1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites

US Defence Minister in Beijing

Philipp Bilsky (act)November 5, 2007

Year after year, China's military budget is increasing in double figures. The Chinese government considers the strengthening of its forces as a natural part of China's modernisation. Whereas Washington is worried the US' military superiority in Asia could be jeopardised.

US Secretary of State Robert Gates wants more transparency in China's military budget
US Secretary of State Robert Gates wants more transparency in China's military budgetImage: AP

High on the agenda of US Defence Minister Robert Gates is transparency in China's military budget. According to Pentagon experts, the budget is higher than Beijing has stated. Franz Umbach, the head of the Asia-Pacific Security programme at the German Council on Foreign Relations, said Washington probably had a point.

"The problem is that the Chinese military budget, as it has been published does not disclose all the defence expenditure. Research and development funding for instance is hidden in other budgets. So there really isn't enough transparency -- at least not yet."

According to official statistics, China's military expenditure rose by about 20 percent this year to 45 billion US dollars. The US experts, however, think the figure of 125 billion dollars is more realistic. Although this higher figure would still only represent a quarter of the US military budget, Washington is anxious US military supremacy in Asia could be at risk.

Chinese arms programmes

A series of Chinese arms programmes is also a cause for concern. Some are even directed against the US army. At least, that's what Christopher Griffin from a conservative Washington-based think tank, the American Enterprise Institute Public Policy Research, believes.

"The first is the anti-satellite capability, the second is investing in the capability to sink American aircraft carriers and the last is advanced air defences and, increasingly, new hydro aircraft. Combined, all three of these seem to be designed to limit our capabilities to intervene in a destabilising event in the region," Griffin said.

An escalation of the Taiwan conflict might pose a serious problem for Washington if it were not able to intervene. But there are also other potential conflicts, such as North Korea, warned Griffin although he said it was "something that no-one wants to discuss right now."

"If the North Korean regime has nuclear weapons, if Kim Jong-il reaches the end of his life, dies of natural causes, there could be internal destabilisation in North Korea -- the United States would most likely have to intervene to secure those nuclear weapons. What would happen between the US and Chinese forces at that point?," Griffin asked.

Gentler tone?

Despite these serious concerns, the US Defence Minister has decided to adopt a more gentle tone towards Beijing than his predecessor Donald Rumsfeld. Although he is worried about China's military ascent, he refuses to depict China as a military threat for the United States.

But Washington's reserve is not only due to the new face in the Pentagon. The US can simply not afford anything more right now. Washington is already overspending in Iraq and Afghanistan and wants to avoid conflict in East Asia, defence experts say.

One way of doing this is thus to improve communication. During their talks in Beijing, the two defence ministers have already decided to set up a hotline between their two armies to avoid conflicts in the future.

Skip next section DW's Top Story

DW's Top Story

Skip next section More stories from DW

More stories from DW