Visionary, or monstrous architecture? Brutalist buildings are either loved or hated. Considered eyesores for decades, they're hip again — but many are still endangered. Germany is calling #SOSBrutalism.
Image: Imago/imagebroker
Advertisement
Threatened or protected: Brutalist architecture around the world
Seen by some as the most disgraceful architectural style of the 20th century, Brutalism also has devoted fans who want to save threatened or neglected historic buildings.
Image: CC BY-NC 2.0/Glasgowfoodie
A movement based on concrete
Brutalist architecture is characterized above all by its exposed, raw concrete — called "béton brut" in French, which gave the style its name. A pioneer of the movement was the famous Swiss-French architect Le Corbusier. Pictured here is a section of his Unité d'Habitation in Marseille, France. Many Brutalist buildings are under threat today; either damaged through neglect or facing demolition.
Image: IPON/IMAGO
Center of learning
The National Library of Kosovo was designed by Andrija Mutnjakovic and inaugurated in Pristina in 1982. Its mission is to "collect, preserve and promote the documentary and intellectual heritage of Kosovo." The building itself is intended to represent a style "that combines Byzantine and Islamic architectural forms," according to the architect.
Built in 1971, Miodrag Zivkovic's monument to the Battle of Sutjeska is located in Sutjeska National Park, Bosnia and Herzegovina. It was erected to commemorate some 20,000 partisans who fought against advancing German forces in May and June 1943.
Image: Reuters/M. Djurica
An international trend
Brutalism experienced its heyday between the 1950s and 1970s. The sometimes monumental concrete colossi were built all over the world, stirring controversy. In India, it was Le Corbusier who stimulated new architectural trends in the 1950s with striking buildings like the Secretariat Building here in Chandigarh or others in Ahmedabad, which inspired many architects.
Image: Christina Gascoigne/Robert Hardi/picture alliance
Much to discover: Brutalism in Eastern Europe
In recent years, many elaborately illustrated books have been published on the diversity of Brutalist architecture in Eastern Europe. The Hotel Thermal in the spa town of Karlovy Vary in the Czech Republic was designed by the husband and wife team of Vera Machoninova and Vladimir Machonin. A campaign was launched to save the building under the name "Respect Madam."
Image: Petr Svancara/CTK/picture alliance
Heated debates in the US and UK
The gray giants are particularly controversial in the United States and the United Kingdom. King Charles is also a vehement opponent of Brutalism. However, there is no threat to destroy "The Egg" in Alabany, New York. Completed in 1978, the building enjoys great popularity as a Center for Performing Arts.
Image: John Greim/Loop Images/picture alliance
Classics face demolition
It was a years-long fight to preserve the Robin Hood Gardens residential complex in East London, built by architects Alison and Peter Smithson. Star architect Zaha Hadid, who died in 2016, was also part of this campaign, but to no avail. In late summer 2017, the bulldozers arrived and demolition work began.
Image: Construction Photography/picture alliance
Progressive victories in monument protection
Some Brutalist buildings are now listed as heritage sites. They may not be demolished, but their use can still be problematic. The Preston Bus Station in the UK for example, is far too big for the number of buses that are supposed to arrive and depart here. An architectural firm from New York is now planning a partial conversion which includes a climbing wall, soccer pitch and skate park.
Brutalist buildings are under threat in Germany as well. The project #SOSBrutalism, initiated by the German Architecture Museum (DAM) in cooperation with the Wüstenrot Foundation, aims to draw attention to deteriorating buildings. Among them is the Central Animal Laboratory of the Free University of Berlin, also known as the "Mouse Bunker."
Image: Soeren Stache/dpa/picture alliance
Successful conversion
If there is no money for maintenance and renovation, an entire building can quickly deteriorate. The Brutalist St. Agnes Church in Berlin was such a case. In 2011, it was leased and renovated by Berlin gallery owner Johann König. Its distinctive architecture has been preserved and it is now home to the König Gallery.
The Helicoide de la Roca Tarpeya in Caracas, Venezuela, was to be a huge shopping center. Due to underfunding and political conflicts, construction was halted in 1960. In the 1970s, the building was illegally occupied and later used by the secret service as its headquarters. It is still partly used today as a prison for political prisoners.
Image: Ariana Cubillos/AP/picture alliance
Brutalism with a twist
Habitat 67 in Montreal, Canada, is one of the best-known Brutalist buildings. Architect Moshe Safdie designed it for Expo 1967 and actually saw it as a counter-reaction to Brutalism. It has been a listed building since 2009.
Image: Êrik Lattwein/Zoonar/picture alliance
12 images1 | 12
"There's never been an architectural style with a more unfortunate name than Brutalism," says Catherine Croft, director of the Twentieth Century Society (C20), which aims to protect and promote Brutalist architecture in the UK.
"Now people have realized that it doesn't mean that it's architecture that is brutal," she says. Rather, many now see the style as honest, sculptural and imaginative.
But just as many still truly hate the style: Prince Charles himself is a heavyweight critic of those "concrete monstrosities."
"The popularity of Brutalism is really rocketing": CroftImage: DW/J. Jitz
New hype, new exhibition
The internet keeps stirring up debate when it comes to Brutalism. All over social media, fans post black-and-white photographs taken from unusual perspectives, emphasizing the dramatic effect of these layered buildings. On Facebook, the "Brutalism Appreciation Society" has attracted nearly 40,000 members.
Aficionados of the architectural style can even add a touch of Brutalism to their living room, or wear it, with pillowcases and T-shirts showcasing these buildings also for sale online.
Surfing on this social media hype, the German Architecture Museum (DAM) and the Wüstenrot Foundation have started using the hashtag #SOSBrutalism to make these buildings visible worldwide in order to contribute to saving those that are currently threatened.
"Brutalism represents an anti-attitude, an anti-idyll," says campaign co-initiator Philip Kurz, of the Wüstenrot Foundation. Some 900 buildings - from London to Abidjan, from Tokyo to Caracas - are already documented on the website sosbrutalism.org. Among the structures featured in the database, some have already been demolished while others are currently endangered.
Now, the German Architecture Museum is opening an exhibition on November 9 based on the online campaign. The show called "SOS Brutalism — Save the Concrete Monsters" gives an overview of the architectural style thanks to photos from Japan, Brazil, the former Yugoslavia, the USA, Israel, Great Britain and West Germany, where many buildings, including churches, were built between 1950 and 1980.
'Brut,' not brutal
The architectural movement was popular from the mid-1950s to the 1970s. After that, the gray giants featuring raw concrete, geometric modular elements and a somewhat monolithic style were largely considered eyesores.
The exposure of raw construction materials was an aspect emphasized by the approach. The style referred not only to raw concrete (called in French "béton brut"), but also to Jean Dubuffet's Art Brut.
Swiss-French architect Le Corbusier was a pioneer of the movement, with his 1952 Unité d'Habitation in Marseille. His generation of architects prioritized uncompromising truthfulness.
Most of these buildings are around 50 years old today. Those that were well-maintained have turned into highly desirable spaces; others are in a more problematic condition.
For their 1970s residential estate in London, called Robin Hood Gardens, Brutalist architects Alison and Peter Smithson designed "streets in the skies," or aerial walkways connecting the rows of apartments.
Marked for demolition: the Robin Hood GardensImage: DW/J. Jitz
They were intended to promote interaction between the residents, but the rundown corridors turned into unattractive areas where people would dump whatever they didn't want in their own apartment.
The housing estate has been scheduled for demolition, prompting a campaign for its preservation supported by high-profile architects such as Richard Rogers and the late Zaha Hadid. The British government nevertheless decided against its heritage listing in 2015; the building now faces demolition.
Catherine Croft, the initiator of the campaign, still sees an overall positive development in the current fate of Brutalist buildings. As a result of public ownership and recession, the buildings were not well maintained, "so they were looking shabby," she says.
"But now the popularity of Brutalism is really rocketing. What we need now is to get local and national governments to realize what amazing buildings they have and get them to invest in them again," she says.
After suffering years of bad reputation, Trellick Tower in northwest London is now a pop culture iconImage: picture-alliance/Arcaid/S. J. Duncan
Post-war revolutionaries
There are also positive examples in the fight to save Brutalism. In the 1970s, the Trellick Tower in London had an extremely bad reputation for crime, with tabloids nicknaming it the "Tower of Terror." After modernization measures, the tower was awarded a heritage listing in 1998. Featured in several music videos and films, the iconic tower has since gained cult status.
Brutalism aimed to offer a collectivist alternative to post-war architecture. Its bunker-like style has even been described by some architects as a method for processing war trauma.
But through successful examples of preservation, Brutalism has obtained a new edge. Philip Kurz of Wüstenrot has his own theory to explain the style's current popularity. "In a society that doesn't have many revolutionaries, these architects with revolutionary ideas are appealing to us," he says.
Controversial architecture
04:42
This browser does not support the video element.
The exhibition "SOS Brutalism — Save the Concrete Monsters!" runs from November 9, 2017, through April 2, 2018, at the German Architecture Museum in Frankfurt.