How anti-Semitism impacted film before and after the Nazis
Jochen Kürten db
August 10, 2017
Anti-Semitic tendencies in film weren't restricted to the Nazi era. Film historian Frank Stern explains how pre-war and postwar films portrayed Jews - and why Germany's approach lags behind the US and France.
Advertisement
Anti-Semitism in film before and after the Holocaust
Even before the Nazis' rise in 1933, anti-Semitism was present in film. After 1945, many directors struggled to deal with the Holocaust, but some continued to make movies with anti-Semitic tendencies.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/S. Kugler
Anti-Semitism in 16th-century Prague
One of Germany's most famous silent films, "The Golem: How He Came Into the World," was made in 1920. Paul Wegener directed and played a leading role in the film set in 16th-century Prague. The Jewish ghetto is in danger and the emperor order the Jews to leave the city. Only the mythical Golem can help. It's one of the earliest films to address the persecution of Jews.
Image: picture alliance / United Archiv
Persecution of Jews in 1920s Vienna
Based on a novel by Hugo Bettauer, "The City Without Jews," is an important example of how films have taken on anti-Semitism. The Austrian-made film is set in Vienna in the 1920s and shows how the residents held Jews responsible for all social ills. Critics, however, have lamented the film's use of anti-Semitic cilches.
Image: Filmarchiv Austria
Fine line between tolerance and clichés
Four years earlier in 1916, the American director DW Griffith had created the monumental historical film,"Intolerance." The story explains historical events over the course of four episodes, taking intolerance to task. Yet in a scene showing the crucifixion of Jesus, Griffith employed Jewish stereotypes. As a result, critics have also accused "Intolerance" of demonstrating anti-Semitic tendencies.
Image: picture-alliance / Mary Evans Picture Library
Ben Hur through the decades
"Ben Hur" was first made in 1925, but has been reinvented many time since then. It tells the story of a conflict betweet Jews and Christians at the beginning of the 1st century. Jewish prince Judah Ben Hur lives in Roman-occupied Jerusalem as a contemporary of Jesus Christ. The way the Jewish-Christian relationship is showed in the Ben Hur films remains a topic of discussion today.
Image: Imago/United Archives
A trial and pogrom in 1880s Hungary
Although hardly known today, GW Pabst's "The Trial" (1948) is an astounding early example of how the cinema reacted to the Holocaust. Filmed in Austria just three years after the end of the war, Pabst tells a true story set in 1882 in Hungary. A young girl disappears from her village and Jews are blamed. Tragically, a pogrom follows.
Image: Filmarchiv Austria
Broaching the truth
"The Trial" remained an exception. After the war, it took the film industry in Europe quite some time to deal with the subject. The French director Alain Resnais was the first to address the Nazi genocide in 1956, in the unsparing 30-minute documentary "Night and Fog."
Image: picture-alliance/Mary Evans Picture Library/Ronald Grant Archive
Bringing the Holocaust to TV
It wasn't until the 1978 television mini-series "Holocaust" was made that the genocide was brought to the broader public. The four-part US production directed by Marvin J. Chomsky tells the story of a Jewish family that gets caught in the cogs of the Nazis' genocidal policies.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Steven Spielberg's 'Schindler's List'
Fifteen years later, American director Steven Spielberg was able to accomplish on the big screen what "Holocaust" had done for television audiences. "Schindler's List" portrayed the brutal reality of the Nazis' anti-Semitism in Germany, but also in Eastern Europe, spotlighting the unscrupulous SS offcer Amon Göth.
Image: picture alliance/United Archives
Claude Lanzmann and 'Shoah'
French director Claude Lanzmann harshly criticized Spielberg's drama. "He did not really reflect on the Holocaust and cinema. The Holocaust cannot be portrayed," he said in an interview. Lanzmann himself took up the subjects of anti-Semitism and the Holocaust in a completely different way - through long documentaries and essay films such as "Shoah" and "Sobibor."
Image: picture-alliance/akg-images
Humor and the Holocaust
Italian comedian and filmmaker Roberto Bengini took a daring approach in his film on anti-Semitism and the Holocaust. In 1997, "Life is Beautiful" premiered, telling the fictional story of Jews suffering in a concentration camps. The humor he wove throughout had a liberating effect.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Roman Polanski's 'The Pianist'
An equally moving film by Polish-French director Roman Polanski was released in 2002. In "The Pianist," the fate of Jewish-Polish musician Władysław Szpilman during the war years of 1943-44 was brought to the big screen. The project allowed the director, whose mother and other relatives were deported and murdered by the Nazis, to work through his own family's past.
Image: imago stock&people
Anti-Semitism and Jesus the Jew
Films about the life of Jesus Christ often come up in discussions about anti-Semitism in cinema. Martin Scorsese's "The Last Temptation of Christ" (1988), for example, has been accused of reinforcing anti-Semitic clichés, particularly in scenes in which Jews are indirectly associated with greed.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Mel Gibson's scandalous 'The Passion of the Christ'
Much more controversial was the film that Australian Mel Gibson released two years later. Both Christians and Jews accused Gibson of explicit anti-Semitism in the film, saying he didn't counter the implications in the New Testament that Jews were to blame for the death of Jesus (who himself was Jewish). In public, Gibson likewise used anti-Semitic speech.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
Turkish anti-Semitism
Audiences and critics alike decried the anti-Semitism in the Turkish film, "Valley of the Wolves." The action-packed movie version of a TV series of the same name showed a battle between Turkish soldiers and Israel. The film employed "anti-American, anti-Israeli and anti-Semitic stereotypes and was inciteful," according to several organizations.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/S. Kugler
WWII still a challenge for filmmakers
Just how difficult it can still be to address the subject matter of World War II is evident in the response to a three-part German TV series from 2013, "Generation War." The series follows a handful of German soldiers fighting on the eastern front. It was criticized in Poland for anti-Semitism and was said to have represented the Polish resistance.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/J. Wolf
Hannah Arendt and 'the banality of evil'
Margarethe von Trotta's film about Hannah Arendt was well received in 2012. The director sketched a balanced portrait of the philosopher and publicist who, in the 1960s, grappled with a figure who was largely responsible for the Nazi genocide: Adolf Eichmann. Arendt coined the phrase "the banality of evil" to explain anti-Semitism clothed in seemingly harmless bureaucracy.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/Heimatfilm/NFP
The 'Wonder Woman' controversy
Because the protagonist of the current Hollywood super hero hit "Wonder Woman" is played by Israeli Gal Gadot, the film was not shown in a number of Arab countries. Gadot herself had served in the Israeli army and defended her experience. Not showing "Wonder Woman" is anti-Semitic, according to the public sentiment in Israel.
DW: When we think about anti-Semitism in the movies, we invariably think about the period 1933 to 1945 and about Nazi propaganda films. But weren't anti-Semitic films produced even before 1933?
Frank Stern: Yes, they were. People immediately think of Nazi films like "Jud Süss" and "Homecoming." They forget that Nazi film politics, filmmakers, actors and scriptwriters could draw on a huge pool of Jewish characters and stories from between the two world wars.
The portrayal of Jewish characters was firmly established in mainstream film. Whether portrayals were positive or slightly critical, self-critical, stereotypical or clichéd - whatever was out there in German-language movies in Berlin or Vienna between the wars was more or less a service outfit for Nazi film policy makers. It just needed to be turned around. Every cliché was exaggerated, and every stereotype got a racist bent.
Ernst Lubitsch's wonderful, funny movies. From 1914 on, Lubitsch portrayed fantastic, neurotic, loving Jewish characters - though you could also take a critical view of them - that lived somewhere in Berlin. They were usually young men. He played these characters, too, with an overly big nose, exaggerated gestures, distinctively erotic, and with sexual connotations.
He developed a trademark style, called the "Lubitsch touch." Everything that came across very lightheartedly on the screen, much beloved by audiences, was reversed after 1933, turned into anti-Semitic, racist, sexist stereotypes where physiognomy played a role in particular - the face, body language - and had a negative connotation. I believe this connection is important because otherwise you would think the Nazis invented it all.
What happened after the war? Did anti-Semitism continue in film?
That is one the most exciting questions in postwar film history. The simple answer is, it lives on! Filmmakers still work with clichés and stereotypes, though now they often have a philo-Semitic bent - that is, an appreciation of and respect for Jews. This can be seen, for example, in the fact that you will hardly see Jewish men on German-language screens, rather Jewish women who are portrayed as victims.
The first movies made after 1945 tended to brush off general responsibility and guilt; instead they point at individuals responsible for the deaths of Jews.
Were there films that spoke out against anti-Semitism, too?
Arthur Brauner made a few films that take a vehement stance against anti-Semitism. In Vienna in 1948, director GW Pabst filmed "The Trial," which turns against anti-Semitism as it still existed after 1945.
Some filmmakers and producers tried to confront the Nazis' anti-Semitism. If you look at German-language film history, you will quickly find that certain stereotypes and clichés reappear - and that has actually increased over the decades.
Germany actually produced a lot of films about the Holocaust and the Nazi years over the past decades. Do you have examples of clichés?
Volker Schlöndorff uses massive anti-Semitic clichés and stereotypes in some of his films, for instance in "The Sudden Wealth of the Poor People of Kombach," which portrays the traditionally conspiratorial, rich, lonely, stateless Jew in a manner so extreme that it is shocking.
"The Tin Drum" has anti-Semitic scenes that take place in Gdansk, something few people seem to have noticed; after all, the film won a lot of prizes. And let's not even talk about a movie that was quickly forgotten - "The Ogre," where the tale of a Christian martyr is supposed to save the Jews…
Certainly Schlöndorff and other directors and filmmakers didn't have a hidden agenda?
No, and neither did Rainer Werner Fassbinder, who also had anti-Semitic elements in his films. This is how I like to explain it: Fassbinder didn't hate Jews; Schlöndorff doesn't hate Jews. But somehow, unconsciously, thoughts about Germany's past, about German-Jewish history are still brewing. Some directors still harbor anti-Semitic thinking, and that simply shows itself in their movies.
What about international film after 1945?
It's a bit different in international film, in particular in France, the US and Britain. Casting is meticulous in French films about Jewish characters. That is not always the case in the US. But they try to avoid portraying anti-Semitic stereotypes and clichés. That would be difficult anyways, because both the American and the French film communities have many talented young Jews.
That was common in Germany before 1933, too: Both Jewish and non-Jewish artists were part of the mix. No one thought about it, people simply worked on their films and tried to do their best. That is typical of the US and France, but not yet of Germany and Austria.
On the other hand, I must say I noticed in recent debates with young filmmakers that a very talented young generation is evolving, so we can expect a new form of non-stereotype film and body language in the future.
Frank Stern has taught cultural history at the Institute for Contemporary History at Vienna University since 2004.An expert on film history, he has previously taught at various universities in Israel, Austria and the US.