived through the events split up. Eventually, he returned to Marysville alone.
Image: David Barton
Walls of fire
Fanned by strong winds, the firefronts of bushfires can grow to more than 100 meters (328 feet) high. In such extreme situations, flight is the only option. Some of those who tried to defend their homes using their garden hoses during the Black Saturday fires were later found dead in their yards, some with melted garden hoses still in their hands.
Image: Getty Images/S. Henderson
Thank you, climate change
Bushfire weather in Australia has become more frequent over the past 30 years, and Australia's climate commission has concluded that: "The intensity and seasonality of large bushfires in southeast Australia appears to be changing, with climate change a possible contributing factor."
Image: Getty Images/AFP/W. West
Not a new phenomenon
But fires as such are not a new phenomenon on the world's driest inhabited continent. And since they have always been a fact of life, Australia's fauna and flora have adapted to these conditions. Species that can deal with fires and their aftermath have thrived.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/W. West
Resist and fuel
Eucalyptus is one such species. The trees are true survivors when it comes to bushfires. But they don't just survive; they even promote fires. In fact, eucalyptus leaves contain an oil with such a high degree of octane that it can be used as fuel. The eucalyptus fares better in blazes than other trees, so fires help it eliminate competition.
Image: CC BY 2.0: John Tann/flickr
Firestarter
Several birds of prey, including the black kite, take this a step further. They pick up burning branches from existing fires and drop them elsewhere to start new ones. As the flames spread, they drive small rodents and birds out of hiding, making it easy for the "firehawks" to catch them.
Image: picture-alliance
Quick rebirth
Many fire-resistant plants, including some eucalyptus, posess a lignotuber. This thick woody section at their base contains buds from which new stems can sprout. They also store starch, which provides fuel for the plants to grow when they cannot photosynthesize. This allows them to rebound quickly after a fire.
Image: Getty Images/L. Dawson
9 images1 | 9
What makes a life?
In 2020, a big fast moving fire came through Colorado, where McCaffrey is based. A couple in their 80s had built a house on their dream property and decided to stay with their home. They both died in the blaze.
"It was interesting to look at their kids, who were kind of saying: 'We are so sad to lose our parents, but they died where they loved and with each other and that's what was most important to them,'" McCaffrey said.
For Egan, the fire pushed him to change careers. Three months after the blaze, he decided to retire from his job as a carer in a residential home and become a climate activist.
"I just had the thought that the future has crashed right through into the present, the extreme weather events are already here now," Egan said. "It galvanized me into early retirement and I'm a full time campaigner for climate action."
He stressed that, for people who live in an area that is at risk of an extreme weather event, it is essential to have a plan.
"When it's upon you, when it's really happening, you can't think very clearly," Egan said.
Returning home after Germany's deadly floods
Residents of devastated communities in Germany are beginning to deal with the aftermath of the catastrophic flooding.
Image: Boris Roessler/dpa/picture alliance
The devastation left by flooding
The water is slowly receding, but the disaster is far from over. In devastated riverside towns in Germany, people are only slowly working their way through dealing with what the flood has left behind: bulks of mud and piles of rubbish.
Image: Boris Roessler/dpa/picture alliance
Unlivable homes
The flood completely destroyed Jutta Schelleckes' apartment. She and her injured husband had been living in the mess for two days before firefighters arrived and decided to escort them out of their apartment and help them find shelter. Jutta is only one of the thousands of citizens whose homes have become uninhabitable.
Image: Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images
Racing against time
What used to be people's furniture and household items has now turned into waste that fills up the streets.
If not removed quickly, the waste can hinder rescue operations and impose safety risks to relief workers and residents. The mud can dry into a rock-hard surface that glues rubble to the streets.
Image: Bram Janssen/picture alliance/AP
Tons of waste and garbage to be removed
With volunteers' help, residents have started to clean up their battered homes and shops. Garbage trucks drive back and forth to remove the aftermath's waste from the streets. In Trier, one of the severely affected regions, 14,000 tons of flood waste was collected during the weekend, the spokesperson of the region's waste management association told public broadcaster SWR.
Image: Thomas Frey/picture alliance/dpa
Solidarity comes to the rescue
In addition to an army of volunteers in disaster zones, countless solidarity initiatives were created to collect donations. The flow of donations quickly became overwhelming, to the extent that several aid organizations announced they have no more capacity to receive more donations. While the COVID pandemic has kept people apart, the disaster has brought communities in the region together.