In times of political turmoil, the cultural scene also aims to take a stand. The year 2018 made it clear how necessary controversial debate is and how unclear some red lines are.
Advertisement
Provocative moments in culture in 2018
In 2018, the cultural scene has been tumultuous: What happens to looted art? Is anti-Semitism award-worthy? How should Germany deal with the Israel boycott movement? And why does an artist shred his work?
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/N. Armer
Behind the scenes
Let us begin with a poem that no longer exists — at least not on the façade of the Alice Salomon Hochschule in Berlin. Its student committee felt that the poem "Avenidas" by Bolivian-Swiss poet Eugen Gomringer, painted in large letters on the school, was sexist. The group managed to have the poem painted over. Minister of Culture Monika Grütters spoke of a "frightening act of cultural barbarism."
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/N. Armer
No medal for literature
In May, the Swedish Academy canceled the Nobel Prize for Literature after 18 women had accused the husband of Academy member Katarina Frostenson of sexual harassment. The couple is also said to have embezzled money and passed on the names of Nobel Prize winners prematurely.
Anti-Semitism or political protest?
The Israeli singer Netta won the Eurovision Song Contest in May. The first calls for boycotts of the ESC 2019, which will take place in Israel, followed right after. The Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement leading the campaigns, which aim to end Israel's human rights violations against Palestinians, is itself controversial and considered by some to be anti-Semitic.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/M. Ulander
A movement affecting German events
Ruhrtriennale art festival director Stefanie Carp first invited Scottish band Young Fathers — self-declared BDS supporters — to perform, then uninvited them, then invited them again. In turn, state premier of North Rhine-Westfalia Armin Laschet cancelled his participation. Carp finally agreed to abide by the state parliament resolution in the future. Its verdict on BDS: "clearly anti-Semitic."
Image: picture-alliance/SvenSimon/M. Ossowski
Anti-Semitism or calculation?
Following the Echo music award nomination for rappers Kollegah and Farid Bang, criticism of their anti-Semitic, homophobic and misogynist lyrics was rampant. When they actually received the award, other artists returned their prizes in protest. The Echo, Germany's most important music prize, was then abolished, and the rappers were invited to the Auschwitz concentration camp memorial site (photo).
Image: picture-alliance/KEYSTONE/Iak/B. Oertwig
Facebook and breasts
Facebook was also busy in 2018 censoring works of art. One who fell prey: Marianne, a national figure of the French Republic, shown in Eugene Delacroix's painting leading an uprising with a bare bosom. According to the social network's guidelines, photos of breasts are removed as soon as a nipple is visible. However, photos of paintings and sculptures are excluded. Facebook once again apologized.
Image: picture-alliance/Luisa Ricciarini/Leemage
Bold act
Street art pioneer Banksy's take on the art world also caused a stir. At an auction of his famous "Girl with Balloon," the artwork was shredded after the acceptance of a bid. Banksy was responsible for it. The press called it a bold act. The buyer was first shocked, then enthusiastic: The value of the work purchased for €1.18 million ($1.35 million) is said to have increased by 50 percent.
Image: picture-alliance/NurPhoto/A. Pezzali
Returning confiscated art
Restitution — and if so, how much? Western countries find it difficult to deal with looted art from the colonial era. France's President Macron showed the way: First he commissioned a report, then he announced that he would return works of art and objects from French museums to Africa over the next five years. In December, some stolen statues were already returned to Benin.
Image: Imago/Belga/E. Lalmand
Hi to the president
Hollywood clearly has been no mecca for Trump fans. But no one has been as outspoken as Robert De Niro at the Tony Awards in June. He began his speech with the words: "F**k Trump" on live TV, and it earned him a standing ovation. Months later, a pipe bomb was sent by a deranged Trump follower to his restaurant in New York.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/V. Hache
Too close for comfort
Speaking of speeches, Oprah Winfrey gave a laudable one on women's rights and racial discrimination at the Golden Globes. Some saw it as an unofficial bid for candidacy for the 2020 presidential election. But soon after, things changed when right-wing media resurfaced photos showing Winfrey rubbing shoulders with Harvey Weinstein, the culprit who triggered the #MeToo movement.
Image: Getty Images/A. E. Rodriguez
#MeToo in Germany
In January, #MeToo also reached the German film industry. Several women accused director Dieter Wedel of sexual assault, abuse of power and rape. Public broadcaster ZDF and the Bavaria Film company initiated internal investigations, but found no evidence of sexual assault. Former employees confirmed that Wedel was disrespectful and choleric.
Image: picture alliance/dpa/U. Zucchi
An unpopular artistic agenda
Chris Dercon held out for almost eight months as director of the Berlin Volksbühne. Critics said Dercon wanted to turn Franz Castorf's cult theater into an "event booth." The controversial director often had feces placed in front of his office and activists occupied the theater for a week. In April, Dercon abruptly resigned. He'll become president of the Association of National Museums in Paris.
Image: DW/G. Schliess
Increased sensitivity following Chemnitz riots
ZDF had wanted to record a concert by punk band Feine Sahne Fischfilet at the Bauhaus in Dessau. However, since the musicians are outspoken anti-fascists, right-wing extremist groups announced protests. The director of the Bauhaus Foundation first canceled the concert, but then realized that she had called even more attention to the neo-Nazis. She was railed with criticism from all sides.
Image: Bastian Bochinski
13 images1 | 13
Art and culture deal with social developments. They refer to the past and stretch into the future. They can tear open reality, deconstruct it and reassemble it in coded form as a way to hold up a mirror to society.
Over the course of history, art and culture have never remained untouched by a politically turbulent climate. The year 2018 has once again shown how much culture comes under pressure where free democracies are at risk — especially in their function as a counterbalance.
Culture under state control
In the US, President Donald Trump has attacked journalists. In Poland, the government is pushing out people working in the cultural field who express critical opinions and filling the positions with more "agreeable" people. The Hungarian press has been trimmed to toe the government line; in Russia, President Vladimir Putin has announced at the end of the year that he would put rap music under state control.
Anyone who is skeptical about the sheer power of large internet companies is likely to be all the more unnerved by a scenario that outlines the collaboration of these companies with politicians. What if platforms like Facebook joined in on the censorship and persecution? The fact that the boundaries between freedom and censorship are fluid in social networks was demonstrated in 2018 by the ongoing deletion of images depicting works of art with nudes.
Fast pace heats things up
In addition, there's the media business, the fast-paced nature of which tends to exacerbate rather than decelerate social discourse. That's what happened when the #MeToo debate revealed that Asia Argento, the movement's leading protagonist to date, allegedly was involved in sexual improprieties herself years ago, for which she later allegedly paid hush money.
Argento's statements that she had been abused by film mogul Harvey Weinstein were promptly called into question. That reveals two sides of the same coin. Just because one is right does not mean the other is wrong.
Escalation and simplification — it doesn't appear that 2019 will be a quieter year. Culture must resist threats. You can find out more about 2018's exciters in the cultural scene in our picture gallery.