Sidang Pembunuhan Samuel Paty Hantui Sekolah-sekolah Prancis
Lisa Louis
8 Desember 2023
Enam remaja didakwa membantu pembunuhan terhadap Samuel Paty terkait karikatur Nabi Muhammad. Pengadilan kini bersiap menjatuhkan vonis. Tapi Prancis mendebatkan kenapa kaum muda bisa terlibat dalam aksi brutal tersebut.
Iklan
Pembunuhan terhadap guru sejarah Prancis Samuel Paty tanggal 16 Oktober 2020 hingga kini masih terngiang di benak banyak orang. Betapa tidak? Di depan gerbang sekolah Jumat sore itu, lehernya digorok oleh seorang pemuda Chechnya berusia 18 tahun setelah menunjukkan gambar karikatur Nabi Muhammad terbitan majalah satir Charlie Hebdo di jam pelajaran.
Paty ingin menggugah diskusi tentang kebebasan berekspresi. Namun sang pembunuh mengaku ingin "membalaskan dendam nabi". Alasan serupa dipakai oleh dua orang teroris untuk menyerang kantor Charlie Hebdo di ibu kota Paris pada Januari 2015 silam dan menewaskan 12 awak redaksi.
Selain pelaku utama, terdakwa teror di Paris mencakup lima orang remaja pria dan seorang remaja perempuan. Mereka berusia antara 13 hingga 15 tahun ketika kejadian. Sebabnya, pengadilan memerintahkan sidang tertutup demi melindungi terdakwa. Karena berusia di bawah umur, mereka hanya diancam hukuman penjara hingga dua setengah tahun.
French teachers in danger
05:10
Kampanye kebencian di media sosial
Salah seorang terdakwa adalah murid perempuan yang pertama kali menghasut aksi protes mematikan terhadap Paty. Dia mengaku kepada ayahnya bahwa Paty telah meminta murid beragama Islam untuk meninggalkan kelas sebelum menampilkan kartun kontroversial tersebut. Gadis itu membingkai seakan dia dikeluarkan dari sekolah karena menentang aksi sang guru.
Iklan
Ayahnya yang marah sontak mengunggah video online dan menuntut sanksi, sambil menyebut nama Samuel Paty. Hasutan itu menjadi viral dan menarik perhatian nasional. Tapi apa yang saat itu belum diketahui adalah bahwa remaja putri itu telah berbohong. Dia bahkan tidak dijadwalkan menghadiri kelas Paty dan hanya mencari alasan setelah diskors karena berperilaku buruk. Kini dia didakwa telah menyebar fitnah.
Lima terdakwa lainnya mengaku telah membantu sang pembunuh mengidentifikasi Paty dengan imbalan uang. Kepada anak-anak tersebut, sang pembunuh diyakini mengklaim hanya ingin membuat Samuel Paty meminta maaf di depan kamera.
Selama sidang, keluarga Paty ingin memahami bagaimana serangan itu bisa terjadi, kata Virginie Le Roy, pengacara yang mewakili orang tua Paty, saudara perempuannya, seorang ipar serta dua keponakannya.
"Apakah anak-anak muda menganggap Paty pantas dihukum karena menayangkan kartun tersebut atau mereka hanya mengejar uang?” tanyanya dalam wawancara dengan DW. "Poin ini menjadi lebih penting karena semua terdakwa lahir di Prancis dan harus berkomitmen terhadap nilai-nilai demokrasi, termasuk kebebasan berekspresi,” tambah Le Roy.
Terror attacks in France since 2015
France has been hit by several terror attacks since 2015, when "Islamic State" militants launched a brutal attack across Paris. Over the past three years, there have been other attacks, and close calls.
Foto: Reuters/C. Hartmann
December 11, 2018: Strasbourg shooting
A gunman opened fire at a Christmas market in the eastern city of Strasbourg, home to the European Parliament. At least two people were killed and 12 injured. Prosecutors opened a terror investigation. France immediately raised its national security alert to its highest level in anticipation of copycat attacks.
Foto: picture-alliance/dpa/aptn
May 12, 2018: Paris knife attack
A man wielding a knife attacks bystanders in a central neighborhood in Paris, killing one person and wounding another four. French prosecutors open a terror probe into the attack, citing witness accounts that the assailant shouted "Allahu akbar" ("God is greatest"). The militant "Islamic State" (IS) group claims responsibility for the attack, calling the knifeman one of their "soldiers."
Foto: picture alliance/MAXPPP/O. Corsan
March 23, 2018: Trebes hostage crisis
An attacker claiming allegiance to IS perpetrates a string of violent crimes in the southern town of Trebes during the morning hours. He kills a man while stealing a car and then fires shots at police officers before entering a Super U grocery store, where he takes hostages. Police shoot dead the attacker. Four people are killed, including including policeman Arnaud Beltrame.
Foto: Imago/PanoramiC/R. Gosselin
October 1, 2017: Marseille train station knife attack
A man fatally stabs two women at the Marseille train station. The perpetrator, Ahmed Hanachi, is shot dead by police on patrol. IS claims responsibility for the attack in a post by its news agency Amaq. In it, they call Hanachi one of the group's "soldiers." Two Interior Ministry officials resign after it is revealed that Hanachi was an undocumented immigrant who they had failed to detain.
Foto: Reuters/J.P. Pelissier
April 20, 2017: Champs-Elysees police shooting
A gunman opens fire on police on the Champs-Elysees, Paris' most iconic boulevard. One police officer is killed and two individuals are injured before police shoot the gunman dead. A note praising IS is found next to the gunman's body. The terrorist group also claims responsibility. The attack occurs just days before the first round of the French presidential election. Security is tightened.
Foto: Imago/Zuma Press/A. Freindorf
February 3, 2017: Machete attempt at Louvre
Soldiers shoot and severely injure a knife-wielding man outside the Louvre museum in Paris after he assails them. One soldier is lightly injured. The attacker had two further machetes in his backpack. A subsequent investigation reveals the Egyptian national had traveled to France from Dubai on a valid tourist visa. A Twitter account associated with the man's name refers to IS in posts.
Foto: picture-alliance/AP Photo/K. Zihnioglu
July 26, 2016: Murder of Normandy priest
Two teens enter a church in Saint-Etienne-du-Rouvray, Normandy and slit the throat of an 85-year-old priest in front of five parishioners. Police shoot the 19-year-olds dead as they try to leave. IS takes responsibility and publishes a video of the teens pledging allegiance to the group. Many French Muslims attend the next Sunday's Mass to show solidarity with Catholics and condemn the attack.
Foto: picture-alliance/dpa/C. Petit Tesson
July 14, 2016: Truck attack in Nice
On Bastille Day, France's national holiday, a truck drives through crowds in Nice that had gathered to watch the fireworks on a major seaside promenade. Before being shot dead by police, the driver kills 86 and injuries more than 400 others. IS claims responsibility, stating that the attacker had responded to IS calls to target civilians living in coalition nations fighting IS in Syria and Iraq.
Foto: Reuters/E. Gaillard
November 13, 2015: Paris attacks
France's most deadly terror attack: IS jihadis armed with automatic weapons and explosives undertake coordinated attacks in Paris including at the Bataclan concert hall, the national stadium and various street cafes. The mass shootings and suicide bombings kill 130 people, injuring hundreds more. IS claims responsibility. Then-President Francois Hollande calls it an act of war by IS.
Foto: Reuters/C. Hartmann
August 21, 2015: Thalys train tragedy averted
A deadly attack is averted: On a high-speed train from Amsterdam to Paris, a man opens fire with an assault rifle that subsequently jams. Other train passengers tackle the man, preventing deadly violence. Four are injured including the attacker. The assailant had been known to French security officials for past drug-related activities and statements in defense of radical Islamist violence.
Foto: picture-alliance/dpa/P. Bonniere
June 26, 2015: Beheading, truck explosion near Lyon
Yassin Salhi beheads his boss and displays the head, along with two Islamic flags, on the gate outside a gas plant near Lyon. He also tries to blow up the factory by driving his van into the gas cylinders. The attempt fails, but unleashes a smaller explosion, injuring two. French authorities claim links between the man and IS. He commits suicide in prison.
Foto: Reuters/E. Foudrot
January 7-9, 2015: Charlie Hebdo, Jewish supermarket attack
Two men with automatic guns storm the offices of satire magazine Charlie Hebdo, killing 12 and wounding 12 others. A different gunman kills a police officer the next day, then four more during a hostage-taking on January 9 at a kosher grocery. Police eventually shoot all three gunmen dead, but not before they claim allegiance to IS and al-Qaida.
Foto: AFP/Getty Images/G. Tibbon
12 foto1 | 12
Efek jera vonis pengadilan
Raphael Dargent, seorang guru sejarah dan anggota serikat guru Prancis, SNALC, mengatakan diskursus nasional tentang bagaimana mencegah tindak kriminal atau terorisme di kalangan remaja saat ini sudah terlambat. "Banyak guru mengkhawatirkan serangan baru,” kata pria berusia 53 tahun itu kepada DW.
"Pemerintah harus fokus pada pengendalian yang lebih baik terhadap akses jejaring sosial, memberikan kami dukungan yang diperlukan untuk mengkampanyekan sekularisme, yang ditolak oleh sejumlah siswa, dan mengamankan sekolah secara memadai untuk mencegah penyerang masuk,” tambah Dargent.
Paul Renault, seorang remaja berusia 18 tahun dan anggota organisasi mahasiswa, FIDL, mengamini pendapat tersebut. "Banyak siswa yang takut,” kata dia kepada DW. "Persidangan ini seharusnya menjadi kesempatan untuk menggencarkan debat publik tentang bagaimana menjamin keamanan di sekolah. Namun, hal ini tidak terjadi,” tambahnya.
Le Roy masih berpendapat bahwa kasus di pengadilan bisa menjadi efek jera – jika ada putusan bersalah.
"Hal ini menunjukkan bahwa sistem peradilan kita membela nilai-nilai dasar demokrasi, dan pihak yang terlibat tidak bisa lepas begitu saja,” katanya. rzn/hp
Jangan lewatkan konten-konten eksklusif yang akan kami pilih setiap Rabu untuk kamu. Kirimkan e-mail kamu untuk berlangganan Newsletter mingguan Wednesday Bite.