A new exhibition looks at how the Nazis used opera as a powerful tool of propaganda, especially during the Nuremberg Rallies. Hitler was personally involved in the staging of some epic Wagner productions.
Advertisement
Hitler had declared Nuremberg the "City of the Nazi Party Rallies" in 1933, deciding that the medieval city's traditional role as a center of German trade, art and culture would provide a fitting backdrop for his epic, annual staged rallies — as would the municipal stadium, theaters, lakes and parks in which the vast annual events were held.
But for both Hitler and Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels — who oversaw the censoring and distribution of film, music, theater and the visual arts in the Third Reich — German music, and especially opera, would lend vital propagandistic impact to these mass Nazi military gatherings.
A new exhibition in Nuremberg's Documentation Center Nazi Party Rally Grounds graphically tells the story of how the Nuremberg Opera House and the site where the massive annual Nazi parades were held were dual stages through which art propaganda was instrumentalized by a murderous regime.
The title of the show, Hitler.Macht.Oper, is a play on the double meaning of the German word "Macht," which translates both as "makes" and "power"; the Führer himself was personally involved in some aspects of the opera stagings that celebrated his leadership.
Spanning 530 meters (1,740 feet) of the Great Hall on the former rally site, the new exhibition employs text, images, film and elaborate stage reconstructions to allow viewers to experience the full force of this powerful propaganda tool.
The Mastersingers
Richard Wagner's Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg (The Mastersingers of Nuremberg) is a four-and-a-half hour operatic odyssey and National Socialist favorite that was performed at the Berlin State Opera to mark the founding of the Third Reich in March 1933.
This "most German of all operas" fit the bill in terms of Nazi art propaganda, portraying the eponymous master singer Hans Sachs as a patriotic creative genius who works above all in the service of his people — and race.
The work made a triumphant return to its namesake city when the Act III prelude featured in Leni Riefenstahl's 1935 Nazi propaganda film, Triumph of the Will, which depicted the 1934 Nazi Party Congress in Nuremberg attended by hundreds of thousands of Nazi supporters.
The Nazis wove anti-Semitism into their films, often quite subtly, as part of their propaganda scheme. How should these films be treated today?
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Hitler's favorite director
Leni Riefenstahl was among the Nazi filmmakers who tried to redeem their reputations after 1945. She was responsible for filming the Nazi party's massive rallies and was an integral part of the propaganda machine. Anti-Semitism was inseparable from the party's ideology.
Image: picture alliance/Keystone
Retelling history with anti-Semitic twist
"Jud Süss," one of the Nazis' most famous propaganda films, which is restricted today, was directed by Viet Harlan in 1940. Harlan tells the historical tale of 18th-century German-Jewish banker Joseph Süss Oppenheimer and places it in the context of anti-Semitic Nazi propaganda. "Jud Süss" was seen by millions of Germans when it was first released.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Mixing anti-Semitism with 'art'
In Harlan's film, anti-Semitic prejudices are underlined by the plot and the way the characters are portrayed. The writer Ralph Giordano said, "Jud Süss" was the "most mean-spirited, cruel and refined form of 'artistic anti-Semitism.'" Michael Töteberg wrote, "The film openly mobilizes sexual fears and aggression and instrumentalizes them for anti-Semitic incitement."
Image: Unbekannt
'The devil's director'
His biographer once called Veit Harlan "the devil's director," due to his unabashed service to Nazi ideology. Harlan had "qualified" himself to make "Jud Süss" after making his own films with anti-Semitic tendencies in the 1930s. After 1945, the director was able to continue working after going on trial and serving a temporary occupational ban.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Dealing with propaganda films - in film
Much was written and said about Viet Harlan and his anti-Semitic film "Jud Süss" after the war. At least one response to Harlan's work was uttered in film form. Director Oskar Roehler dealt with the origin and effect of the propaganda film in his melodramatic, controversial film "Jud Suss: Rise and Fall" (2010).
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/Concorde Filmverleih
Joseph Goebbels pulled the strings
The Nazis were quick to recognize that cinema could have a powerful effect in swaying the people. Joseph Goebbels and his Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda used the medium to promote their ideologies, including anti-Semitism. Besides feature films like "Jud Süss," cultural and educational films were also made.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
A so-called documentary
Another Nazi-made anti-Semitic film was "The Eternal Jew," released just a few months after "Jud Süss" in 1940. The film, made by Fritz Hippler, shows well-known Jewish artists, scenes from the Warsaw Ghetto and images of Jewish religious practices, combining them in a deceitful manner with excerpts from Hitler's speeches and SS marches. The propaganda work was billed as a documentary.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Devil in the details
Most of the propaganda films the Nazis made between 1933 and 1945 used smaller doses of anti-Semitism and were not as overt as "Jud Süss." Some films were even toned down during production. The historical film "Bismarck" (1940) was originally planned as a much more aggressive anti-Semitic propaganda film.
Image: Picture-alliance/akg-images
Anti-Semitism from the perspective of Charlie Chaplin
During the war, Hollywood produced a number of anti-Nazi films that condemned anti-Semitism. Charlie Chaplin humorously portrayed Hitler in "The Great Dictator" in 1940. After the war, Chaplin said he would have acted differently, had he been aware of the extent of the Nazis' extermination policy against the Jews.
Image: AP
9 images1 | 9
The year the film was released, an epic rendering of Die Meistersinger opened the Nuremberg Rally at the Nuremberg Opera House. Performed by a high-caliber star ensemble selected by Hitler himself, and featuring opulent staging by Nazi designer and architect Benno von Arent, the tone was set for future Third Reich productions.
As detailed in the Hitler.Macht.Oper exhibition, Hitler himself ordered the reconstruction of the Nuremberg Opera House in 1934, such was its symbolic significance. Star Nazi architect Paul Schultze-Naumburg was charged with purging the "bourgeois, avant-garde architecture" of the Art Nouveau building and creating a more minimal and brutalist interior that reflected the institution's dual function as a venue for art and politics.
The annual Nuremberg Rally was itself subject to a strict stage direction. The epic militarily-influenced backdrop utilized typical theater staging such as floodlights, music, stages and decoration. Composer Friedrich Jung was therefore commissioned to create a monumental piece to be played during the "Great Appeal of the Political Leaders" ceremony during the 1939 Rally, which was however cancelled at short notice, as a day before its planned start on September 2, Germany invaded Poland.
Wagner and Nazi opera
Wagner's own anti-Semitism was no doubt also part of the appeal for Hitler, who was a long-time fan of the dramatic composer.
On the 200th anniversary of the composer's birth in 2013, the BBC asked: "Can we listen to, watch or perform Wagner's music with a clear conscience? Was Wagner's music despicably perverted by the Nazis, or did their adulation merely expose its inherent perversions?"
While the BBC piece acknowledged that Wagner was not a Nazi, he was indeed anti-Semitic. "Wagner had already made his monstrous sentiments clear, beginning with his infamous 1850 treatise On Jewishness in Music," noted the broadcaster.
Hitler was a true opera lover, attending performances almost daily during the time he lived in Vienna. In Mein Kampf, he described his first witnessing of a performance of the opera Lohengrin at age 12 as a life-changing experience.
The dictator liked to inspire the Nazi leadership with his favorite Wagner opera, Rienzi, a proto-fascist story of an Italian nationalist who rises up against Rome's corrupt elites. Like Die Meistersinger, these were stories of great saviors of the people that would become analogous with Hitler and would help promote his own cult of personality.
'Degenerate' music
In 1938, the Nazis celebrated a week of nationalistic music with the Reichsmusiktage, or Reich's music days, with Hitler youth choir and Berlin Philharmonic performances; but a concurrent exhibition, Entartete Musik (Degenerate Music), in Düsseldorf was used to denounce and ridicule "unGerman" black and Jewish music.
Half a year after the infamous Degenerate Art exhibition, Jewish composers like Arnold Schoenberg, Kurt Weill and Hanns Eisler (who later composed the East German national anthem), in addition to African-American jazz musicians, were pilloried by a regime that was also busily promoting Wagnerian opera, including to foreign observers.
However, in secret, the self-appointed Messiah of the German people actually had a predilection for diverse forms of music.
Hitler's record collection, which was rediscovered in 2007, included Russian composers such as Peter Tchaikovsky, Alexander Borodin and Sergei Rachmaninoff that the Nazis had labeled as "subhuman," according to a Der Spiegel report — indeed, star violinist Bronislaw Huberman, a Polish Jew, featured on one of the found Tchaikovsky recordings.
Largest exhibition of its kind
The exhibition at Nuremberg's Documentation Center Former Nazi Party Rally
Grounds, located on the actual site where the rallies where held, features over 350 exhibits that includes an array of original audio and video clips, scholarly texts, image collages, eyewitness accounts and theater stage and set design recreations.
It is divided into seven themes such as "Mastersingers," "Opera" and "Twilight of the Gods" — or Götterdämmerung in German, the name of Wagner's opera that was one of the last to be staged by the Nazi regime in 1944 in the bomb-damaged Nuremberg Opera House.
The exhibition is the largest of its kind on the subject of music theater under National Socialism since the renowned exhibition on "degenerate" music in Düsseldorf in 1988.
Hitler.Macht.Oper runs from June 15 through February 3, 2019.
How Hitler and the Nazis defamed art
Before he was a dictator, Adolf Hitler was a painter. The "Führer" categorized works of art according to his personal taste. Works he hated were branded "degenerate art" and removed from museums.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Degenerate art
Modern artworks whose style, artist or subject did not meet with the approval of Adolf Hitler and the National Socialists were labeled "degenerate art." From 1937, the Nazis confiscated such works from German museums. In a traveling exhibition, "degenerate art" was held up for public ridicule. Here we see Reich Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels and Hitler at the original exhibition in Munich.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Hitler's art
Hitler had an affinity for Romanticism and 19th century painting and preferred peaceful country scenes. His private collection included works by Cranach, Tintoretto and Bordone. Like his role models Ludwig I. of Bavaria and Frederick the Great, Hitler wanted to manage his own art exhibition at retirement, to be shown in the city of Linz on the River Danube in the "Führer Museum."
Image: picture-alliance/Everett Collection/Actual Films
The confiscations
The National Socialists were not the first to persecute avant-garde artists, but they took it a step further by banning their works from museums. In 1937, the authorities had over 20,000 art works removed from 101 state-owned German museums. Anything that the Nazis didn't consider edifying to the German people was carted off.
Image: Victoria & Alber Museum
Hitler's national style
Abstract art had no place in Hitler's "national style," as grew clear when the "Great German Art Exhibition" put traditional landscape, historical and nude paintings by artists including Fritz Erler, Hermann Gradl and Franz Xaver Stahl on display in Munich on July 18, 1937. The closer the depicted subject to the actual model was, the more beautiful it was in the eyes of the Führer.
Image: Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-C10110/CC-BY-SA
What was considered degenerate
Even those in Hitler's inner circle were highly unsure which artists he approved of. The 1937 "Great German Art Exhibition" and the simultaneous "Degerate Art" exhibition in Munich's Court Garden Arcades brought some clarity. Unwelcome were creative artists of the modern period including Max Beckmann, Otto Dix, Wassily Kandinsky, Paul Klee, Ernst Ludwig Kirchner and Max Pechstein.
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Degenerate art on tour
In the "Degerate Art" exhibition, 650 confiscated artworks from 32 German museums were on display, the exhibits equated with sketches by mentally handicapped persons and shown together with photos of crippled persons. The intention: to provoke revulsion and aversion among visitors. Over two million visitors saw the exhibition on its tour of various cities.
Image: cc-by-sa/Bundesarchiv
Legal foundation
The "Degenerate Artworks Confiscation Law" of May 31, 1938 retroactively legalized their unremunerated acquisition by the state. The law remained valid in the postwar years, the allies determining that it had simply been a redistribution of state property. Unlike stolen artworks, pieces that the Nazis labled "degenerate" and had removed from museums can be freely traded today.
Image: CC by Österreichische Nationalbibliothek
The "degenerate art" trade
The confiscated art was taken to storage facilities in Berlin and at Schönhausen Palace. Many works were sold by Hitler's four art merchants: Bernhard A. Böhmer, Karl Buchholz, Hildebrand Gurlitt and Ferdinand Möller. On March 20, 1939 the Berlin fire department burned approximately 5,000 unsold artifacts, calling it an "exercise."
125 works were earmarked for an auction in Switzerland. A commission charged by Hermann Göring and others with liquefying the "degenerate" art products estimated the minimum bidding prices and commissioned the Fischer Gallery in Lucerne to carry out the auction. Taking place on June 30, 1939, it met with eager interest worldwide.
Image: picture alliance/dpa
Much "degenerate art" in the Gurlitt collection
Over 21,000 works of "degenerate art" were confiscated. Estimates on the number subsequently sold differ; sources estimate 6,000 to 10,000. Others were destroyed or disappeared. Hundreds of artworks believed lost turned up in Cornelius Gurlitt's collection — and reignited the discussion.