Zimbabwe: Top court rejects bid to delay elections
May 9, 2023
The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party wanted a delimitation report declared invalid in a bid to delay elections until new voting boundaries had been reviewed.
Advertisement
Zimbabwe will go ahead and hold presidential and legislative elections between July and August, the country's Constitutional Court ruled.
Zimbabwe's main opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), had sought to have the elections delayed by having the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission's (ZEC) delimitation report nullified.
What is delimitation?
Delimitation is a process during which the country is divided into constituencies and wards for election purposes.
Advertisement
When delimitation is unbalanced to favor a particular party, it is known as "gerrymandering" which can be used to manipulate election results.
The MDC was particularly concerned about the delimitation report released in February, which it said drew the electoral boundaries and precincts in a way that favored Zimbabwe's ruling ZANU-PF party.
The opposition party took their concerns to the country's Constitutional Court, which rejected their application on the grounds that the MDC could not prove how fundamental rights were being violated and how the delimitation of constituencies affected those rights.
But the party's president, Douglas Mwonzora, told reporters that the court dismissed the application because it does not hold jurisdiction, and that the Constitutional Court had "made a political judgement."
The week that changed Zimbabwe
President Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe was removed as the ZANU-PF party's leader after holding the post for 37 years. The party’s youth league, the military and his supporters also withdrew from backing Mugabe.
Image: picture-alliance/AP Photo/B.Curtis
Mnangagwa, Grace Mugabe go head to head
In November 2018, Robert Mugabe dismissed his vice president, Emmerson Mnangagwa, after accusing him of "plotting a coup against the government." Some Zimbabweans feared Mugabe was grooming his wife, Grace Mugabe, to take over in the event of his death.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/J. Njikizana
Chiwenga's warning
On November 13, 2017, General Constantino Chiwenga, commander of Zimbabwe's Defense Force, warned that the army could "step in" to save the country from political tension and economic crisis.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/J. Njikizana
Tanks in Harare
Military and armored vehicles were seen at the outskirts of Harare, the capital of Zimbabwe, on November 14, 2017. On the same day, the military also took over the state-run broadcaster ZBC.
Image: Reuters/P. Bulawayo
Mugabe safe in army hands
On November 15, 2017, Major General SB Moyo, the military spokesman, announced on the ZBC that Mugabe and his family were "safe and sound and their security was guaranteed." He said the military was targeting "criminals around" Mugabe who were "committing crimes that are causing social and economic suffering."
Image: Reuters/ZBC
A 'smiling' Mugabe meets Chiwenga
On November 16, 2017, General Constantino Chiwenga, along with other officials, was seen in military uniform meeting President Robert Mugabe (C) at the State House. It was reported that Mugabe was smiling as they both shook hands. However, the leaders of ZANU-PF announced that there was "no going back."
Image: Reuters/Zimpapers/J. Nyadzayo
Mugabe puts in a public appearance
After being placed under house arrest, Mugabe appeared publicly at a university graduation ceremony on November 17, 2017. Here, a military officer adjusts a chair for Mugabe, who is dressed in a blue-and-yellow academic gown, to sit on after arriving to preside over the ceremony. Mugabe, who was reportedly tired, was then caught falling asleep.
Image: picture-alliance/AP Photo/B. Curtis
Zimbabweans call on Mugabe to go
On November 18, 2017, residents of the capital, Harare, held a protest with anti-Mugabe placards demanding the president's resignation. Veterans of the independence war, activists and ruling party leaders called publicly for Mugabe to be forced from office.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/Z. Auntony
Mugabe ousted from ZANU-PF leadership
Zimbabwean War Veterans leader Chris Mutsvangwa (R) arrived at a meeting of the ruling ZANU-PF party in Harare November 19, 2017. After hours of deliberation, the party announced that it had decided to fire Mugabe as leader of the party.
Image: Reuters/P. Bulawayo
Mugabe does not step down
Many expected that after being recalled as ZANU-PF party leader, President Mugabe would use his address to the nation resign with dignity. Zimbabweans were left shocked after the rambling speech made no reference to him stepping down. Mugabe now faces impeachment, with proceedings believed to be starting on Tuesday.
Image: Getty Images/AFP/Str
End of an era
Rather than face impeachment proceedings, Robert Mugabe prompted dancing in the streets of Harare when he resigned on November 22. "My decision to resign is voluntary on my part and arises from my concern for the welfare of the people of Zimbabwe and my desire for a smooth, non-violent transfer of power," the 93-year-old said in a letter.
Image: picture-alliance/AP/T. Mukwazhi
Euphoria in Harare
Supporters of Emmerson Mnangagwa celebrate the end of four decades under Mugabe. Mnangagwa was joined by cheering crowds after he returned to Zimbabwe from exile in neighboring South Africa. He is expected to be sworn in on November 24.
Image: picture-alliance/AP Photo/B.Curtis
11 images1 | 11
'Country a laughingstock'
"It is an unfair judgement and we don't accept that judgement. The matter is not stopping here. We are going to continue with our struggle for democracy. We want free and fair elections in Zimbabwe. And there can never be free and fair elections where the delimitation report is so fundamentally flawed," Mwonzora told DW.
"This is a recipe for disaster for country. It makes our country a laughingstock."
The MDC was represented by Lovemore Madhuku, a law professor and constitutional lawyer.
"Our clients are very clear they want the delimitation report attended to by a court and a declaration of invalidity made and for that reason they then have to go to the High Court," Madhuku said.
"So, if they want to fight legally, they will have to go to a court that will issue a declaration of invalidity."
The ZEC is yet to respond to a request for comment from DW.
President intolerant of dissent
Controversies and accounts of irregularities have marred Zimbabwe's recent elections.
Incumbent leader President Emmerson Mnangagwa, came to power in 2017 after a military coup ousted longtime president Robert Mugabe.
While Zimbabweans initially welcomed the putsch and Mnangagwa's promise of democratic reforms, rights groups have recently accused him of being as oppressive as Mugabe.
Amnesty International and other rights groups said the arrest and pretrial detention of 50-year-old MDC parliamentarian Job Sikhala and other activists — along with the banning of some political meetings — suggest that Mnangagwa is willing to use the justice system against his political opponents.
The dates for Zimbabwe's polls have yet to be announced.
This article has been adapted from a radio report that was originally broadcast on DW's daily radio show, AfricaLink.
Edited by Keith Walker and Cai Nebe
Robert Mugabe: From hero to despot
Mugabe led the overthrow of Rhodesia's white rulers, instituting a new era for the country. But his 37-year descent into despotism and his economic ruin of the country eventually drove a military coup against him.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/U. Baumgarten
The birth of a political force
Mugabe's political life began in the 1960s with the formation of a radical anti-colonialist movement that fought white minority rule. He joined Joshua Nkomo's National Democratic Party and its fight against white government. He was jailed for 10 years, during which he studied tirelessly. On release, the "thinking man's guerrilla" rose to the top of the Zimbabwe African National Liberation Army.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/Keystone Pictures USA
Mugabe takes power
After a 15-year war and global sanctions, Mugabe forced Ian Smith's government to negotiate, winning universal suffrage, new elections and independence. He was elected prime minister, initially winning approval for policies of racial reconciliation and improving health and education for the black majority. But within two years, 20,000 people were killed fighting an insurgency from once-ally Nkomo.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/AFP
Land seizures
In 1987, Mugabe gained broad executive powers as president, with a reconciled Nkomo as deputy. He became an international pariah over the 90s for devastating the economy, rigging elections and seizing white farmers' land. His land reform policy, an attempt to placate angry war veterans, wrecked the crucial agricultural sector and foreign investors fled. By 2002, he was sanctioned internationally.
Image: AP
Human rights abuses
In the 2000s, Mugabe became increasingly flagrant with his oppression of Zimbabweans. In 2005, he notoriously started a campaign of destroying slums and "illegal dwellings," directly affecting at least 700,000 people. A huge number of urban and rural poor, who were opposed to Mugabe's rule, were made homeless. The campaign was condemnded by the United Nations.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/EPA
Lavish parties
As his people starved and his country was driven to ruin, Mugabe lived an extravagant life. For his 91st birthday in 2015, Mugabe threw a lavish party, costing a reported $1 million (€900,000), complete with elephant slaughters, called "obscene" by opposition figures. By 2015, his country had completely switched to the US dollar after inflation rates hit 89.7 sextillion percent year-on-year.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/T. Mukwazhi
Military coup
On November 14, 2017, military elements seized control of a public broadcaster and announced Mugabe would be held under house arrest. In the days that followed, people swept the streets to demand the resignation of Mugabe, cheering on the military resistance. First Vice President Emmerson Mnangagwa was backed as leader, and he replaced Mugabe a week later.
Image: picture-alliance/dpa/B. Khaled
Failing health
After his humiliating fall from power, Mugabe, who once claimed he would rule to the age of 100, quickly deteriorated. By September 2019, he was dying. After ruining his country's once-proud medical system, he was forced to seek treatment in Singapore.