UN biodiversity talks: Is the world at a tipping point?
Katharina Schantz
October 21, 2024
Two years on from a historic deal to halt nature's decline, there's concern about the lack of progress. Species are vanishing at an alarming rate, threatening human food supply, health and security.
Advertisement
Biodiversity — or the variety of all living things on Earth — is collapsing. That's because humans continue to push ecosystems to the brink through burning fossil fuels, intensive farming, urbanization and pollution.
In the past 50 years, populations of vertebrates have plummeted 73%, according to a recent report by conservation group WWF, while scientists estimate about a million animal and plant species are now threatened with extinction, some in the coming decades.
But the diversity of interconnected living organisms is the foundation of healthy ecosystems, and the loss of even one species can upset the intricate balance.
To address these challenges, two years ago nearly 200 nations signed what was called at the time a "landmark" UN biodiversity deal to safeguard nature.
Now, over the next two weeks, thousands of policymakers, business leaders and civil society groups will gather in the Colombian city of Cali to track the deal's progress and tackle sticky issues like financing.
It's a crucial task because a decline in biodiversity also threatens the social and economic well-being of billions of people, say experts.
"If we don't protect our nature, we are actually undermining our economies, we are undermining our agriculture, and we will not be able in future to feed a population of 10 billion people on this planet," Astrid Schomaker, executive secretary of the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity, told DW.
In Florida, ocean restoration groups help preserve reefs
02:29
Slow progress on national biodiversity plans
Leaders at the 2022 UN Biodiversity Conference laid out ambitious goals to protect 30% of land and sea areas by the end of the decade — up from 17% of land and nearly 8% of oceans. The deal, which is to biodiversity what the Paris Agreement is to climate, also aims to restore 30% of degraded areas.
"It was already very difficult to agree on this, but the challenge lies ahead — because now, states have to implement what they agreed on," said Florian Titze, an international policy analyst at WWF in Germany.
To help track progress and ensure countries are implementing agreed targets, governments were required to submit updated national biodiversity strategies and action plans (NBSAPs) ahead of the Cali biodiversity summit. To date, only 34 out of 196 countries have done so. Germany is among those to have missed the deadline.
"Countries like Germany aren't feeling the pressure to submit their plans ..., because other countries haven't done so either," Titze told DW. "We only have another five years left until 2030. If the implementation of promises doesn't start now, we will likely miss the targets for 2030."
A new study found that 8.2% of oceans are now protected — a 0.5% increase since the 2022 biodiversity agreement. It also suggests that just 2.8% of that is effectively protected, calling the "gap between pledge and action vast."
What's holding back progress on implementing biodiversity plans?
This year's conference is expected to address the obstacles to updating and implementing action plans.
"What is often holding us back is a discussion with other sectors that feel that environmental policy is encroaching on them negatively on them or is problematic for competitiveness," said UN biodiversity chief Schomaker.
For instance, when the German government announced in 2023 it was going to abolish "environmentally harmful" tax breaks for diesel fuel, farmers took to the streets in their thousands to protest what they saw as a threat to their livelihoods.
Kazakhstan sees return of wild horses
Przewalski's horses were almost extinct. Now, animals from zoos in Germany and the Czech Republic are being released into the wilds of Kazakhstan.
Image: David W Cerny/REUTERS
'Historic moment' for rare horses
The first steps into a new home: A Przewalski's horse carefully leaves the container in which it was transported from the Czech Republic to the Kazakh steppe. He will never forget the sight of the animals running into the steppe, Prague Zoo Director Miroslav Bobek told dpa news agency, calling it a "historic moment." The journey to get to this point was a long one.
Image: ABDUAZIZ MADYAROV/AFP/Getty Images
The scent of freedom
The "Return Of The Wild Horses" community project of the Prague and Berlin zoos aims to reintroduce the animals to Kazakhstan. Przewalski's horses are one of the last wild horse breeds in the world and were almost extinct for a time. There are now around 2,400 animals worldwide, but only a few live in the wild.
Image: ABDUAZIZ MADYAROV/AFP/Getty Images
Tricky trip to Kazakhstan
The flight from Prague, for which the animals were sedated, took 15 hours. "We had to deal with many problems, but in the end we successfully transported the three Przewalski's horses over a distance of more than 4,000 kilometers," zoo director Bobek told dpa. The animals will meet four specimens from Berlin Zoo in the Kazakh steppe.
Image: Vaclav Pancer/CTK/picture alliance
Welcome to the wilderness
In early June, two mares, Ypsilonka and Zeta the Second, and a stallion, Zorro, arrived at the reintroduction center, where they will get used to life in the Altyn Dala nature reserve. The Prague horses were transported from the airport to their destination in pick-up trucks over unpaved roads. Here a container with a horse is being unloaded.
Image: ABDUAZIZ MADYAROV/AFP/Getty Images
Pioneer Przewalski's
The four Berlin horses also arrived in Kazakhstan at the beginning of June. Together with the Czech animals, they will form the first herd in the region. Over the next five years, at least 40 horses are to be reintroduced to their natural habitat. The long-term goal is to create a new population of the rare horse species in the wild.
Image: Jens Kalaene/dpa/picture-alliance
Successful field test in Mongolia
In the past, Prague Zoo has already successfully reintroduced Przewalski's horses to the Gobi Desert in Mongolia, including these ones. The animals are well adapted to the extreme conditions of the Central Asian steppes. Przewalski's horses are very hardy. They can live in both icy cold and extreme heat.
Image: Petr Josek Snr/REUTERS
The horses are part of a bigger picture
The reintroduction is not only intended to preserve the species ― researchers are also hoping for a positive effect on the local flora and fauna. As large grazers, wild horses contribute to open spaces, which can have a positive impact on insects, small mammals and ground-nesting birds. The Przewalski's horses are also said to make the grass steppe more resilient to fires.
Image: David W Cerny/REUTERS
7 images1 | 7
The government postponed a full phaseout until 2026, although the UN's biodiversity deal aims to progressively reduce subsidies harmful to nature by $500 billion (€461 billion) a year by 2030.
"We are accelerating positive biodiversity spending, but it is still vastly outnumbered or outspent by subsidies that are negative for biodiversity and that's a key issue for us to attack," said Schomaker.
Advertisement
Who will pay for nature protection?
Who foots the bills for biodiversity spending will be up for discussion at Cali. At the last summit, developed countries pledged to raise $25 billion annually by 2025 and $30 billion by 2030 in financial aid for low-income countries to protect their nature.
But a recent report found only two countries — Norway and Sweden — had paid their fair share toward the target. Some 23 out of 28 countries analyzed "are paying less than half of what they pledged."
In a press conference ahead of the summit, Colombian Environment Minister Susana Muhamad called for developed countries to increase what they'd pledged "as we need to give a signal that the commitments that were agreed on ... are going on track."
Countries also agreed to earmark $200 billion a year for safeguarding biodiversity by 2030 through public and private sources, with negotiators expected to talk about how the huge sum will be raised in time.
Rich biodiversity hiding in Delhi’s urban sprawl
08:02
This browser does not support the video element.
WWF's Titze hopes policymakers will agree on some aspects of their financing strategy. In a best-case scenario, this would include ways to distribute money to low-income countries, how to deal with subsidies harmful to biodiversity and the role of private sector financing.
"The question is how effective it will be? Can countries commit to concrete measures?" said Titze.
Finding financial solutions
Funding solutions that balance nature conservation with economic needs are on the agenda, said Schomaker.
Biodiversity credits are one tool being mooted. These schemes in theory would allow companies to offset environmental damage by buying credits from organizations or projects that safeguard or restore nature. Advocates say monetizing nature in this way would incentivize protection, while critics have said credits are a tool that invites greenwashing.
Also on the table are debt-for-nature-swaps, which entail relieving a country's debt in exchange for investment in conservation.
Another major discussion will center around the use of genetic data from nature and income that derives from that use — like in the pharmaceutical sector, where DNA sequencing of plants to produce medication can lead to multibillion-dollar profits.
Delegates will discuss fairly compensating countries with a lot of biodiversity — which are also frequently low-income — for the use of their genetic resources, as well as Indigenous communities who often preserve these species. That money could be channeled into protecting habitats.
While financial incentives can help, experts warn they must be paired with concrete action and political will to make lasting change.
"If we lose ecosystems and a tolerable climate, then human life as we know it will no longer be possible on this planet," said Titze. "We are talking about preserving our own civilization. There is little that could be more important."
Edited by: Jennifer Collins
This article was updated to reflect the change in NBSAPs.
Biodiversity loss and its significant impact on our lives
No more honey, tequila or bird song — as species on the planet disappear at an alarming rate cartoonist Rohan Chakravarty (aka Green Humour) looks at some of the essential services and guilty pleasures we could miss.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
An unsweetened world without honey
Animals help pollinate about 88% of the world's flowering plants — and few are better known than the honeybee. Humans have managed these bees for centuries, harvesting their sweet honey and wax to make items like candles. While domesticated honeybees aren't at risk of extinction, beekeepers worldwide are reporting massive colony losses. Threats include pesticides, climate change …
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
A warmer and sleepier world
… and the loss of the plants from which they feed. Honeybees, which belong to the genus Apis, are among the main coffee plant pollinators. But research suggests extreme heat is harming bees and coffee production, with growers in Latin America seeing yield declines. Honeybees constitute only a tiny fraction of pollinators. Many of the species, so vital to our food supply, are under threat.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
No more sunrises? Well, the tequila kind
Insects aren't the only pollinators. Tequila and Mezcal lovers should toast to the long-nosed bat. These winged, nocturnal creatures' favorite tipple is the nectar of the agave plant from which tequila is made. The bats get a dusting of pollen when they stop off for a drink. However, conservationists say populations are in decline due to habitat loss, climate change and agave overharvesting.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
The fig and the wasp: A special relationship
The fig tree and fig wasp would not exist without each other. Females lay their eggs inside the plant's fruit, crawling through a hole so narrow they lose their wings, becoming trapped. The eggs hatch and larvae burrow out, transform into wasps and fly away, carrying fig pollen with them. While the tree and the wasp are not in immediate danger, scientists say increasing temperatures are a threat.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
Wake me up before you ... migrate
Robin populations are strong, but warmer temperatures are changing their behavior. American robins, for instance, are starting their migratory journeys to breeding grounds much earlier. Studies have shown other bird species are having fewer chicks because of climate change. If bird habitats are not protected, availability of food and shelter could be curtailed.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
Chips minus the fish
Fish face multiple threats from pollution and over-exploitation to climate change. One study found that sustainable fish catches dropped 4% between 1930 and 2010, with China and Japan seeing declines of 15% to 35%, due to warming waters. Some 90% of fish populations are now over exploited or depleted. Billions of people rely directly on a healthy marine ecosystem for food and work.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
The connection between flying foxes and a stinky fruit
The durian. It's a polarizing fruit. To aficionados, it's the delicious king of all fruit. To haters, it's a stinky abomination. Whether you love or despise it, you have the flying fox, which is actually a bat, to thank for its existence. The giant bats help to pollinate the tree. Flying foxes are hunted as pests and are also under threat from habitat loss.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
All hail the chocolate midge
Swarms of midges — what a nuisance! Well, actually, we wouldn't have any chocolate without the chocolate midge. The tiny fly is thought to be the only pollinator that can get into the flowers of the cacao tree. These midges prefer wild cacao to the cultivated stuff and are suffering from habitat loss as forest is cleared for cacao plantations. Improving midge habitat equals bigger fruit yields.
Image: Rohan Chakravarty/DW
Chocolate bar: €2, Nature: Priceless
In Montreal, states will try to reach an agreement to prevent mass extinction and to protect our ability to produce food as well as the trillions of dollars in ecosystem services, like pollination, provided by nature. But much of the wealth nature provides is unquantifiable, from the feeling of happiness at the sound of a robin's song to the sense of calm conjured by a forest stroll.