While the Bern exhibition focuses on "degenerate art," the Bonn show includes mainly Nazi-looted artworks or those of questionable provenance. The works from Cornelius Gurlitt's estate have caused ownership controversy.
Advertisement
Gurlitt collection shown in Bern
The exhibition "Gurlitt Inventory. Denerate Art" opened in November 2017, with the Bern Art Museum revealing, for the first time, works discovered in the Gurlitt private collection in Munich. Here are a few.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle
August Macke: Landscape With Sailboats
"Of all of us, he gave the brightest and purest timbre to color," declared Franz Marc after his friend and fellow artist August Macke fell in World War I in 1914. Macke painted his sailboat images at Lake Tegernsee in Bavaria. This painting was among the roughly 1,500 found in the Cornelius Gurlitt collection.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle
Otto Mueller: Reclining Female Nude at Waterside
Slender women are a characteristic motif of the influential German expressionist art movement. This model reposes unclothed on a water-surrounded rock.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle
Ernst Ludwig Kirchner: "Melancholy Girl"
A difficult, suspicious and depressed man, Kirchner created this wood cutting in 1922. Nazis removed many of his works from German museums and defamed them as "degenerate." Born in the German region of Franconia, Kirchner was buried in Switzerland.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle
Otto Dix: Leonie
The artist had a reputation for social criticism even as a young man. "I can't get ahead; my paintings can't be sold. I'm either becoming famous or infamous," he said in 1920, not long before finishing this painting.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle
Emil Nolde: Broad Landscape with Clouds
"My homeland was like a fairytale, my parents' home in the flat countryside, thousands of larks soaring up and down in jubilation, my country of wonder from sea to sea," enthused the North German painter Maler Emil Nolde. Broad expanses and the blurred transitions between sky, earth and water were his motifs.
Image: Kunst- und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland
Franz Marc: Sitting Horse
No motif or animal fascinated Marc more than horse, a metaphor for purity and innocence in the eyes of this expressionist painter. His daring experimentation with color resulted in a group of paintings of blue horses in 1910. This image, also in the Gurlitt collection, was a predecessor.
Image: Kunst- und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland
6 images1 | 6
It's a double exhibition that packs a punch, with the Bern Art Museum and Bonn's Bundeskunsthalle (National Art Museum) for the first time showing a large part of the artwork from the private collection of Cornelius Gurlitt. Discovered in a spectacular find in 2012 and then confiscated, the works stimulated worldwide discussion about art stolen by the Nazi regime.
The Swiss exhibition opened on Thursday, November 2. Titled "'Degenerate Art' — Confiscated and Sold," it includes about 150 works. "We are telling the history of 'degenerate art' and placing it in the context of campaigns waged against contemporary art since the late 19th century," said Bern's Art Museum Director Nina Zimmer.
Opening on Friday, November 3, the exhibition in Bonn is titled "Gurlitt: Status Report" and focuses on artworks taken from Jewish collectors or those whose provenance is largely unknown.
Cornelius Gurlitt, who died in 2014, bequeathed his father's complete collection to the Bern Art Museum. An art merchant for Adolf Hitler,Hildebrand Gurlitt had traded objects forcibly taken from individuals, including the painting "Zwei Reiter vom Strand" (Two Riders on the Beach) by Max Liebermann. Evading an examination by the postwar "Art Looting Investigation Unit," the elder Gurlitt died in 1956, and his son guarded the approximately 1,500 works of art.
"After accepting the inheritance, a difficult time began for all participants," said Marcel Brülhart, vice president of the Bern Art Museum Foundation. Provenance research proved far more difficult than anticipated, he said, and the cost of legal actions has been exorbitant.
How Hitler and the Nazis defamed art
Before he was a dictator, Adolf Hitler was a painter. The "Führer" categorized works of art according to his personal taste. Works he hated were branded "degenerate art" and removed from museums.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Degenerate art
Modern artworks whose style, artist or subject did not meet with the approval of Adolf Hitler and the National Socialists were labeled "degenerate art." From 1937, the Nazis confiscated such works from German museums. In a traveling exhibition, "degenerate art" was held up for public ridicule. Here we see Reich Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels and Hitler at the original exhibition in Munich.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Hitler's art
Hitler had an affinity for Romanticism and 19th century painting and preferred peaceful country scenes. His private collection included works by Cranach, Tintoretto and Bordone. Like his role models Ludwig I. of Bavaria and Frederick the Great, Hitler wanted to manage his own art exhibition at retirement, to be shown in the city of Linz on the River Danube in the "Führer Museum."
Image: picture-alliance/Everett Collection/Actual Films
The confiscations
The National Socialists were not the first to persecute avant-garde artists, but they took it a step further by banning their works from museums. In 1937, the authorities had over 20,000 art works removed from 101 state-owned German museums. Anything that the Nazis didn't consider edifying to the German people was carted off.
Image: Victoria & Alber Museum
Hitler's national style
Abstract art had no place in Hitler's "national style," as grew clear when the "Great German Art Exhibition" put traditional landscape, historical and nude paintings by artists including Fritz Erler, Hermann Gradl and Franz Xaver Stahl on display in Munich on July 18, 1937. The closer the depicted subject to the actual model was, the more beautiful it was in the eyes of the Führer.
Image: Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-C10110/CC-BY-SA
What was considered degenerate
Even those in Hitler's inner circle were highly unsure which artists he approved of. The 1937 "Great German Art Exhibition" and the simultaneous "Degerate Art" exhibition in Munich's Court Garden Arcades brought some clarity. Unwelcome were creative artists of the modern period including Max Beckmann, Otto Dix, Wassily Kandinsky, Paul Klee, Ernst Ludwig Kirchner and Max Pechstein.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Degenerate art on tour
In the "Degerate Art" exhibition, 650 confiscated artworks from 32 German museums were on display, the exhibits equated with sketches by mentally handicapped persons and shown together with photos of crippled persons. The intention: to provoke revulsion and aversion among visitors. Over two million visitors saw the exhibition on its tour of various cities.
Image: cc-by-sa/Bundesarchiv
Legal foundation
The "Degenerate Artworks Confiscation Law" of May 31, 1938 retroactively legalized their unremunerated acquisition by the state. The law remained valid in the postwar years, the allies determining that it had simply been a redistribution of state property. Unlike stolen artworks, pieces that the Nazis labled "degenerate" and had removed from museums can be freely traded today.
Image: CC by Österreichische Nationalbibliothek
The "degenerate art" trade
The confiscated art was taken to storage facilities in Berlin and at Schönhausen Palace. Many works were sold by Hitler's four art merchants: Bernhard A. Böhmer, Karl Buchholz, Hildebrand Gurlitt and Ferdinand Möller. On March 20, 1939 the Berlin fire department burned approximately 5,000 unsold artifacts, calling it an "exercise."
125 works were earmarked for an auction in Switzerland. A commission charged by Hermann Göring and others with liquefying the "degenerate" art products estimated the minimum bidding prices and commissioned the Fischer Gallery in Lucerne to carry out the auction. Taking place on June 30, 1939, it met with eager interest worldwide.
Image: picture alliance/dpa
Much "degenerate art" in the Gurlitt collection
Over 21,000 works of "degenerate art" were confiscated. Estimates on the number subsequently sold differ; sources estimate 6,000 to 10,000. Others were destroyed or disappeared. Hundreds of artworks believed lost turned up in Cornelius Gurlitt's collection — and reignited the discussion.
Image: privat/Nachlass Cornelius Gurlitt
10 images1 | 10
Consequences in Switzerland
The affair has also reignited discussion over whether the Washington Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art are being properly executed in Switzerland. The principles published in 1998 outline precets that should govern the restitution of Nazi-looted art to its original owners,
Historian Georg Kreis says that, "Provenance research is now being taken more seriously" in Switzerland, although the subject had been on the agenda before the Gurlitt find in 2012. "Otherwise people wouldn't have overreacted at the discovery and immediately declared the entire collection to be looted art," adds Kreis. According to current knowledge however, only six of the works from Gurlitt's estate had apparently been looted, while many others are still being investigated. Read more:How Germany has dealt with Nazi-looted art after spectacular Gurlitt case
The controversy swirling around the Gurlitt inheritance has widened the discussion beyond legal considerations. "The issue of the Holocaust must be recognised in its full catastrophic consequences,” says Georg Kreis. "It's not just about money. It's about recognizing that material losses occurred in connection with a enormous historical monstrosity."
The pieces shown in Bern focus on "degenerate art," with most of their origins clarified. The more sensitive side of the Gurlitt collection is in Bonn, exploring "Nazi-Stolen Art and the Consequences" and focusing on artworks taken from Jewish collectors. Many of the 250 works are suspected to have been stolen, and in some instances the sources have not been sufficiently clarified — including works by Breughel, Beckmann and Dix. Added to each exhibit is a list of previous owners, insofar as research has been able to determine.
Embedded in a historical context, the exhibition chronologically follows the life of Hildebrand Gurlitt and demonstrates how the art merchant worked and personally profited in the Nazi system. The exhibit also traces political and social developments during the Third Reich and the explores the fates of individual Jewish artists and art collectors.
With 1,039 objects from the Gurlitt depot under study, reports are expected to be released in 2018. Project Director Andrea Baresel-Brand estimates that in roughly two-thirds of the cases, it will not be possible to clarify the provenance. But Rein Wolfs, head of Bonn's Bundeskunsthalle, summed it up, saying, "Every stolen work of art is one too many. Every restitution to its rightful owners is a huge success."
The research into the Gurlitt find is in fact work in progress. Reflecting the status quo in September 2018, another "Gurlitt: Status Report" is scheduled for showing in the Martin Gropius Building in Berlin.
Gurlitt Collection: Germany's most infamous Nazi-looted art trove
So far, only 14 works were proven to have been looted under the Nazis among the some 1,500 found in Gurlitt's hoard.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle / Foto: David Ertl
Carl Spitzweg, 'Playing the Piano,' ca. 1840
This drawing by Carl Spitzweg was seized in 1939 from Jewish music publisher Heinri Hinrichsen, who was killed at the Auschwitz death camp in 1942. It was acquired by Nazi art dealer Hildebrand Gurlitt — and later found among the spectacular collection of works hoarded by his son, Cornelius Gurlitt. The work was auctioned by Christie's at the request of Hinrichsen's heirs.
Image: Staatsanwaltschaft Augsburg/Lost Art Datenbank
Max Beckmann, 'Zandvoort Beach Cafe,' 1934
The watercolor by the Jewish painter Max Beckmann entered Gurlitt's collection only in 1945. Held by the allied occupation forces at the Central Collecting Point in Wiesbaden from 1945-1950, it was returned to Hildebrand Gurlitt in 1950. Before working for the Nazi regime, Gurlitt had collected and exhibited modern art, curating Beckmann's last exhibition in 1936 before the artist fled Germany.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle / Foto: David Ertl
Otto Griebel, 'Veiled Woman,' 1926
This work was owned by lawyer and art collector Fritz Salo Glaser. Artists of Dresden's avant-garde scene were his guests in the 1920s — as was the young Hildebrand Gurlitt. It is not known how Gurlitt came to possess the painting. It was confiscated in 1945 and later returned. Of Jewish heritage, Glaser only narrowly avoided deportation to the Theresienstadt concentration camp in 1945.
Image: Kunst- und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland GmbH / Foto: David Ertl
Claude Monet, 'Waterloo Bridge,' 1903
This painting by the famous impressionist is not suspected to have been looted. The artist sold it to the Durand Ruel Gallery in 1907. The Jewish art merchant and publisher Paul Cassirer is said to have given it to Marie Gurlitt as a present, and she left it to her son Hildebrand Gurlitt in 1923.
Image: Kunst- und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland GmbH / Foto: David Ertl
Thomas Couture, 'Portrait of a Seated Young Woman,' 1850
A short handwritten note allowed provenance researchers to identify this work by the French painter as a looted work of art. The picture was seized from the collection of Jewish politician and resistance leader Georges Mandel, who was executed by French fascists near Paris in 1944. German Culture Minister Monika Grütters (right) handed over the work to Mandel's heirs in January 2019.
Image: picture-alliance/AP Photo/M. Schreiber
Paul Signac, 'Quai de Clichy,' 1887
The activist group Provenance Research Gurlitt identified this painting by French neo-impressionist Paul Signac as stolen Jewish property in October 2018. Gaston Prosper Levy fled Nazi-occupied France in 1940. Occupying soldiers are believed to have looted his art collection shortly before his escape. The painting was returned to Levy's family in 2019.
Image: picture-alliance/Keystone/A. Anex
Auguste Rodin, 'Crouching Woman,' approx. 1882
Hildebrand Gurlitt must have acquired this work by the French sculptor between 1940 and 1945. Previously belonging to the Frenchman Eugene Rudier, it entered circulation in 1919 at an auction by Octave Henri Marie Mirbeau, who is said to have received it as a present from the artist.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle / Foto: David Ertl
Albrecht Dürer, Knight, Death and Devil, 1513
This copper engraving by Albrecht Dürer once belonged to the Falkeisen-Huber Gallery in Basel. It is not known how it got there or how long it was there however. In 2012 the engraving turned up in Cornelius Gurlitt's collection. "Old masters" like Dürer were very important to the National Socialists' view of art and were often exploited for propaganda.
Image: Kunst- und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland GmbH / Foto: David Ertl
Edvard Munch, 'Ashes II,' 1899
The provenance of this drawing is completely unknown. It is certain, however, that Hitler considered Norwegian artist Edvard Munch's work "degenerate art." Some 82 pieces by Munch were confiscated in German museums in 1937.
Image: Bundeskunsthalle/Foto: Mick Vincenz
Francois Boucher, 'Male Nude,' undated
Hitler venerated 18th-century French painting. He secured exceptional paintings for his own collection by targeting the collection of the Rothschild Family after the annexation of Austria. Hildebrand Gurlitt supplemented them with drawings by renowned French painters. He acquired this work by Boucher from a Parisian art merchant in 1942.
Image: Kunst- und Ausstellungshalle der Bundesrepublik Deutschland GmbH / Foto: David Ertl
In Gurlitt's apartment
Cornelius Gurlitt hoarded the sculpture along with many other artworks for decades in his Munich apartment. Before his death in 2014, he consented to have his stocks researched and — should they include articles of stolen art — have them returned to their rightful owners in accordance with the Washington Principles on Nazi-looted art.