This Xmas, think plastic trees and homemade presents
Suzanne Cords
December 24, 2022
Would you rather buy a plastic tree or use a real one, even if it died after the festivities?
Advertisement
When Sylvia Meier looks out of the window, she sees a beautiful fir tree standing two meters high. Red baubles and fairy lights hang from the branches.
"That's my Christmas tree," she says, "and has been for many years."
She bought it as a small tree in a pot for the holiday season and then planted it in the garden after Christmas.
How Christmas has changed in Germany since 1945
Germany may be the home of many of the world's Christmas traditions. But how the holiday is celebrated here has gone through significant changes over the last seven decades.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/S. Stache
German Christmas: From bust to boom, and back again
Christmas has gone through changes in Germany. From post-war hunger and essential-gifts-only to the luxury of the country's economic miracle in the 1950s, to this year's debate on whether powering up extravagant Christmas lights are ethical, when there is war in Europe.
Image: Thomas Kienzle/AFP/Getty Images
Christmas after the war
1945: Germany was still in ruins during the first Christmas after a devastating war. Refugees and homeless people roamed the streets as survivors started rebuilding a nation that had been destroyed by war. That Christmas, people were simply focused on finding shelter and enough food to survive a long winter.
Image: Getty Images
Postwar celebrations
1946-1949: Charity organizations distributed gifts, chocolate and sweets to impoverished children during years that were marked by hunger for many. It was said that the lack of food and housing also brought people together. Many made a great effort to somehow celebrate Christmas with what little food or gifts they had.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Christmas during the economic boom
1950s: As West Germany began to develop thanks to a postwar economic and industrial boom, Christmas celebrations reflected growing affluence. Most gifts were still practical in nature such as clothes, bed linen or cookery utensils but children also started to receive new toys.
Image: Orlando /Three Lions/Getty Images
Festival of peace
1950-1959: As Communist-led East Germany solidified a secular, socialist ideal, its leadership decided to "de-Christianize" Christmas, just as the Nazi regime had attempted to do in the 1930s and 1940s. Christmas became a non-religious family gathering named "year's end fest" or "peace festival."
Image: picture-alliance/ ZB
East Germany's export hits
1960-1969: Traditional wood carvings from the Ore Mountains in Saxony near the border with former Czechoslovakia were highly popular, including in West Germany. They soon turned into one of East Germany's bestselling exports.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/R. Hirschberger
Growing consumerism in the West
1960-1969: In West Germany, people were becoming more prosperous. Christmas gifts grew more valuable and expensive, extending into new areas such as technology and luxury goods. But at the same time, more people were criticizing the new consumerist spirit of the event, ostensibly eroding the Christian origins of the holiday.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Germany's most important festivities
1970s: The growing culture of gift giving turned Christmas into the most important holiday of the year for retailers. Theologians complained that Easter was actually the most significant day in the Christian calendar and that the meaning of Christmas was being corrupted and commercialized.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/S. Stache
Consumerism under the tree
1980s: West Germans had finally arrived in the age of mass consumerism. Gifts were no longer essential items and people bought things for fun rather than out of real need.
1990s: After the country's reunification in 1989, many families who had been separated by borders between East and West Germany spent the holiday together for the first time. Many East Germans opted to shop for presents in the West, helping business boom in the west even as the economy slumped in the east.
Image: Fotolia/Tyler Olson
Christmas in the new Millennium
By 2023, polls show only around 56% of Germans consider themselves secular, believing in no religion. A growing number of young people in Germany attend "Christmas after-parties," events they'd go to after the customary spartan dinner and gift-giving at home. With a more relaxed attitude toward the religious aspect of the festivities, Christmas becomes more of a social event.
In 2022, the energy crisis due to the war in Ukraine led German politicians to recommend abstaining from Christmas lighting to save power. Amid the climate emergency, there has also been debates surrounding how ethical it is to have elaborately-lit Christmas displays: Was it really necessary to have that Santa Claus hanging from the balcony, or a fleet of reindeer with blinking noses on your roof?
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/S. Stache
12 images1 | 12
'The most sustainable tree is not a tree'
From the point of view of many Germans, Sylvia has done everything right. After all, she says, around 30 million trees are cut down every Christmas just to put them in German living rooms. However, not everyone has a garden like the Meier family. And even if they do, many trees don't survive outside at all because they've been in the warm house for too long. So what's the solution?
Advertisement
"To put it bluntly, the most sustainable tree is not a tree," Corinna Hölzel from the environmental organization Friends of the Earth Germany (BUND) told the media outlet Redaktionsnetzwerk Deutschland. "Or a tree that would be cut down anyway during forestry measures — that is, a waste product." However, since this would not cover the quantity requirements of all households, alternatives are in demand, because "we do not want to ban the tradition of Christmas trees, of course," the environmental expert added.
The tree simply belongs
Contrary to what many think, however, a reusable plastic tree is definitely not an alternative. Because although it does its duty for decades on Christmas Eve, it eventually ends up in the trash. And unlike the real tree, it is not biodegradable.
On the other hand, about 80% of the fir trees planted for Christmas in Germany come from monoculture — the practice of growing one crop species in a field at a time — with fertilizers and pesticides included. If you want to celebrate in an environmentally friendly way, you should at least buy a tree from regional ecological cultivation, BUND advises.
And many people are now doing just that, because, according to a survey by the broadcaster ARD, only 24% of Germans want to do without a tree altogether; it's simply part of the festivities. In 2022, however, festive lighting in the home and garden will be cut back considerably due to the energy crisis. This is good news for the environment, because as long as electricity is generated from fossil fuels, CO2 emissions will rise.
The fight against mountains of waste
And what about the wrapping paper? Year after year, the trash cans in Germany overflow.
According to estimates by the stationery and book publisher Dabelino, about 8,000 tons of wrapping paper end up in the trash every year in Germany alone. But here, too, there are signs of a trend reversal. According to the study, 50% of respondents want to reduce wrapping paper for the sake of the environment.
In many families old paper is reused. And around 20% of Germans no longer want to support the consumerist frenzy, but only want to put homemade items on the gift table.
Sustainable tourism: Our recommendations for ecofriendly travel
After more than two years of pandemic-related restrictions, people are eager to get back to traveling. Let us show you how to satisfy your wanderlust, yet keep your carbon footprint small.
Image: Rüdiger Wölk/IMAGO
Don't fly!
If you want to reach your destination in an environmentally friendly way, you should avoid using air travel as a means of transport. Trains are much better. And if the service allows bikes to be taken along, as is the case for this vacationer at Münster train station, that's even better.
Image: Rüdiger Wölk/IMAGO
Put your car on the train!
If it is absolutely necessary to take your own vehicle to a faraway holiday destination, German Rail company DB's Autozug (car train) is the ideal means of transport. Although there are currently only a handful of connections, long distances, for example from northern Germany to Italy, can be covered in a much more relaxed manner by rail than with your own vehicle.
Image: Action Pictures/IMAGO
The night train
Travelling on a night train is an unforgettable experience. Deutsche Bahn pulled out of the business years ago, but is now offering night connections in cooperation with other European competitors. These trains have become established as important means of transport in countries likes France, Poland and Sweden.
Another way to reduce your carbon footprint is to pack light and leave some room in your bag or suitcase. That way you'll have to carry less. And can even bring home some souvenirs on the way back.
Image: Monika Skolimowska/picture alliance/dpa
Avoid waste with reusable tableware
A picnic in beautiful surroundings is to be savored, especially on holiday. To avoid littering nature with plastic or other waste, it's a good idea to bring reusable tableware. And be sure to take your leftovers back home.
Image: Christin Klose/picture alliance/dpa
Choose small hotels
All-inclusive deals at large resorts can be appealling and are often comparatively cheap. But often, hotel staff pay the price, earning low wages and enduring poor working conditions, with managers pocketing the profits. That's why it's better to stay at small hotels, for example here in the village of Stavna in Montenegro.
Image: MartinxSiepmann/imagebroker/IMAGO
Pick unconventional hotels
If you're bored by conventional holidays, pick a quirky establishment instead, for example this "barrel hotel" in Razvode, Croatia. Guests stay in old wine barrels with luxurious interiors, each fitted with its own bathroom. Outside, there's a pool for everyone to use.
Image: Hrvoje Jelavic/PIXSELL/picture alliance
Support local businesses
Travelers who are committed to sustainability should support small businesses. Local craftsmen, hoteliers or fruit and vegetable traders benefit tremendously when you put your money into the local economy.
Image: Daniel Gammert/picture alliance/dpa
Book local guides
Vacationers can find out which operators pay tour guides decent wages. Fairunterwegs.org (German for fair journey), for example, lists numerous respectable operators known for their ethical practices. It is a good idea to support such businesses.
Image: Fabian von Poser/imageBROKER/picture alliance
Keep insider tips a secret
If you discover a virtually untouched place on a vacation, you shouldn't broadcast it to the world via social media. There are many examples, such Thailand's Maya Bay, which were hyped as "insider tips" on Instagram, Facebook and then overrun by tourists. So best to keep hidden gems secret!
Image: YAY Images/IMAGO
10 images1 | 10
Consuming more consciously
This also applies to food, which is increasingly being consumed more consciously than in earlier times. Some 39% of Germans say they want to eat regional foods at Christmas. So gone are the days of unrestrained feasting orgies; more and more people are eating healthily, many vegetarian or vegan, often for the sake of the environment.
After all, 70% of all Germans are now in favor of a more environmentally friendly Christmas. So something is happening under the Christmas tree.
"However, it does little good to think about sustainability only at Christmas," the environmental psychologist Karen Hamann told ARD. "We should try to reduce our climate-damaging behavior throughout the year from areas such as air travel, mobility, energy and nutrition," she said. "On the other hand, we shouldn't condemn ourselves over every little thing either."
Silvia Meier agrees. And that's why she has already picked out her grandma's recipe for the traditional roast goose, as she does every year. "Maybe not entirely climate-friendly," she says, "but my family is already looking forward to it." Except her daughter Antonia, who gets to enjoy vegan tofu.