1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
Music

Syrian musicians triumph in the Elbphilharmonie

Rick Fulker
October 30, 2018

A speech by an exiled Turkish journalist alongside an orchestra of Syrian refugees may sound like a disturbing kind of arts event in Hamburg's iconic concert hall. It was in fact anything but.

Hamburger Rede zum Exil der Körber-Stiftung
Image: Körber-Stiftung/Claudia Höhne

Turkish journalist Can Dündar and the Syrian Expat Philharmonic Orchestra were the protagonists in Hamburg's Elbphilharmonie on October 29. The event, hosted by Germany's Körber Foundation, was simply titled "Speech on Exile & Concert."

It began with a searing yet moving account of the experiences of exiled Turkish journalist Dündar, recounting the startling regression of his homeland into autocratic rule in only five years, and giving a moving account of exile in its outward, and most importantly, inward aspects: "Your exile begins the moment you reject the mainstream," he said.

Read moreTurkish journalist Can Dundar: Erdogan's opponents 'at risk everywhere in the world'

"New Life in Exile" is accordingly one of the three themes currently being focused on by the Körber Foundation, along with "Digital Literacy" and "The Value of Europe."

Dündar's speech came on the 95th anniversary of the founding of the Turkish Republic. It was also the day after regional elections ushered the immigration-hostile AFD party into the last of Germany's 16 state parliaments. Having seen his own country slide into totalitarianism on the back of populist ideas that have underpinned the rise of Germany's far right, Dündar issued a clear warning to his host country. 

"If the AFD enters the government, they might send the migrants back, but you will end up as exiles in your own country," he told the Elbphilharmonie concert goers. 

Read moreGermany: Immigration officials deny Turkish journalist Adil Yigit will be deported

Sad yet uplifting

"Syriac Fantasy II" - a composition by Wassim Ibrahim

This browser does not support the audio element.

It was not all grim politics however, as the speech itself and the subsequent performance quickly proved — especially when conductor Ghassan Alaboud commenced the poignant, endless melancholy of composer Suad Bushnaq's "The Borrowed Dress."

Then the pallette of emotions broadened with "My Beautiful Homeland," with composer Jehad Jazbeh also featuring on solo violin. The merry outbursts had an undertow of sadness that was reminiscent of Jewish klezmer music. Meanwhile, the theme of the evening – exile – seemed vividly evoked in "Passion," composed in 1975 by Dia Succari, that evoked a tender, dignified dance, or perhaps an endless trek.

The orchestra's string subset is roughly one-third female Image: SEPO/P. Adamik

Contributing to the monumentality of the experience was the acoustic of the "Kleiner Saal" (Small Hall) of the Elbphilharmonie, the trademark bumpy "skin" of its windowless walls magnifying the sound that came from a pared-down version of the orchestra. Reduced to strings, the ensemble easily filled the space aurally.

Read moreOut of brutality, beauty: The Syrian Expat Philharmonic Orchestra

Between tragic stories and sensual delights

One might initially have to overcome inhibitions to go to such an event. Syria today is associated with the unspeakable brutality of war, the suffering of millions of refugees within and beyond the country, along with hundreds of thousands of political asylum seekers in Europe. Yet the aftermath of hearing this mysteriously evocative music is a new curiosity, the listener wanting to know: what are the stories behind these pieces?

Orchestra founder and artistic director Raed Jazbeh explained to DW: "We are gold. In Syria, a country of 32 million people, there are about one hundred classical musicians. Here, in the Syrian Expat Philharmonic Orchestra, there are also about one hundred classical musicians. We are a precious resource."

If the war ended and some orchestra members returned to their native country, that wouldn't be the end of its work, says Jazbeh, but rather a new beginning, a new phase of networking, rebuilding and cross-fertilization of ideas.

Music that gets under the skin

The orchestra created a sound of rich diversity: In-between tones, tiptoing pizzicati and sighing dissonances packed into what sounded like a long, sad song characterize "Syriac Fantasy II," a 2018 composition by Wassim Ibrahim.

"Roaming" - with the composer Maher Mahmoud as soloist on the oud

This browser does not support the audio element.

But the biggest ovations from the sold-out rows in the auditorium came following Mahmer Mahmoud's 2015 composition, "Roaming," for the oud – a kind of lute from the Middle East. It began with a solo sequence that was interrupted by a medical emergency somewhere in the hall. After restarting, the performance culminated in a dazzlingly virtuosic, jazzy sequence.

All of this gets under the skin. The listener doesn't have to go halfway to emotionally comprehend it, but instead finds oneself awash in feeling.

The unique symphonic sound might only have been born out of the catastrophic destruction of a country. These are not simply artists recreating sounds from an exotic place. Instead, the work with Syrian composers in exile is generating something new, a transmorphing of indigenous sounds into a symphonic context.

Read moreArtists After the Escape: Aeham Ahmad — When music saves a life

Can Dündar's voice sometimes trembled during his speechImage: Körber-Stiftung/Claudia Höhne

Above all, the Syrian Expat Philharmonic generates joyful creativity. The music recalls the feeling of the exiled person who, in Can Dündar's bittersweet yet exhiliarating words, has emerged from loneliness, separation, alienation and despair. 

"It gives you the opportunity to leave established motorways in order to carve your own path and to discover skills you didn't know you had," the exiled journalist told the packed crowd. 

"The tape over your mouth is gone, as are the shackles on your ankles and the blindfold for your eyes … Leaving your comfortable home to recreate yourself … Like diving into cold water, you may shiver first, but you feel invigorated, rejuvenated, fortified, liberated."

Skip next section Explore more
Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Skip next section More stories from DW