Netflix sued after woman makes 'Baby Reindeer' claim
June 7, 2024
A Scottish woman has sued Netflix for at least $170 million, saying she was defamed over her portrayal in the series "Baby Reindeer."
Advertisement
A woman who claims she was the inspiration for the stalker in the hit Netflix miniseries "Baby Reindeer" sued the streaming giant on Thursday, seeking at least $170 million in damages.
Netflix accused of defamation, negligence
Fiona Harvey accused Netflix of defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, gross negligence and violations of her right of publicity in the lawsuit filed at the California federal court.
Harvey, a Scottish attorney who lives in England, has identified herself as the real-life "Martha," the delusional, violent and abusive woman — played by actress Jessica Gunning — at the center of Richard Gadd's global sensation.
The British black comedy claims in its opening episode to be "a true story."
"The above quote ... is the biggest lie in television history," the lawsuit states.
Harvey accused Netflix of spreading "brutal lies," including that she is a "twice convicted stalker who was sentenced to five years in prison."
"Defendants told these lies, and never stopped, because it was a better story than the truth, and better stories made money," the lawsuit said.
She said many people couldn't tell the difference, and thousands of Reddit and TikTok users talk about her as the "real" Martha.
Tokio Hotel's Kaulitz brothers to reveal intimate moments in Netflix series
Tokio Hotel's twin frontmen are getting their reality show on Netflix. A look back at how they became Germany's most successful teenage boy band in the 2000s.
Image: Geisler-Fotopress/picture alliance
Instant fame in 2005
Tokio Hotel was a success story straight out of a fairy tale book. Four boys from a village near Magdeburg, in the center of Germany, got together in a band. A music manager heard them play, Sony BMG signed the youngsters — only to bow out before the first recording. The manager was later fired for what turned out to be poor judgement. In 2005, Universal Music Group took over the band's marketing.
Image: Sascha Radke/picture alliance
Ambitious teenagers
Bill (center) and his twin brother Tom Kaulitz were 15 when they founded Tokio Hotel along with their two friends from school, Georg Listing and Gustav Schäfer. The boys' debut single, "Through the Monsoon," skyrocketed to the top of the charts. Teenage girls stormed the record stores.
Image: Martin Meissner/AP Photo/picture alliance
Heartthrobs Tom and Bill
Bill, the band's singer, and guitarist Tom rocked the stage, while Georg and Gustav stayed in the background. Six months after they started, Tokio Hotel had become Germany's most successful boy band, winning prizes right and left. Fame came with a price, however: Screeching girls pursued the twins, who could no longer set foot outside without being surrounded by fans.
Image: Steffen Schmidt/dpa/picture-alliance
Smile for the cameras
Two years later, Tokio Hotel released their second album, "Zimmer 483." It was yet another mega success story, along with the single release "Übers Ende der Welt." The charismatic German shooting stars had by then become pros at press conferences and in front of the camera.
Image: Miguel Villagran/dpa/picture-alliance
Sold-out concert halls
In 2009, the band toured through 18 European countries. Their "Welcome to Humanoid City" show, with Bill in flashy stage outfits created by international designers Dean & Dan Caten, played to packed concert halls.
Image: Jörg Carstensen/dpapicture-alliance
Times of crisis
The band's decision to adopt a new direction and a new look in 2014 — Tom shed his dreadlocks, Bill tried his hand as a fashion model — did not have the desired effect. Record sales slumped, and concert ticket sales were down, too. The band's new appearance in particular didn't sit well with the girls who wanted "cute Bill" back.
Image: Lado Alexi/Universal Music
New beginnings
In 2016, Tokio Hotel announced the band would henceforth be producing their own music. After the album "Dream Machine" was released in 2017, a concert tour across Europe took them to smaller, more intimate concert halls and clubs than in the past.
Image: Lado Alexi/dpa/picture alliance
Grown up at last
A 2017 film documentary titled "Behind the World" gave the members of the band an opportunity to speak out about what it was like to be so famous at a young age and how they each dealt with that overwhelming fame in their own way. Their music has obviously matured since their very first teenager hit song; their latest album, which came out in 2022, is titled "2001."
Image: L. Alexi
Close partners
Unlike their band colleagues Gustav and Georg who still live in Germany, the Tokio Hotel Kaulitz twins moved to Los Angeles many years ago, where they get together regularly to work on new songs. They are still beloved interview guests in their native Germany, and they also remain in the spotlight of tabloid papers. They are shown here performing at the 2019 finale of Germany's Next Top Model.
Image: Breuel-Bild/picture alliance
Power couple
In 2019, Tom Kaulitz married to German supermodel Heidi Klum, fueling the tabloids' fascination. The 16-year age gap between the famous TV producer, now 50, and the Tokio Hotel guitarist has served as a major talking point.
Image: picture-alliance/abaca/L. Hahn
Their own Netflix series
Now the brothers will star in their own TV show. The Netflix reality series "Kaulitz & Kaulitz" promises exclusive access to the twins' private lives, "following Bill and Tom
over eight months, charting their international career, family life, tour bus incidents, parties, drama and flirtations on a road trip through the USA," Netflix announced. The series is set to be released on June 25.
Image: Geisler-Fotopress/picture alliance
11 images1 | 11
Netflix defends matter 'vigorously'
Netflix, in response to the lawsuit, said it intended to "defend this matter vigorously and to stand by Richard Gadd's right to tell his story."
The seven-episode series premiered on Netflix in April.
The show is based on Gadd's one-man play, and follows a fictionalized version of the author who meets the character Martha in the pub where he works.
She eventually becomes a stalker who sends him tens of thousands of emails, tweets at him hundreds of times, smashes a bottle over his head, gouges his eyes, sexually assaults him, and is finally arrested and sent to prison.
None of this actually happened, Harvey's lawsuit said.