Why Nepal sends so many migrant workers to the Middle East
Diwakar Rai
November 1, 2022
Despite the potential for abuse and exploitation, Middle Eastern countries continue to attract hundreds of thousands of Nepali migrant workers every year.
Advertisement
Kumar Thapa, a 41-year-old migrant worker, returned to Nepal in 2018 after laboring for nine years in the Middle East.
Working for a construction company in Saudi Arabia, he used to save enough to send the equivalent of about €100 ($98) to his family back home. The money was spent on his child's education as well as on building a small house in their hometown in Sindhupalchowk district.
All in all, Thapa's family was able to afford a comfortable life with the income he earned in the Middle East.
But his story is more of an exception than a rule.
Many Nepalis who move to the region in search of work encounter widespread abuse and exploitation.
At least 7,467 migrant workers have died abroad since 2008, according to figures from the government's Labor Migration Report, with 750 of those deaths reported between 2018 and 2019.
These figures exclude workers who migrate through unauthorized channels as well as laborers who work in India.
'Kafala system' ensures widespread abuse
Recruitment agencies often deploy intermediaries to find potential migrant workers. They regularly use deception or coercion to hire workers and promise them lucrative jobs.
While host countries usually require employers to pay recruitment fees, they often pass on the costs to workers, who take out loans to pay back the costs.
The workers then face a heavy debt burden amounting to thousands of euros even before they leave their country of origin.
Pregnant women in Nepal struggle to access health services
03:00
From the time they land in their host country, they are subject to stringent restrictions on their movement and freedoms, as part of the "Kafala" — or sponsorship — system, which gives employers total control over migrant workers' employment and immigration status.
The system is in force in all Arab Gulf countries, except Iraq, as well as in Jordan and Lebanon.
Employers regularly seize workers' passports, visas and phones, and sometimes also reduce or withhold their wages. While domestic workers are confined to their homes, laborers toiling at construction and industrial sites are relegated to tiny and overcrowded dorms.
Gender-based discrimination is rampant with many female domestic workers experiencing abuse, including sexual violence.
Nepal's economy relies on remittances
Despite the risks and potential for exploitation, Middle Eastern countries continue to attract hundreds of thousands of Nepali migrant labor every year. Last year alone, over 620,000 Nepali workers moved to the region.
That's because these jobs often offer higher pay than jobs in Nepal.
Many workers then send remittances home, which now account for as much as 25% of the nation's total economic output. Nepal is currently the fifth most remittance-dependent economy in the world.
The remittances have lifted a significant number of households out of poverty.
This influx of outside cash has been keeping the economy afloat for a long time now, despite the country suffering bouts of political instability over the past decade.
The high reliance on remittances means that the government has been wary of taking measures that could hurt migration to these countries, and, in turn, the flow of cash into Nepal.
Nepali woman heads back to school — with her son
In Nepal, only 57% of women can read and write. Among them is Parwati Sunar, who left school early and had her first child at the age of 16. Today, she's trying to make up for lost time — in the same school as her son.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Close quarters
Parwati Sunar, 27, lives in a two-room house with a tin roof and unfinished bricks. She shares the home with her sons Resham (11) and Arjun (7) and her mother-in-law. Her husband works as a laborer in the southern Indian city of Chennai.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Cold shower
Since the house has neither running water nor a toilet, part of the family's morning ritual involves washing in front of the house at the water pump. An adjacent field serves as a spot for their toilet duties.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Walking to school
After dressing and eating a simple meal of rice and lentils, Sunar sets off for school with her eldest son Resham (right). The walk takes about 20 minutes. Resham has no problem walking to school together with his mother: "We chat as we walk to school and we learn from our conversation," the 11-year-old told the Reuters news agency.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Oldest in class
Sunar is in seventh grade at the Punarbas village school in southwestern Nepal. It's fun to be in a class with her, said 14-year-old Bijay. "Didi is pleasant," he added, using the Nepali term for an elder sister. "I help her in studies and she helps me too."
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Many girls drop out
"She is doing a good job," Shruti, who is in 10th grade, said of Sunar. "I think others should follow her and go to school." According to official figures, 94.4% of girls in Nepal attend elementary school, but nearly half drop out for reasons ranging from lack of textbooks to poverty. Sunar, however, wants to keep going.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Bytes and bikes
After school, Sunar and her son take off their school uniforms, jump on their bike and ride together to the New World Vision Computer Institute, where they take a computer course — in preparation for a possible future office job.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
A new start
"I enjoy learning and am proud to attend with classmates who are like my own children," said Sunar. She regrets dropping out of school as a teenager, and has given up her job as a housemaid in neighboring India in order focus full-time on her education — computer skills included.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
Long-distance relationship
Sunar's husband works as an unskilled laborer in Chennai, more than 2,000 kilometers (around 1,200 miles) away. He supports the family, but they rarely see each other. Video calls are often the only way to keep in touch. The family belongs to the Dalit community — the lowest Hindu caste of the "untouchables."
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
What comes after school?
In the evening, Sunar sits in front of her small brick house. What will she do after her schooling is complete? She doesn't know yet. At the moment, her only thought is to finish school, she said. But she hopes that she isn't the only one and that other women in rural Nepal will follow her example.
Image: Navesh Chitrakar/REUTERS
9 images1 | 9
Recruitment agencies also lobby the Nepali government to ensure their activities aren't restricted.
"The Foreign Employment Act states that the recruiters' businesses are protected. Those companies don't care whether workers' rights are respected or not, or when workers are offered different, low-paying jobs than what was mentioned in their contracts," Kul Prasad Karki, chairperson of Pravasi Nepali Coordination Committee (PNCC), an NGO working for the rights of migrant workers, told DW.
Advertisement
Workers' rights in the spotlight
The issue of migrant worker abuses has been back in international focus as Qatar prepares to host the 2022 FIFA World Cup this month.
Reports suggest that many of the thousands of workers who toiled under scorching conditions to build the infrastructure needed for the tournament — including stadiums, roads and hotels — have suffered from heat-related deaths and injuries.
Nepali workers have formed a sizable contingent of the workforce employed in Qatar.
Of the nearly 2.7 million people living in the Gulf country, Nepalis account for about 432,000 – or 16% of the total population, according to UN data from July 2022. Most of them are employed at construction sites.
Amid growing global scrutiny, some Gulf countries have started implementing limited reforms to the system, like allowing workers to transfer jobs after a certain period and easing restrictions on returning to their home country.
Still, workers and rights groups say many who want to change jobs face threats from employers and bureaucratic delays, and the measures do little to protect domestic workers.
Kathmandu: Living and breathing in one of the world's most polluted cities
Nepal's capital Kathmandu is one of the fastest-developing cities in the world — and also one of the dirtiest. The city's inhabitants are battling with the health consequences.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Then and now
Looking down on Kathmandu from Swayambhu temple, a sacred Buddhist pilgrimage site in the west of the city, — last year and in 1967. Green spaces have been built over, and mountains have disappeared behind a veil of smog. In 2018, Nepal ranked as having the worst air quality of the 180 countries in the global Environmental Performance Index.
Image: Marco Panzetti
City of cars
The Nepalese capital is set in a valley, where air pollution gets trapped between the mountains. Much of it is dust from unpaved, dirt roads. Brick kilns on the outskirts of the city also foul up the air. But the biggest culprit is traffic.
Image: Marco Panzetti
No walk in the park
The number of vehicles in Kathmandu is rising by 14% each year, three times faster than the population. As the amount of traffic grows, pedestrians face cars whizzing by in terrifying proximity, deafening noise and smog that makes the eyes water and the breath shorter.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Poisonous air
Pollution takes it toll on residents' health. "My nose is dry, I suffer from headaches and my lungs are not well. So I am using a mask to protect myself from dust," says 63-year-old Narayan Dahal, walking through Kathmandu's busy Kalanki district.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Limited protection
After two days wear in Kathmandu, a face mask is grimy from the air. While dust causes discomfort, these masks do little to protect the wearer from the fine particles in smog that go much deeper into the lungs and can cause heart and respiratory diseases, and even cancer.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Getting a lungfull
Many in Kathmandu don't bother with masks at all, and for street traders like this young cotton candy seller at one of Kathmandu's busiest crossroads, the fumes are an occupational hazard.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Rushing into the modern age
Just half a century ago, the Nepalese capital was a town of only a few hundred thousand people. Today, it's a metropolis of 3 million. Without proper planning, urbanization has exploded out of control. The city's main arteries, like Kanti Path, are choked with exhaust fumes.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Gasping for breath
A woman on a break from work holds her throat as she surveys the polluted city from above. Kathmandu is still being rebuilt after a catastrophic earthquake hit Nepal in April 2015, killing 9,000 people. Some hoped new builds would adopt cleaner burning brick kilns, for instance. But for now, pollution remains a big problem.
Image: Marco Panzetti
Memories of fresh air
"I used to come to Kathmandu as a kid, and the air was not bad," says 29-year-old Buddhist monk Pasang Thunglu. "But when I came back in 2015, the air was unbreathable. The earthquake made things worse because now construction sites produce lots of dust."
Image: Marco Panzetti
Dirty and devine
Even the deities aren't safe. In a Kathmandu craftsman's showroom, this brass statue of the goddess Tara is wrapped in paper to prevent dust from ruining the painted details of her face.
Image: Marco Panzetti
10 images1 | 10
A huge human cost
For Nepal, the massive outward migration and the remittance-reliant economy — notwithstanding their socioeconomic benefits — have come with a huge human cost, with concerns that the system is disrupting the nation's social fabric.
With many people working abroad for long periods of time, leaving their spouses behind, the divorce rate has gone up.
It has also accelerated a shift from traditional joint families toward nuclear families, resulting in many of the elderly, particularly in rural areas, being left without any caregivers.
"Migration is a natural process and it is a choice," said Manju Gurung, co-founder of POURAKHI Nepal, an organization working for the betterment of migrant workers. "But everyone should be informed about what it brings to an individual's life."