Mexico's press under siege: The rising journalist death toll
Claudia Herrera-Pahl
July 11, 2023
In Mexico, journalism has become one of the deadliest professions. On Saturday, another reporter — Luis Sánchez, was found dead. But the public appears too intimidated to show outrage.
Advertisement
The body of Luis Martin Sanchez Iniguez was found wrapped in plastic, hands tied, a message pinned to his chest with a knife. Authorities did not reveal what the messages said, but such notes are frequently left by drug cartels with the bodies of victims. The 59-year-old correspondent for La Jornada was kidnapped in the Mexican state Nayarit last Wednesday, and found dead on Saturday. He is the third correspondent for the daily newspaper to have been murdered in recent times, and the second in 2023.
According to Mexico's attorney general, Alejandro Gertz Manero, two further media professionals have disappeared in the past few days. While one has since been found alive, the other is still missing without a trace. It is suspected that both were working on a story together.
A sad record
In Mexico, violence against journalists has risen to the point that the country is now a sad record-holder. Multiple organizations, including Reporters Without Borders (RSF), have deemed Mexico the deadliest country for journalists in North and South America. In 2022, Mexico was the country with the most murdered journalists worldwide (11), according to RSF.
In addition to murders, human rights organizations such as Article 19 also track daily attacks against journalists, and found that in June 2022, a journalist or media institution was attacked every 14 hours in Mexico.
Changing the narrative: Latin American women use constructive journalism to shape their stories
The collaborative "Cambia la Historia" project brings together female journalists to address the visibility of structural violence against women through constructive journalism. Meet the participants!
It's time to change history
The aim of "Cambia la Historia" is to not just to denounce structural violence against women in Mexico, El Salvador and Guatemala, but also to seek solutions through constructive journalism. The multimedia works are published on a platform created by DW Akademie and in the independent media outlets from where the reporters collaborate.
Image: DW Akademie
Daniela Rea, Mexico City
"Cambia la Historia allows me to tell stories about women, the violence we experience and the way we propose to end it," said award-winning journalist Daniela Rea. In addition to being co-founder and reporter for Pie de Página, a member of the Global Investigative Journalism Network, Daniela is part of Nuevos Cronistas de Indias of Gabriel García Márquez's New Ibero-American Journalism Foundation.
Image: Privat
Dalia Souza, Jalisco (Mexico)
"For many years, they have been called "crazy." Now we share the struggle of women who fight neurotypical mental health and the patriarchal model of feminism," said Dalia Souza, head of information at ZonaDocs, an independent media outlet in Jalisco, Mexico. ZonaDocs investigates forced disappearances and gender issues, among other topics.
Image: Privat
Fátima Escobar, San Salvador (El Salvador)
Fátima Escobar is a journalist who works as a reporter for Alharaca, one of the few multimedia outlets in El Salvador with a specific agenda on gender. "Cambia la Historia means building and learning about a new journalism that challenges you and changes the meaning of information every day," she said. Her journalistic work is focused on public health, gender and human rights issues.
Image: privat
Dulce Soto, Mexico City (Mexico)
Dulce Soto works as a reporter and mentor at Corriente Alterna, a platform developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico to promote journalism. She leads a team of reporters-in-training and advises their investigations. "I really like learning. It's like going back to school but without the ugliness of an inflexible system. Besides, working with other women like me is very rewarding."
Image: Privat
Jade Ramírez Cuevas, Jalisco (México)
"This space allows us to rethink ideas of self-care and topics that affect us. We are talking about us as women and therefore it is very important to share," said award-winning Jade Ramírez Cuevas. A self-taught radio reporter, she is currently the director and founder of Perimetral, a platform focused on radio journalism that portrays the problems faced by rural and indigenous people.
Image: Privat
Lizbeth Hernandez, Mexico City (Mexico)
"It is very empowering to think of our stories as a collective, it is a gift. I want to empower us for all those who face violence every day," said the coordinator of Kaja Negra, a digital media outlet focused on stories about women and the LGBTQ+ community. Since 2011, she has covered women's struggles in Mexico for media outlets such as The Washington Post in Spanish and Animal Político.
Image: Privat
Mely Arellano, Puebla (Mexico)
Arellano is co-founder and co-director of LADO B, a local digital media outlet, with almost 10 years of existence and more than 20 local, national and international journalism awards. In 2014 she won the "Equity and Gender" award in the Reportage category of the National Journalism Award and one in the Chronicle category in 2018 with a text about women's resistance to the mine in Ixtacamaxtitlán.
Image: Mely Arellano Ayala
Paulina Alejandra Ríos, Oaxaca (Mexico)
Paulina Alejandra Ríos has been a journalist for more than 30 years. She is the director of the Página3.mx news portal, the first independent media outlet in Oaxaca which has been active for 10 years. "Cambia la Historia is an exciting and motivating professional challenge. It means to write again, to live again, to feel that passion again and to continue acquiring knowledge," she said.
Image: privat
Silvia Lilian Trujillo, Guatemala (Guatemala)
"This is a unique opportunity for dialogue, it is a space of trust," said Silvia Lilian Trujillo about Cambia la Historia. She is co-editor of the feminist media outlet LaCuerda, one of the few independent media outlets in Guatemala with a gender agenda. In addition to being a sociologist, she is a professor at Rafael Landívar University and has conducted research for several UN organizations.
Image: Privat
Women support each other
Journalists and photojournalists Marlene Martínez (Lado B), María Ruíz (Pie de Página), Isabel Briseño (Pie de Página), Mariana Mora (ZonaDocs), Diana Manzo (Página3) and Mahé Élipe (Kaja Negra) contributed with visual and narrative proposals to the development of their colleagues' projects, each of them linked to an independent media outlet in the region.
11 images1 | 11
One third of all attacks from the state
Article 19 estimates that many attacks on journalists in Mexico originate from state or local authorities. Since 2007, the Mexican administration — be it at the federal, state, communal or local level — is the most common aggressor against media. In the first half of 2022, authorities committed 128 attacks, or about 38,67% of all attacks the organization documented.
In Mexico, assaults on journalists have long been a depressing reality. The first report of a journalist murdered in Mexico is from 1860. Vicente Segura Arguelles, co-founder of the satire magazine Don Simplicio, publisher of two further papers and representative of political-conservative journalism, was shot by liberal troops in Mexico City. Since then, hundreds of journalists have been murdered. So far, since incumbent President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador assumed office in 2018, 44 journalists have been killed — of whom Sanchez Iniguez was the most recent.
Advertisement
'We know the risk'
In other cases, attacks have ended less tragically. On December 15, 2022, unknown motorcyclists fired at the prominent news anchor Ciro Gomez Leyva in Mexico City in a drive-by. The bullet-proof encasing of his car shielded him from three direct shots.
"We know that we are pursuing journalism in a violent and dangerous country, and that we are exposed to risks," Gomez Leyva said at the time. But he added that the Mexican capital had not seen anything like it since the 1980s.
He pointed out that the violence was usually directed more at local journalists and smaller media outlets than at renowned journalists working for Mexico's largest outlets.
Was this a direct attack on Gomez Leyva, or an ordinary assault in a country marred by daily violence? In 2022, the country recorded more than 30,000 murders and more than 109,000 disappeared persons. Gomez Leyva was reluctant to draw any hasty conclusions: "There is no certainty, only uncertainty.”
Desensitized to the violence
The violence seems to have become so commonplace that Mexico's population has shown little outrage and even less protest. "As long as I am safe, and my family is safe, it doesn't matter what happens around me," investigative journalist Anabel Hernandez described a common attitude.
"This apathy, this indifference of the people towards the suffering of others creates more space for impunity and leads to more violence against all of us, including journalists."
"This brute force, the intimidation and subjugation of the people at gunpoint — be it by narcos, the armed forces, or the police — forces a nation to its knees in the face not only of violence, but of authoritarianism. This life on bended knee will have consequences for generations to come," Hernandez, who won DW's Freedom of Speech Award in 2019, concluded.
Hernandez, like Gomez Leyva, is well-known in Mexico.
She argued that the progress Mexcio had made in the field of human rights in past decades was now at stake, jeopardizing not only journalism, but also the nation's democracy.