Water power is the largest renewable energy source in the world, but some plants are running out of water due to severe droughts. Is climate change jeopardizing the future of hydropower plants?
Image: Getty Images/AFP/S. Panthaky
Advertisement
Civilizations have used water as a source of energy for millennia, and it has been used to generate electricity for nearly 150 years.
Water powers around 70 percent of the world's renewable electricity, and more than 15 percent of the world's total power supply. It's cheap, and unlike solar and wind, can produce electricity on demand.
But building hydroelectric dams also reshapes ecological systems, inundates landscapes, and has forced millions of people to abandon their homes.
And now, water power faces an added complication: Climate change means some countries are experiencing severe droughts and reservoirs are drying up.
The Guri dam in Venezuela during a drought in 2016Image: Reuters/C.G. Rawlins
"We cannot avoid the fact that climate change is having a remarkable impact on hydropower generation and it increases the challenge of managing hydro plants," Clemente Prieto of the Spanish Committee on Large Dams, told DW.
Malawi relies on hydropower for 98 percent of its electricity supply. Last year, it suffered prolonged blackouts. According to the World Bank, less than 10 percent of Malawians have access to a power supply anyway, but key public infrastructure, such as hospitals, was badly hit.
Hydropower makes up 95 percent of Zambia’s power supply — most of it from Lake Kariba, the world's largest man-made reservoir. But due to El Nino in 2016, water levels dropped to 13 percent of their usual capacity, Daisy Mukarakate, climate change program specialist with the United Nations Development Program Africa (UNDP), told DW.
Richer countries have been hit too. Following four years of severe drought, a shortage of hydropower meant California had to use more gas to cover its electricity demand. That cost more than $2 billion (€1.6 billion) and led to a 10 percent rise in CO2 emissions, according to the Pacific Institute for Studies in Development, Environment, and Security.
In other words, Californians had to pay more for dirtier power.
In Spain, hydropower generation fell by half from 2016 to 2017, meaning more fossil fuels were burned and CO2 emissions shot up by 40 percent. Latin American countries like Venezuela, Colombia and Brazil have had similar experiences.
Yet despite uncertainty about our future climate, reservoirs are still being built around the world.
Does building new hydro plants make sense?
Threatened lifeline: The Tapajos River
The Tapajos flows wild and free through the Amazon rainforest, acting as a lifeline for species. The river also sustains people — like the Munduruku indigenous group. But dam projects are threatening the river's ecology.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
Along the banks
The Munduruku people live mainly in forest regions and riverbanks, in villages spread along the Tapajos River in the Brazilian states of Para, Amazonas and Mato Grosso. With an estimated population of 12,000 to 15,000 people, the Munduruku are the most numerous indigenous group along the free-flowing Tapajos River.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The forest
The dwellers of the Sawre Muybu Indigenous Land have sought for at least three centuries to officially demarcate their territory. The 178,000-hectare area includes rainforest that is threatened by illegal loggers and mining — and more recently, by the construction of reservoirs for hydropower.
Image: Getty Images/M. Tama
The 'chief'
Munduruku people live largely as they have for centuries. Villages are represented by women known as "cacicas." Maria Aniceia Akay Munduruku, from the upper Tapajos, has taken part in her people's movement against the construction of hydropower dams, including by demarcating indigenous land. She doesn't speak Portuguese: Her husband helps her to communicate with others outside the village.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The essence of life
The Tapajos River is the essence of life for the indigenous Munduruku people. They depend on its water for sustenance, and to get around. The waters teem with vitality — there are 324 identified species of fish living in the waters, beside Amazonian manatees and giant otters.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
Rich biodiversity
Along the river also live hundreds of species of birds, lizards and amphibians. Tapirs and giant anteaters ply the riverbanks, while jaguars and ocelot also prowl the rainforest and savannah. The region is among the world's most important for rare land and water species.
Image: picture alliance/WILDLIFE/P. Oxford
The students
Munduruku children attend the village school, under the guidance of indigenous teachers. In this picture, girls play in the shared classroom at Sawre Muybu village during their holiday break. Animals such as monkeys, parrots, dogs and capybaras are welcome among the children.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
Living off the land
Manioc flour is the staple food in Munduruku villages — cassava planted on the family farm is crushed, shredded and then roasted in a wood-burning stove. Also sweet potatoes, yams and bananas are grown. Although Munduruku consume mainly food grown in the local fields, items such as sugar, salt and coffee have also made their way into the traditional diet. They are purchased in town once a month.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The threat
An aerial view shows the Teles Pires dam, on the homonymous tributary to the Tapajos. The lighter green color indicates the area of forest that was submerged — critics point out that rotting vegetation from inundated forest produces considerable quantities of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas. The specter of ongoing drought also casts doubt on future usability of such hydropower stations.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
International partners
This aerial image shows construction at the Sao Manoel hydropower dam, which is supposed to begin operation by January 2018. Partially funded by Chinese companies, the cost of the project is estimated to reach €600 million euros. The plant, located on the Teles Pires River, will have the capacity to generate 700 megawatts of electricity.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
The consequences
If built, the Sao Luiz do Tapajos dam would inundate this stretch of the river — including its shallows, rapids, beaches, waterfalls, inlets and shores. Once full, it would create a reservoir the size of New York City. Planned dams could flood up to 7 percent of indigenous territory, resulting in loss of land, poorer water quality and less fish — deeply affecting Mundukuru livelihood.
Image: DW/N. Pontes
10 images1 | 10
Brazil is planning to build several dams, including over 40 in the basin of the Tapajos River — one of the most biodiverse places on the planet. The project has come under intense criticism for the impact it will have on local wildlife and indigenous human populations.
But Greenpeace says that with many countries seeing their hydropower production decline, the Tapajos project is even more questionable. "Why would a country whose energy security is already compromised by overreliance on hydropower aim to increase that reliance still further?" a Greenpeace report reads.
Instead, Greenpeace proposes a combination of wind, solar and biomass, which it says will, in the long term, be cheaper and more efficient, as well as far less destructive.
UK researchers say that if all plans currently on the table for new hydropower plants in eastern and southern Africa were fulfilled, the risk of power shortages could increase, since most rely on the same scarce rainfall and would suffer a drop in generation at the same time.
Still, experts like Michael Taylor, senior analyst on renewable energy with the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), told DW Africa still has a lot of hydropower potential, and with such high demand for renewable energy, it cannot be ignored.
Brazilian dam threatens indigenous way of life
This browser does not support the audio element.
"There is a huge energy deficit in Africa and we cannot throw away options if we want to overcome underdevelopment," said Mukarakate of UNDP.
But it is important to plan with projected changes in regional weather in mind, and to consider the type of facilities that will be most efficient.
In Spain, which already has more than 1,000 hydropower dams, Eva Hernandez, head of the water and agriculture program with WWF Spain, told DW the focus should not be on building more, but improving the ones the country has.
Hydro: one piece of the puzzle
Some are several decades old and need repair. But there is also scope to develop some conventional hydroelectric dams — which use the potential energy of water stored behind a dam by releasing it in a controlled way to drive a turbine — to include pumped storage capacity.
Pumped storage uses electrical power to pump water from a reservoir at a lower elevation to a higher one. Then, when the power is needed, it's released again. As such, it tackles one of the problems with fluctuating renewable power — storage — and boosts its integration into the grid, Hernandez says.
Unlike fossil fuels, solar and wind power aren't produced to schedule or according to need, but depend entirely on the weather. Pumped storage is a way to convert excess power into potential energy, then back into electricity, on demand.
Taylor says hydropower shouldn't be seen as an alternative to other renewables, but as a compliment to them, making the entire energy system more efficient and the power supply more secure.
The future energy system has to be renewable, but Mukarakate says we still need to preserve a healthy mix of different energy sources.
"If we keep depending only on one source like hydropower, vulnerability will stay very high," she says. "We have to bring all the options together — biomass, wind, solar, biofuels, etc."
Focusing on the system as a whole is also key to a more secure supply for the African countries already being hit by reduced rainfall. Taylor says connecting up national grids means if one country is struggling with its power supply, it should be able to draw on that of a neighboring country to make up the shortfall.
Ultimately, a greener energy supply is the solution to its own problems — the sooner we stop burning fossil fuels, the more stable our climate will be.
Africa's biggest dams
Some of the world's biggest dams are located in Africa on the Nile, Congo and Niger rivers. Here is an introduction to the biggest dams on the continent.
Image: picture-alliance/Yannick Tylle
Grand Renaissance Dam in Ethiopia
The Grand Renaissance Dam in Ethiopia is currently the biggest dam in Africa and was previously known as the Millennium Dam. It is located close to the border with Sudan on the Blue Nile. Construction started in 2011 and the dam currently generates 6,000 megawatts annually.
Image: William Lloyd-George/AFP/Getty Images
Grand Renaissance Dam in Ethiopia
The reservoir holds back almost 63 billion square meters (68 billion square feet) of water and is one of the largest reservoirs on the continent. Its surface measures 1,680 square kilometers (650 square miles). The dam's walls are 145 meters (475 feet) high and 1,800 meters (5,900 feet) long.
The Aswan High Dam, Egypt
The Aswan Dan Dam is located close to the city of the same name In southern Egypt. It holds back 169 square kilometers (62 square miles) of a lake called Lake Nasser. The turbines produce 2,100 MW and due to the high production capacity, the Aswan High Dam ranks as Africa's second largest. It took eleven years to build and was opened in 1971.
One of the world's biggest dams is located in Mozambique. The Cahora Bassa Dam has a capacity of 2075 megawatts and ranks after the Aswan High Dam. The major part of electricity produced is exported to South Africa. But sabotage during the civil war in 1981 prevented the generation of electricity for ten years.
Image: DW/M. Barroso
Gibe III in Ethiopia
The Gibe-III-Dam is located 350 kilometers (155 miles) southwest of the capital Addis Abeba. In total it produces 1,870 MW and is, with a height of 243 meters (797 feet), the third largest dam in Africa. Construction began in 2007 and was completed in 2016.
Image: Getty Images/AFP
The Inga dams in DR Congo
The Inga Dams in Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) consists of two single dams. Inga 1 (generating 351 MW) and Inga 2 (1,424 MW). They were commissioned in 1972 and 1982 respectively as part of a failed industrial development scheme under then-dictator Sese Sekko Mobutu. The two dams currently operate at a 50 percent capacity because they have not been properly maintained in recent years.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa
The Inga dams in DR Congo (continued)
The two dams are located in the west of the DRC, 225 kilometers (140 miles) southwest of Kinshasa, and is located on the Congo River. The Congolese government plans to start an Inga 3 project, a 4,800 MW hydroelectric plant that would cost 13 billion euros ($14 billion).
The Akosombo Dam in Ghana
One of the top african dams is the Akosombo Dam. It sits at the base of Lake Volta, which has a surface area of 8,502 square kilometres and is the largest reservoir in the world. The turbines generate 912 megawatts, but the dam also serves as flood control. The Lake Volta itself is popular for being a way for trade and travel.
Image: picture-alliance / dpa
The Kainji Dam in Nigeria
Located on the Niger River, the Kainji Dam is the sixth biggest dam in Africa. It was built in just four years and opened in 1968. It is 65 meters (213 feet) high, 550 meters (1805 feet) across and generates a total of 760 megawatts.
The Tekeze Dam, Ethiopia
Africa's seventh biggest dam is the Tekeze Dam in Ethiopia. With a height of 188 meters, it is the highest dam in Africa. However the dam has a productivity of just 300 MW, so it only generates one-twentieth of the hydroenergy produced by its big brother the Grand Renaissance Dam. It took seven years to build and was opened in 2009.
Image: CC/International Rivers
The Bujagali Dam in Uganda
The Bujagali Dam in Uganda is located on the Nile River close to Lake Victoria and generates 250 MW. The dam has been operating since 2012 and is the biggest hydroelectrical dam in Uganda. The construction of two new dams, Karuma und Isimba, could change this but this would mean the resettlement of thousands of farmers and the flooding of protected areas.
