As the reservoir behind a new dam on the Nile River fills up, DW examines the ways such mega-dams hurt the environment, and looks at a few alternatives.
Advertisement
Dams are often touted as environmentally friendly. Although they do represent a renewable source of energy, a closer look reveals that they are far from green. DW lays out the biggestenvironmental problems of mega-dams.
1. Dams alter ecosystems
Water is life — and since dams block water, that impacts life downstream, both for ecosystems and people. In the case of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD), which is being filled in Ethiopia and is set to be Africa’s largest source of hydroelectric power, Egypt is concerned it will receive less water for things like agriculture.
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam: A never-ending saga
From corruption and mismanagement to a looming diplomatic crisis: Construction on Ethiopia's mammoth dam has been far from smooth sailing.
Image: DW/M. Gerth-Niculescu
A concrete colossus
At 145 meters high and almost two kilometers long, the Grand Renaissance Dam is expected to become Ethiopia's biggest source of electricity. As Africa's largest hydroelectric power dam, it will produce more than 15,000 gigawatt-hours of electricity, beginning in 2022. It will source water from Africa's longest river, the Blue Nile.
Image: DW/M. Gerth-Niculescu
The outlook so far
With more than 50% of Ethiopians still living without electricity, the government wants the dam to be up and running as soon as possible, so tens of millions of residents will be able to access power. The first of a total of 13 turbines are due to be operational by mid-2021.
Image: DW/M. Gerth-Niculescu
A long time in the making
Construction on the current dam began in 2011 — but the site was identified between 1956 and 1964. The coup of 1974 meant the project failed to progress, and it was not until 2009 that plans for the dam were resurrected. The $4.6 billion (€4.1 billion) project has consistently been the source of serious regional controversy, with its plan to source water from the Blue Nile.
Image: picture-alliance/AP Photo/E. Asmare
Transforming the landscape
In a few years, this entire area will be covered in water. The reservoir which is needed to generate electricity is expected to hold 74 billion cubic meters of water. Ethiopia wants to fill the artificial lake as soon as possible, but neighboring countries are concerned about the impact this might have on their own water supplies.
Image: DW/M. Gerth-Niculescu
Diplomatic deadlock
Egypt, in particular, fears that filling the reservoir too quickly will threaten their water supply and allow Ethiopia to control the flow of the Blue Nile. Ethiopia is insisting on having the reservoir filled in seven years. Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed met with Egyptian President Abdel-Fattah al-Sisi on Sunday, to discuss the matter.
Image: Imago Images/Xinhua
No solution in sight
However, two days of negotiations between Ethiopia, Egypt, and Sudan in Washington over the weekend failed to solve the reservoir issue, despite the US stepping in to mediate. With no progress over the last four years, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed even called on South Africa's President Cyril Ramaphosa — and the 2020 chairperson of the African Union — to intervene in the dispute.
Image: Reuters/S. Sibeko
Back-breaking work
Amidst the heated negotiations, up to 6,000 employees are still working around the clock to get the dam completed by the deadline. The working conditions are not for the faint-hearted: In the hottest months, temperatures on the construction site can reach up to 50 degrees.
Image: DW/M. Gerth-Niculescu
Project mired in corruption
Over the years, construction was also delayed significantly due to ongoing corruption and mismanagement issues. Last month, 50 people were charged with severe graft offenses relating to the dam, including the former CEO of Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP).
Image: AFP/E. Solteras
8 images1 | 8
Downstream ecosystems rely not only on water, but also on sediment, both of which are held back by big dams. As solid materials build up in a manmade reservoir, downstream land becomes less fertile and riverbeds canbecomedeeper or even erode away. Emilio Moran, a professor of geography and environment at Michigan State University in the US, described sediment loss of 30 to 40% as a result of large dams.
"Rivers carry sediment that feeds the fish, it feeds the entire vegetation along the river. So, when you stop sediment flowing freely down the streams, you have a dead river."
And ecosystems may have adapted to natural flooding, which dams take away.
Mega-dams also often have a large footprint on land upstream. Aside from displacing human communities, flooding to create a reservoir also kills plants, and leaves animals to drown or find new homes. Reservoirs can also further fragment valuable habitat and cut off migratory corridors.
2. Dams reduce biodiversity and cause extinction
Aquatic species, particularly fish, arevulnerable to the impacts of dams. Moran says the Itaipu Dam, which was constructed on the border between Paraguay and Brazil in the 1970s and 1980s, resulted in a 70 percent loss of biodiversity.
"On the Tucuruí Dam that was built in the 80s in the Amazon," he added, "there was a 60% drop in productivity of fish."
Many fish species rely on the ability to move about freely in a river, be it to seek food or return to where they were born. Migratory species are badly affected by the presence of dams. In 2016, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) reported a 99% drop in catches of sturgeon and paddlefish— both of which are migratory — over a period of three decades. Overfishing and river alteration were cited as major threats to the species’ survival.
A2018 study predicted that fish stocks on Asia’s Mekong River could drop by 40% as a result of dam projects – with consequences not only for biodiversity, but for the people whose lives and livelihoods depend on those fish.
The stakes for biodiversity are particularly high foranimals threatened with extinction. And not only for aquatic species. The Tapanuli orangutan— the Earth’s rarest ape, with only 500 individuals left — could finally be pushed to the brink if a planned hydroelectric project in Sumatra, Indonesia, is completed.Dams can literally snuff out species.
3. Dams contribute to climate change (and are affected by it)
As reservoirs fill, upstream forests are flooded, eliminating their function ascarbon sinks. As the drowned vegetation decomposes, decaying plants in manmade reservoirs release methane, a powerful greenhouse gas. That makes reservoirs sources of emissions— particularly those in tropical forests, where there is dense growth. It’s estimated that greenhouse gas emissions from dams amount to about a billion tons annually, making it a significant global source.
And as the climate changes, more frequent and prolonged drought meansdams will capture less water, resulting in lower electricity production.Countries dependent on hydropower will be especially vulnerable as temperatures keep rising.
Threatened lifeline: The Tapajos River
The Tapajos flows wild and free through the Amazon rainforest, acting as a lifeline for species. The river also sustains people — like the Munduruku indigenous group. But dam projects are threatening the river's ecology.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
Along the banks
The Munduruku people live mainly in forest regions and riverbanks, in villages spread along the Tapajos River in the Brazilian states of Para, Amazonas and Mato Grosso. With an estimated population of 12,000 to 15,000 people, the Munduruku are the most numerous indigenous group along the free-flowing Tapajos River.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The forest
The dwellers of the Sawre Muybu Indigenous Land have sought for at least three centuries to officially demarcate their territory. The 178,000-hectare area includes rainforest that is threatened by illegal loggers and mining — and more recently, by the construction of reservoirs for hydropower.
Image: Getty Images/M. Tama
The 'chief'
Munduruku people live largely as they have for centuries. Villages are represented by women known as "cacicas." Maria Aniceia Akay Munduruku, from the upper Tapajos, has taken part in her people's movement against the construction of hydropower dams, including by demarcating indigenous land. She doesn't speak Portuguese: Her husband helps her to communicate with others outside the village.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The essence of life
The Tapajos River is the essence of life for the indigenous Munduruku people. They depend on its water for sustenance, and to get around. The waters teem with vitality — there are 324 identified species of fish living in the waters, beside Amazonian manatees and giant otters.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
Rich biodiversity
Along the river also live hundreds of species of birds, lizards and amphibians. Tapirs and giant anteaters ply the riverbanks, while jaguars and ocelot also prowl the rainforest and savannah. The region is among the world's most important for rare land and water species.
Image: picture alliance/WILDLIFE/P. Oxford
The students
Munduruku children attend the village school, under the guidance of indigenous teachers. In this picture, girls play in the shared classroom at Sawre Muybu village during their holiday break. Animals such as monkeys, parrots, dogs and capybaras are welcome among the children.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
Living off the land
Manioc flour is the staple food in Munduruku villages — cassava planted on the family farm is crushed, shredded and then roasted in a wood-burning stove. Also sweet potatoes, yams and bananas are grown. Although Munduruku consume mainly food grown in the local fields, items such as sugar, salt and coffee have also made their way into the traditional diet. They are purchased in town once a month.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The threat
An aerial view shows the Teles Pires dam, on the homonymous tributary to the Tapajos. The lighter green color indicates the area of forest that was submerged — critics point out that rotting vegetation from inundated forest produces considerable quantities of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas. The specter of ongoing drought also casts doubt on future usability of such hydropower stations.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
International partners
This aerial image shows construction at the Sao Manoel hydropower dam, which is supposed to begin operation by January 2018. Partially funded by Chinese companies, the cost of the project is estimated to reach €600 million euros. The plant, located on the Teles Pires River, will have the capacity to generate 700 megawatts of electricity.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The consequences
If built, the Sao Luiz do Tapajos dam would inundate this stretch of the river — including its shallows, rapids, beaches, waterfalls, inlets and shores. Once full, it would create a reservoir the size of New York City. Planned dams could flood up to 7 percent of indigenous territory, resulting in loss of land, poorer water quality and less fish — deeply affecting Mundukuru livelihood.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
10 images1 | 10
Moran described a vicious circle, for example in Brazil, which gets 60 to 70% of its energy from hydropower: "If you wipe out half the rainforest, there will a loss of half the rainfall. And then there won't be enough water to provide the amount of power from those dams," he explained.
4. Dams reduce water quality
Manmade reservoirs trap fertilizers that run into the water from surrounding land.In addition, in somedeveloping countries, sewage flows directly into the reservoirs.This kind of pollution can result in algae blooms that suck the oxygen out of the water, making it acidic and potentiallyharmful to people and animals.
Still water in large manmade lakes is warm at the top and cold at the bottom, which can also affect water quality.While warm water promotes the growth of harmful algae, the cold water that is often released through turbines from the bottom of a reservoir may contain damagingly high mineral concentrations.
Insome cases, water in manmade reservoirs is of such bad quality that it is not even fit to drink.
5. Dams waste water
Since more surface area of the water gets exposed to the sun, reservoirs result in much more evaporation than the natural flow of the river before that dam existed. It’s estimated at least 7% of the total amount of freshwater needed for human activities evaporates from the world’s reservoirs every year.
This effect is made worse in hot regions, Moran pointed out. "Certainly if you had a reservoir in a tropical area with high temperatures, there is going to be a lot of evaporation," he said. And big reservoirs “are, of course, evaporating constantly.”
Living Planet: Water — a limited resource
Reservoirs are also a haven for invasive plant species, and weed-covered reservoir banks can lead toevapotranspiration — orthe transfer of water from the land to the atmosphere through evaporation from soil and transpiration from plants. Such evapotranspiration amounts to six times more than the evaporation from the water’s surface. And there is even evidence that dams increase water use and promote water waste by creating a false sense of water security.
The evidence is damning. But if mega-dams have so many harmful environmental effects, what are the alternatives? Although some green groups point to small hydropower as being more ecologically sound, Moran is skeptical. "A dam is a dam - it's blocking the fish, it's blocking the sediment."
He pointed to the need to consider not just how to maximize energy production, but also maintain ecological productivity. One option he cited is the use of in-stream turbines.
And manyenvironment advocates agree that other renewable energies such as solar and wind can provide clean electricity at a far lower environmental cost.
Why fish need ladders
Upstream and downstream - some fish need to migrate over long distances. But weirs, dams, locks and other manmade obstacles block their way. Monorails, ladders and even elevators help fish get where they need to go.
Award-winning fish elevator
For the structure on the right, a German company last week received the German Innovation Award for Climate and Environment. It is a fish elevator, which transports fish from the lower to the upper water level - and vice versa - of a weir. This elevator enables fish to cross the man-made obstacle and continue their journey along the river.
Image: Baumann Hydrotec
In and out
The fish elevator, constructed by the German company Baumann Hydrotec, runs mainly on water power. Fish enter a container inside a water-filled chamber at the bottom of the weir. Eventually a latch closes. Water enters the chamber and lifts the container up. The latch opens, and the fish continue their journey.
Image: Baumann Hydrotec
A long way to go
But why do fish need an elevator at all? The reason is that they migrate up and down rivers. Salmon are famous for their long journey. They travel hundreds of kilometers from the sea up the rivers to reach spawning grounds, where they lay their eggs. Freshwater eels also travel a long way to reproduce. And a lot of other fish species migrate just to search for food.
Image: picture alliance/Arco Images GmbH
End of the line
Migration ends as soon as something like this shows up: a dam. Without help, fish are unable to reach the upper level. And they might not survive being washed down with the rushing water from the upper to the lower level.
Image: Getty Images/Jeff T. Green
Travel by train
Conservationists might come up with a solution like gathering fish on one level of a dam and transporting them to the other level - by monorail. This is what actually happens at the Hwacheon Dam in South Korea. The dam interrupted an important fish migration route when it was built in 1944.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/Yonhap News
A great help
Fish ladders are more natural. They offer an alternative route from the upper to the lower level and vice versa, allowing fish to overcome the man-made obstacle themselves. Though manmade, fish ladders don't have to be elaborate, expensive constructions - they can be small and simple, like this one.
Image: picture alliance/dpa/J. Büttner
25,000 fish a day
When the weir, dam or lock is economically important and quite big, the fish ladder will look very impressive. This one in Geesthacht near Hamburg, Germany, on the river Elbe, is 550 meters (1,800 feet) long. It is the biggest fish ladder in Europe, consisting of 45 interconnected pools that the fish have to pass through.
Image: dapd
Spiral staircase
Fish ladders can take the form of spiral staircases. Fish work their way up from one pool to the other. This construction, though, needs less space than the usual kind of fish ladder. An added benefit: the roundish pools prevent the fish from hurting themselves in the course of their journey.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/J. Lübke
Aiming high
One of these spiral staircases for fish is to be found at a hydropower station near Kiel in northern Germany. Looking like some futuristic industrialstructure, it is 200 meters (656 feet) long, consists of 36 pools and covers an incline of 3 percent.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/W. Pfeiffer
Special treatment
Eels are weak swimmers, they just slither up- and downstream. They need special eel ladders: watery, ascending ramps with brush-like structures on the ground. Special rest areas allow them to have a break during their climb. Eels' ladders are often built alongside ordinary fish ladders.