Germany's AfD files suit against spy agency
February 7, 2019
The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) has filed a lawsuit against the domestic intelligence agency.
The lawsuit, which the party filed at an administrative court in Cologne, seeks to ban the Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV) from publicly reporting on its decision to treat the AfD as a so-called "test case."
It accuses the BfV of among other things making "defamatory statements about a party" and violating "neutrality and objectivity." It also seeks a fine of up to €10,000 ($11,400) for each time the BfV made the statements.
The Süddeutsche Zeitung and public broadcasters NDR and WDR first reported on the suit.
Read more: Can Germany’s far-right AfD be subjected to surveillance?
Spy agency discrediting the AfD?
The third-largest party in the German parliament said it sought legal action against the BfV because the publication of information about the test case decision had "stigmatized" the party.
"The complaint is not aimed at the fact that the intelligence agency is monitoring the AfD, but at the fact that the agency has made this public," a party spokesman said.
In the absence of an official decision, the BfV lacks a legal basis for spreading "public-discrediting communication," according to AfD lawyers.
Read more: German bloggers release classified intelligence report on far-right AfD
Precursor to surveillance
In January, the BfV announced it would treat the AfD's federal party as a test case, signaling it was worried about right-wing extremism within a party.
The categorization means the BfV can use open-source material to investigate whether the party poses a threat to the constitutional order. It does not allow the BfV to use undercover agents or other intelligence methods to collect information.
However, a test case is considered a possible precursor to full surveillance using all available intelligence gathering techniques.
Read more: Extreme-right defectors deal a blow to Germany's far-right AfD
cw/amp (dpa, AFP)