German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius sees popularity soar
Helen Whittle
February 22, 2023
Just over a month after taking office, Defense Minister Boris Pistorius is outranking other government members in popularity ratings. Why is that?
Advertisement
Just a few weeks after taking over as defense minister on January 19, Boris Pistorius from the center-left Social Democrats (SPD) has become Germany's most popular politician, according to a telephone survey of 1,361 eligible voters conducted last week and published by public broadcaster ZDF. He outranked popular Green Party politicians Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock and Economy Minister Robert Habeck.
The 62-year-old took office after his predecessor, Christine Lambrecht, was forced to resign following a series of political blunders. After having served as interior minister for the northern state of Lower Saxony for over a decade, Pistorius suddenly found himself in the spotlight, as the war in Ukraine dominates both the media and political landscape.
German government's hot seat: The defense ministry
Boris Pistorius is set to be Germany's new defense minister. Who were his predecessors?
Boris Pistorius' appointment came as a surprise to most political pundits. He is a trained lawyer and has been serving as minister for the interior in the northern state of Lower Saxony since 2013.
Image: Droese/localpic/IMAGO
Christine Lambrecht (SPD) 2021-2023
Lambrecht's yearlong tenure was a succession of minor scandals and unfortunate statements. She had to take much of the criticism for the German government's hesitation to send heavy weaponry to Ukraine. Her gaffes included taking her adult son on an official trip in a military helicopter, and a New Year's message about the war in Ukraine almost drowned out by fireworks exploding in the background.
Image: Sean Gallup/Getty Images
Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer (CDU) 2019 - 2021
In 2020, Kramp-Karrenbauer disbanded a company of the Special Forces Command (KSK) after police seized weapons and ammunition during a raid on the property of a KSK soldier linked to far-right networks. During her time as defense minister, Kramp-Karrenbauer apologized to soldiers who for decades faced discrimination on the basis of their sexual orientation.
Image: Michael Kappeler/dpa/picture alliance
Ursula von der Leyen (CDU) 2013 - 2019
Ursula von der Leyen's tenure is often linked to an overhaul in personnel, materiel and finances to modernize the Bundeswehr, and to the "Agenda Attractiveness." During von der Leyen's term, the Bundeswehr began its fight against the "Islamic State" (IS ). In addition, a new military organizational area was set up to tackle cyberwarfare.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/A. I. Bänsch
Thomas de Maizière (CDU) 2011- 2013
Thomas de Maizière shaped the Bundeswehr after the suspension of compulsory military service. In 2011, he unveiled plans to reduce troop numbers, cut bureaucracy and eliminate inefficiency in the Federal Ministry of Defense, turning the army into a wholly professional force. An ally of Chancellor Angela Merkel, he moved on to become interior minister.
Image: Reuters
Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg (CSU) 2009 - 2011
Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg was the youngest-ever German defense minister. He had to deal with the aftermath of a deadly airstrike in Kunduz but was cleared of being responsible for the Defense Ministry's inadequate communications policy on the incident. He oversaw the suspension of compulsory military service in 2011, but resigned after he was found to have plagiarized part of his doctoral thesis.
Image: picture alliance/dpa
Franz Josef Jung (CDU) 2005-2009
Jung rejected US demands that Germany participate in heavy fighting in southern Afghanistan and opted for the deployment of a rapid reaction force in northern Afghanistan instead. Jung later took political responsibility for the airstrikes in Kunduz, when a US fighter jet responded to a call by German forces, struck two fuel tankers captured by Taliban insurgents and killed over 90 civilians.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Peter Struck (SPD) 2002 - 2005
In his attempt to justify Germany's mission in Afghanistan, Peter Struck coined the much-quoted phrase "Germany will also be defended in the Hindu Kush." He oversaw the revamp of the Bundeswehr to become a nimbler fighting force capable of responding to smaller, regional conflicts. Struck announced in 2003 that Germany would reduce its military by more than 10% by 2010, leaving 250,000 troops.
Image: Kurt Vinion/Getty Images
Rudolf Scharping (SPD) 1998 - 2002
Under Rudolf Scharping, the Bundeswehr participated in NATO air strikes against Serbia, the first time German soldiers had operated outside Germany since World War II. In 2001, Scharping was criticized publicly by US Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld when he was found to be the source of a report that the United States would intervene in Somalia as part of their campaign against terrorism.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Volker Rühe (CDU) 1992 - 1998
Under former English teacher Volker Rühe, the Bundeswehr gradually began its foreign missions outside NATO territory. By supporting the United Nations missions in Cambodia, Somalia and the Balkans, the armed forces gained their first experience of foreign deployment.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Gerhard Stoltenberg (CDU) 1989 - 1992
Gerhard Stoltenberg, a former finance minister, headed the West German Defense Ministry at the time of reunification and assumed command and control of the all-German armed forces on October 3, 1990. The East German army, the Nationale Volksarmee, merged with the Bundeswehr, thereby leaving the eastern defense alliance "Warsaw Treaty" to join NATO instead.
Image: Sepp Spiegl/IMAGO
Rupert Scholz (CDU) 1988 - 1989
Rupert Scholz continued the policy of détente between the two military blocs just before the collapse of the Soviet Union. He was replaced in a Cabinet reshuffle in 1989 but later made headlines when he stated in 2007 that he felt Germany should strive to become a nuclear power.
Image: Sven Simon/United Archives/IMAGO
Manfred Wörner (CDU) 1982 - 1988
A former fighter pilot, Wörner later went on to become NATO's secretary-general. In 1983, Wörner faced criticism due to the scandal surrounding German General Günter Kiessling, who the military secret service falsely accused of being gay. Wörner ordered Kiessling's early retirement, as homosexuality was considered a security risk at the time.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Hans Apel (SPD) 1978 - 1982
Hans Apel (l) was the first West German defense minister not to have served in the army. During his tenure, NATO's Double-Track Decision was made, offering the Warsaw Pact a mutual limitation of ballistic missiles in 1979. It was combined with a threat by NATO to deploy more medium-range nuclear weapons in Western Europe.
Image: dapd
Georg Leber (SPD) 1972 - 1978
Georg Leber served in the Luftwaffe during World War II. The trade union leader was held in high esteem by the Bundeswehr rank and file. He oversaw an enlargement of the Bundeswehr and the creation of Bundeswehr universities in Munich and Hamburg. Leber stepped down after taking responsibility for a case of East German espionage in his ministry.
Image: Egon Steiner/dpa/picture alliance
Helmut Schmidt (SPD) 1969 - 1972
Helmut Schmidt, an officer in World War II, former mayor of Hamburg, and later Ffinance minister and chancellor of Germany, was the first member of the center-left Social Democrats to become defense minister. During his term, the service time for military conscripts was reduced from 15 to eight months.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Gerhard Schröder (CDU) 1966 - 1969
Gerhard Schröder had been first interior and then foreign minister before he took over the Defense Ministry under Chancellor Kurt-Georg Kiesinger. In 1969, he ran for the office of German president, supported by CDU and the far-right NPD, but was narrowly beaten by center-left candidate Gustav Heinemann.
Image: Kurt Rohwedder/dpa/picture alliance
Kai-Uwe von Hassel (CDU) 1963 - 1966
Early on, the Bundeswehr engaged in many civilian missions such as rescue missions during flood disasters and earthquakes. Its humanitarian missions began as early as the mid-1960s under Kai-Uwe von Hassel, who oversaw the expansion and gradual consolidation of the West German armed forces.
Image: Fritz Fischer/dpa/picture alliance
Franz-Josef Strauss (CSU) 1956 - 1963
The conservative from Bavaria held various government posts between 1953 and 1969. He was charged with the build-up of the new West German defence forces, the Bundeswehr, but in 1961, he and his party, the CSU, were suspected of taking bribes from US fighter jet maker Lockheed for arranging West Germany's purchase of 900 F-104G Starfighters. Strauss and the CSU denied the allegations.
Image: picture-alliance/F. Leonhardt
Theodor Blank (CDU) 1955 - 1956
Theodor Blank, born as the third of 10 children of a carpenter, was conscripted to the Wehrmacht when World War II broke out in 1939 and rose to become a first lieutenant. The staunch Catholic became one of the founders of the CDU in 1945. Following on from his short tenure as defense minister, he served as minister of labor and social affairs from 1957 to 1965.
Image: akg-images/picture alliance
20 images1 | 20
Unpopular predecessors
"Christine Lambrecht was hired, like her predecessors [Ursula von der Leyen and Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer — Editor's note], at a time when national defense was no longer considered to be of great importance," Gero Neugebauer, a political scientist at Berlin's Free University, told DW.
Advertisement
But Pistorius took office under different circumstances and immediately scored points with conservative-minded Germans, Neugebauer added.
Little known to many in and outside of Germany, Pistorius was a surprise choice for the role of defense minister. In appointing a man to the post, Chancellor Olaf Scholz broke his pledge to maintain gender parity in the Cabinet.
Pistorius, a law graduate and former mayor of the northwestern city of Osnabrück, comes from the law and order wing of his party. He undertook his mandatory military service from 1980 to 1981. But he has no extensive military experience and was unfamiliar with federal — let alone international — politics.
Johann Wadephul, the deputy chairman of the center-right opposition Christian Democratic Union (CDU)grouping in the federal parliament, the Bundestag, described Pistorius' appointment as a selection from the "B team."
Nevertheless, Pistorius has a solid reputation as a politician who gets things done. He was responsible for introducing extensive reforms to the police force in Lower Saxony where he helped to bring in new recruits and improve citizen outreach, as well as prioritizing the fight against political extremism.
Close ties with the chancellor
At the time of Pistorius' appointment, Scholz — who also hails from Osnabrück — described his new Cabinet minister as an "outstanding politician." "With his experience, competence, and assertiveness, as well as his big heart, he is exactly the right person for the Bundeswehr at this turning point," Scholz said.
Like Scholz, Pistorius also ran for the leadership of the SPD in 2019 and, like Scholz, also lost. The latest polling, however, indicates Pistorius is way ahead of the competition.
After his debut appearance in the role of defense minister at the Munich Security Conference this past weekend, the Swiss daily Neue Zürcher Zeitung reported that Pistorius was being touted as a potential "leader."
"Pistorius communicates clearly and directly, but not in such a way that others might feel offended," political scientist Neugebauer told DW. "He is demanding but not a showoff, and often meets personally with the soldiers, which has earned him a reputation as someone who cares."
This clear and direct approach was on show in Munich as Pistorius announced that "Ukraine must win this war" — in contrast to the chancellor's "Ukraine must not lose the war, Russia must not win the war."
Pistorius reaffirmed Germany's pledge to reach NATO's military spending target of 2% of GDP — Germany's military spending reached about 1.5% of its GDP in 2022. "By 2025, we will put at NATO's disposal a full army division," he added.
In early February, less than a month after taking office, the defense minister made an unannounced visit to Ukraine — his first foreign trip in the role. Pistorius met with President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and his counterpart, Oleksii Reznikov, and announced a plan to dispatch more than 100 Leopard 1A5 tanks, in addition to the already approved delivery of modern Leopard 2 battle tanks to Ukraine.
Fresh from his well-received appearance at the Munich Security Conference, Pistorius demonstrated his caring, hands-on approach during a visit to Ukrainian troops being trained in the German city of Munster on Monday.
"Talking about a war is different from looking into the faces of people who [...] came here directly from the front line, and who will go back there with the tanks once they have completed their training," he told reporters.
But Pistorius has made it clear this is not enough — he is asking for an additional €10 billion for the defense budget (currently €50 billion) to build up the military after more than three decades of chronic neglect and underfunding.
With budget negotiations for 2024 and 2025 due to take place in March, there are already rumblings of a division within his own party over how exactly the money should be allocated. In an interview with the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper, SPD leader Saskia Esken appeared to be setting Pistorius certain limits, for example, in highlighting coalition projects such as fighting child poverty.
It remains to be seen whether the defense minister will deliver.
"Pistorius hasn't enjoyed a 'grace period' because he did not want one and knew he would not have one and therefore didn't ask for one: he's a doer," said Neugebauer. "When the piano needs to be moved to another room in the apartment, he is not the one carrying the sheet music."
Edited by: Rina Goldenberg
While you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter Berlin Briefing.